Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 58 of 64
President Trump Will Make America Great Again, Our country Is Been flooded with Millions of Illegal immigrants and Businesses Have been Going to other Countries For Many Years now President Trump Tariff Will Make Hundreds …
President Trump Will Make America Great Again, Our country Is Been flooded with Millions of Illegal immigrants and Businesses Have been Going to other Countries For Many Years now President Trump Tariff Will Make Hundreds of thousands of Companies To come Back to the United states
Focuses on economic impacts of immigration and tariffs bringing companies back, with underlying anxiety about demographic change.
@Elgringo521 Mar 4, 2025
Prices will go sky high now in america and people will suffer the got want now with trump.?
Prices will go sky high now in america and people will suffer the got want now with trump.?
Predicts economic hardship (price increases) and suffering under Trump, framing concern in economic terms.
@michaelcoady828 Mar 4, 2025
The way things are we essentially give away 250 billion to Canada. Stop crying.
The way things are we essentially give away 250 billion to Canada. Stop crying.
References financial transfers (250 billion) and dismisses complaints, framing discussion in economic terms.
@sbncaptain8209 Mar 4, 2025
actually poop eating people is much better to people who blow themselves with bombs. canada needs people and Canadians don't want to have children the government have no choice but to allowed migration
actually poop eating people is much better to people who blow themselves with bombs. canada needs people and Canadians don't want to have children the government have no choice but to allowed migration
Argues that Canada needs immigration due to low birth rates and labor demands, using crude comparative framing to justify policy.
paulgomez381 Jan 29, 2026
Canadian must be greatful that Indians R in Canada...for the Canadian Economie...
Canadian must be greatful that Indians R in Canada...for the Canadian Economie...
Argues that Indian immigrants contribute economically to Canada, framing immigration as economically beneficial.
anilchopra4901 Jan 29, 2026
Integration ya not. It’s about money to be removed from Canada back to India, China, etc….
Integration ya not. It’s about money to be removed from Canada back to India, China, etc….
Claims immigrants extract wealth from Canada to send to India and China without substantiation, mixing economic concern with unverified assertion.
OlDee-w4k Jan 28, 2026
Canada has such a small population especially compared their less friendly neighbors to the south. Hope they figure out how to retain the skilled people they need to grow strong enough to fend off any …
Canada has such a small population especially compared their less friendly neighbors to the south. Hope they figure out how to retain the skilled people they need to grow strong enough to fend off any threats.
Discusses Canada's population size and need for skilled workers to maintain economic strength relative to neighboring countries.
omghowcueify Feb 24, 2026
OH HOG WASH AND CANADA HAS BEEN TAKING ADVANTAGE OF AMERICA FOR MANY YEARS NOW, WE ARE NOT SCARED
OH HOG WASH AND CANADA HAS BEEN TAKING ADVANTAGE OF AMERICA FOR MANY YEARS NOW, WE ARE NOT SCARED
Claims Canada has exploited America economically and dismisses threat concerns, framed as economic grievance.
@kennethjohnson347 Mar 4, 2025
Dark times are here for working people in all countries facing these tariffs more is going on than what we see.
Dark times are here for working people in all countries facing these tariffs more is going on than what we see.
The comment discusses economic impacts of tariffs on working people across countries, expressing concern about broader economic consequences.
@davetomlinson9063 Mar 4, 2025
So you tell me, a 5th Generation Canadian, Laid Oil Oil & Gas Alberta GAL never to get work in Calgary again; how Truedodo Bird/Carney Capone's Immigrants today BENEFIT CANADA WHEN...."Filipinos in Canada send approximately …
So you tell me, a 5th Generation Canadian, Laid Oil Oil & Gas Alberta GAL never to get work in Calgary again; how Truedodo Bird/Carney Capone's Immigrants today BENEFIT CANADA WHEN...."Filipinos in Canada send approximately $1 billion to $1.2 billion CAD annually in remittances to the Philippines. This amount remained stable even during COVID-19 pandemic, with about $1.079 billion sent between January and October 2020."
Combines personal job loss narrative with selective statistics about remittances to argue immigrants don't benefit Canada economically.
JoeyMontana-s9w Feb 17, 2026
America got one big madness President at the White House. We believe he already open the Bank of America to receive 25 percent from Canada ?? , 25 percent from Mexico ?? and another 10 …
America got one big madness President at the White House. We believe he already open the Bank of America to receive 25 percent from Canada ?? , 25 percent from Mexico ?? and another 10 percent from China ??. These tariffs (taxes) are for US government work? Trump is that Federal government himself. Gurrentee the prices will go up .Trump does care about the poor but himself. This is very bad for partnership with Canada? Trau speak the truth
Focuses on tariffs, taxes, and economic impact on prices and the poor, with criticism of Trump's policies.
@PaulXiong-q4r Mar 4, 2025
Ha. What he wants is very cheap immigrant labor
Ha. What he wants is very cheap immigrant labor
Uses sarcastic tone to critique employer motivations for immigration, suggesting exploitation of cheap labor as the underlying economic driver.
Jm-Gonz Feb 11, 2026
USA is a consumer society. If USA wants to bring the deficit down then it should consume less. By the way following are the deficits US have by each country in order. Why trymp is …
USA is a consumer society. If USA wants to bring the deficit down then it should consume less. By the way following are the deficits US have by each country in order. Why trymp is not targeting Vietnam, Germany Ireland Japan or South Korea? \n \nChina $295.35 B \nMexico $171.86 B \nVietnam $129.38 B \nGermany $88.01 B \nIreland $87.23 B \nJapan $72.35 B \nSouth Korea $69.92 B \n \nCanada has $63.3 B trade deficit and mainly due to oil demands in US. All US has to do was to buy less oil from Canada and it would have worked out. US coming after Canada and putting an economic war because it want to acquire Canada. He is learning land grabbing from his friends, you know who is grabbing land in world from sovereign countries. \n \nThis may be the last election US had.
Analyzes trade deficits with specific statistics and comparative data across countries, though includes conspiratorial framing about US intentions.
@simsandhu2008 Mar 4, 2025
Let's raise our wages to where they should be or at least back to 2005 levels by doing a go fund me and buy khalistan over in India or wherever they want khalistan to be …
Let's raise our wages to where they should be or at least back to 2005 levels by doing a go fund me and buy khalistan over in India or wherever they want khalistan to be and once we export 4 or 5 million India's our employers will have no choice but to pay over 19 an hour to be a doctor and our kids will have summer jobs again. But no Tim's, eff Tim's they chose a side they are eliminated. It's back to country style donuts the way it should have gone!
Argues that immigration suppresses wages and proposes exporting immigrants to raise labor costs, framing immigration as an economic problem.
CarsonBrandon-m9l Jan 28, 2026
Pay your fair share
Pay your fair share
Calls for equitable tax contribution, framing fairness in economic terms.
@mccachl1 Mar 4, 2025
America is bankrupt and will continue...
America is bankrupt and will continue...
Makes a claim about America's economic status and trajectory, comparing nations implicitly.
@SMFJose Mar 4, 2025
I guess made in the USA cost more in Canada. \n\nThank you Governor Tee
I guess made in the USA cost more in Canada. \n\nThank you Governor Tee
Discusses pricing differences between US and Canada, attributing higher costs to tariffs or trade policy.
@joep5885 Mar 4, 2025
they should've deported all these visa student immigrants...over 5million of them and 0 went to school!!! then on top of it people are making the same money from 10 years ago while the cost of …
they should've deported all these visa student immigrants...over 5million of them and 0 went to school!!! then on top of it people are making the same money from 10 years ago while the cost of living goes up and up and up they mock us because we don't want to have children because we simply cannot afford 2-3k childcare while making 3.5k/month after taxes and rent at 3k/month while they come here have a free house, free money, pop out kids like crazy because the government will pay for the extra kids shit...highschool kids cant even get a job these days...the jobs that used to be for kids like tim hortons mcdonalds etc...are literally taken by immigrants as full blown jobs then there's not even enough jobs for the people here and employers are paying less and less and if you don't like it move along there's 100 illegal immigrants on student visas behind you waiting for that job when they should've been out of this country already!! Vancouver full of crackheads on fentanyl...Toronto full of heroin addicts walking around like zombies truck drivers buying cdl's from vending machines... icing on the cake was a crackhead doing heroin on a bench in broad daylight right on king st w. we're talking about a main street not a slow street or a side street where nobody sees shit...its fucking KING AND PETER!! I got so pissed off I tried to confront the dude but he was so out of it he couldn't even function... now we're talking about a crackhead that if he opens his eyes and he's flipping out and sees you as the cookie monster he'll fucking stab you with a needle what if it has hiv? or some other messed up disease? what if its a kid? WHAT IF IT'S YOU? what will it take for people to finally care about the issues in the community?!? crackhead immigrant? deported... cdl's? 10mil government trust fund to either run your own truck or to open a company...this would end all of these bankruptcy runaways whenever shit happens... student WORK visas? revoke them all...if they can't afford to pay for their international studies they have no business being an international student... first you study...get your degree once COMPLETED if you want to come back because you liked Canada apply from OUTSIDE Canada for a visa/pr. we don't need people working 10 years saving up to study living in a condo bedroom like 6 people in there driving up the cost of living for everyone else then fucking off when shit gets tough...
Extended critique mixing unverified claims about visa students and government benefits with economic grievances about wages, housing, and job availability.
TiredOfY Aug 25, 2025
224 a day thats what we get ?????????
224 a day thats what we get ?????????
Comment expresses concern about low financial support ($224/day), combining economic critique with implicit questioning of adequacy.
deuce527 Feb 14, 2026
White peole think they are too good to work at timhortons. Literally brown ones are the inky ones who want to work there. And on top of that they’ll be working two jobs at a …
White peole think they are too good to work at timhortons. Literally brown ones are the inky ones who want to work there. And on top of that they’ll be working two jobs at a time. Keep the people who work and pay taxes get rid of all those who don’t (homeless drug addicts)
Contrasts work ethic and tax contribution between groups, framed around economic participation and labor market dynamics.
mikefryer5183 Jan 27, 2026
« Prev 58 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)