Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 49 of 64
Eye for an eye, it makes sense. You are correct, we the people will pay for this 25% increase. This how America will be worse again by putting more people in deeper debt and poverty.
Eye for an eye, it makes sense. You are correct, we the people will pay for this 25% increase. This how America will be worse again by putting more people in deeper debt and poverty.
Discusses economic consequences of tariffs (25% increase, debt, poverty) while expressing concern about negative impacts on Americans.
@rm26367 Mar 4, 2025
There are winners in a trade war, the country the can stand the most will win.
There are winners in a trade war, the country the can stand the most will win.
Discusses trade war dynamics and economic competition between nations in terms of resilience and winning.
@RenardGarland Mar 4, 2025
It's gonna hurt all of us. : ( The economy was coming back around since Covid. By the end of 2024, I felt it and was feeling optimistic I can't believe this is happening now. …
It's gonna hurt all of us. : ( The economy was coming back around since Covid. By the end of 2024, I felt it and was feeling optimistic I can't believe this is happening now. Ugh.
Expresses concern about economic harm and loss of optimism regarding economic recovery.
@iluvchocolate1322 Mar 4, 2025
When I studied economics years ago were studied trade, tariffs and isolationism. Trade always came out on top in our simulation models. I don't like Trudeau but he is right here and articulate.
When I studied economics years ago were studied trade, tariffs and isolationism. Trade always came out on top in our simulation models. I don't like Trudeau but he is right here and articulate.
Draws on economic education and trade theory to support a policy position on tariffs and isolationism, while acknowledging the speaker's correctness despite personal political disagreement.
@Unitedflyier Mar 4, 2025
Waiting for him to tell the American ppl how their going to make up the 180 billion trade deficit. all the Americans in here dumping on America just remember your the one being taking advantage …
Waiting for him to tell the American ppl how their going to make up the 180 billion trade deficit. all the Americans in here dumping on America just remember your the one being taking advantage of
Focuses on trade deficits and economic disadvantage, comparing the US position unfavorably to others.
@MH-in5gl Mar 4, 2025
Trump is trying to end a war it’s not the same thing. We don’t need Canada if you haven’t been to America then you don’t know. We can make whatever you can make and better …
Trump is trying to end a war it’s not the same thing. We don’t need Canada if you haven’t been to America then you don’t know. We can make whatever you can make and better we can grow anything and more then you can just bc of regional weather. Canada is mad bc they make a lot of money off of us and trump is changing America and getting what it’s worth. America always pays more for imports and exports , why? and yet with out American people buying y’all’s stuff you your government will fall gotta keep last and for most gotta keep Canadian politicians payed as far as I know y’all haven’t had to worry about prices in y’all’s country. For years we have been paying more for stuff that should be made here or we pay less. Plain and simple we are getting what we are worth take it or leave. It will be funny when he cuts all exports from Canada it will take a little bit but we will compensate ans there gonna with they just took the 25% little saying over here is you never know what you got till it’s gon.
Extended argument about trade imbalances, export/import pricing, and economic worth between the US and Canada, with comparative claims about production capacity.
@dababysymba8302 Mar 4, 2025
tRump and Elon are holding the country hostage and taking all it's wealth and the MAGAT's are cheering, soon they will pay more for groceries, gas, homes and just about everything. the stock market are …
tRump and Elon are holding the country hostage and taking all it's wealth and the MAGAT's are cheering, soon they will pay more for groceries, gas, homes and just about everything. the stock market are plummeting and they are cheering and loosing their jobs because of DOGe, Canada need to fight back (and we will) even harder and make the red states pay against their products and services and farmers, it's not against the american people but the illegal tariffs, stay strong ??
Discusses economic consequences of Trump/Elon policies (inflation, job losses, stock market) and calls for Canadian retaliatory tariffs.
@mtlHc Mar 4, 2025
Trump is going to screw up the economies all over the world and it’s not a good time for that
Trump is going to screw up the economies all over the world and it’s not a good time for that
Expresses concern about Trump's economic policies and their negative global impact, framed as an economic threat.
@BluesJames Mar 4, 2025
The clapping seals in here don't remember all the jobs that Americans lost to Canada. All the automotive jobs. Just look at Detroit. Thats because of Canduhduh.
The clapping seals in here don't remember all the jobs that Americans lost to Canada. All the automotive jobs. Just look at Detroit. Thats because of Canduhduh.
Argues that Canada caused American job losses in automotive sector, with dismissive tone toward Canadian supporters.
@jakewinternheimer7297 Mar 4, 2025
The clapping seals in here don't remember all the jobs that Americans lost to Canada. All the automotive jobs. Just look at Detroit. Thats because of Canduhduh.
The clapping seals in here don't remember all the jobs that Americans lost to Canada. All the automotive jobs. Just look at Detroit. Thats because of Canduhduh.
Duplicate of previous comment: argues Canada caused American job losses in automotive sector.
@jakewinternheimer7297 Mar 4, 2025
Something had to be done to bring production back to US. And this is it.
Something had to be done to bring production back to US. And this is it.
Justifies trade policy based on economic rationale of restoring domestic production and manufacturing.
@markpowder4664 Mar 4, 2025
this is going to destroy US industry
this is going to destroy US industry
Asserts that tariffs will damage U.S. industrial capacity, framing the issue in economic terms.
@andyf4292 Mar 4, 2025
How much tariffs do you owe us already.. All these countries has charged us and yet do not pay us.
How much tariffs do you owe us already.. All these countries has charged us and yet do not pay us.
Raises concerns about tariffs and trade imbalances between countries, framed as an economic grievance.
@judynunley4194 Mar 4, 2025
United States never needed Canada to survive The US has been getting reamed by Canada and other Countries way too long. If this means our jobs come callback home, then so be it. We are …
United States never needed Canada to survive The US has been getting reamed by Canada and other Countries way too long. If this means our jobs come callback home, then so be it. We are no longer going to pay out more than we are given. US first.....
Argues that US trade relationships are economically unfavorable and prioritizes domestic job creation and national interest.
@ReginaldScottRoss Mar 4, 2025
Canada will grow stronger, they will soon take more advantage of their resources and open up to new markets, Canada will be more independent and their gain will be USA loss.
Canada will grow stronger, they will soon take more advantage of their resources and open up to new markets, Canada will be more independent and their gain will be USA loss.
Discusses Canada's economic independence, resource development, and competitive advantage relative to the US.
@queretaromexico Mar 4, 2025
Trade war with the US is never a good idea. Having being puppet state all this years depending on the fresh milk from the UNITED STATES UDDER for survival
Trade war with the US is never a good idea. Having being puppet state all this years depending on the fresh milk from the UNITED STATES UDDER for survival
Argues against trade war with the US based on economic dependency and comparative disadvantage for Canada.
@imadiyijulius5400 Mar 4, 2025
Canada’s economy will tank than we will make them our 51st great idea trump you should ask what would you like for us to do president Trump. We fund your military and your economy. Your …
Canada’s economy will tank than we will make them our 51st great idea trump you should ask what would you like for us to do president Trump. We fund your military and your economy. Your ass is ours
Discusses economic consequences (tanking economy) and financial relationships between Canada and the US.
@ChildOfTheTrueOneKing Mar 4, 2025
Canada is our largest supplier of fertilizer which is needed for food production. We could starve from Trump's actions
Canada is our largest supplier of fertilizer which is needed for food production. We could starve from Trump's actions
Discusses economic interdependence and food security implications of trade disruption.
@Katnyannyan Mar 4, 2025
For all the American's siding with Canada. Did you know Canada has never fulfilled its obligation to Nato. they only pay 1% of its gdp. They are supposed to pat 2%. The united States has …
For all the American's siding with Canada. Did you know Canada has never fulfilled its obligation to Nato. they only pay 1% of its gdp. They are supposed to pat 2%. The united States has been carrying the water for Canada and other countries so they can flaunt social programs like universal healthcare. If they paid their fair share for defense they would not be able to afford it. Its about time these countries start paying the United states back. Since Canada became a member of Nato in 1949 they have never fulfilled their payment obligation, but enjoyed the security of being a member. America pays 4.5% and some other years 6% of our gdp to NATO. with out the US there is no NATO. Maybe Canada should take over for the US. Like that will happen. If Canada was the 51st state they would be the 4th poorest state. Not trying to be mean this is just reality. The dictator of Canada has never cared about his people, or he would have simply secured your damn border. https://www.forcesnews.com/news/world/nato-which-countries-pay-their-share-defence
Argues that Canada's social programs are subsidized by US defense spending and NATO contributions, with specific (disputed) claims about NATO payment obligations and GDP percentages.
@MLR-y7e Mar 4, 2025
What Trump seems to try to get at most is the unfair act of the USMCA. Most trades benefited Canada, while Canada refused to provide the same fair trades. Sometimes Trump does say things that …
What Trump seems to try to get at most is the unfair act of the USMCA. Most trades benefited Canada, while Canada refused to provide the same fair trades. Sometimes Trump does say things that may have gone off track like fentyl handling on Canada's end and border handling. It seems like our borders at the time were less strict on the American side versus the Canadian side of the border. Trump did state multiple times that most countries like Canada were unfair to USA. Even with the USMCA, America got screwed by Mexico as will. America has been there helping and supporting and submitting to every country. Yet failed to support our own people when we need it, especially to clear up our own debts. Sadly, America is falling behind due to poor handling of Government Democrat corruption. I am neutral as both parties don't always provide the best solution for everyone. You have to pick who can help the American people. Seeing how corrupt the Democrats has ran America and the defacto behind of all the wars and money laundering has surprised me, and I hope the change with Trump will help everyone realize how screwed we all are in correcting those corruption that isn't really needed.
Analyzes trade imbalances under USMCA, border economics, and argues that Canada benefited unfairly while America fell behind economically.
@peterher8179 Mar 4, 2025
« Prev 49 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)