Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 40 of 64
Those Sun chips are a luxury. You want to afford chips? You gotta buy the Great Value 😒
Those Sun chips are a luxury. You want to afford chips? You gotta buy the Great Value 😒
Comments on affordability and consumer purchasing power in the context of economic hardship.
drest5316 Aug 27, 2025
Canada is our largest supplier of fertilizer which is needed for food production. We could starve from Trump's actions
Canada is our largest supplier of fertilizer which is needed for food production. We could starve from Trump's actions
Discusses economic interdependence and food security implications of trade disruption.
@Katnyannyan Mar 4, 2025
Omg Bravo to that first woman!! We have to do something Canada!! The young lady that spoke brought me tears. How can the young people have families??? They can't afford to look after themselves let …
Omg Bravo to that first woman!! We have to do something Canada!! The young lady that spoke brought me tears. How can the young people have families??? They can't afford to look after themselves let alone a family. So so sad and scary. Omg, so many good points!! Canadians we have to stand up and say something!!! Trudeau ruined this country and now Carney is going to make it much worse!!!
Focuses on housing affordability and economic hardship for young people, with emotional appeals and calls for action.
portugualinmyheart6164 Aug 27, 2025
Canada a great decline just like Argentina. No products processed, Locked natural resources & too much borrowing. The deceit & greed is from the bottom to the top.
Canada a great decline just like Argentina. No products processed, Locked natural resources & too much borrowing. The deceit & greed is from the bottom to the top.
Compares Canada to Argentina's decline, citing economic mismanagement, resource underutilization, and debt as causes.
BrendaMcLaughlin-xe5dj Feb 19, 2026
pretty wild how basic cable is a luxury honestly. Ive had it for a few months when my and my g/f moved to our very first apartment like 15-20 years ago and its been outa …
pretty wild how basic cable is a luxury honestly. Ive had it for a few months when my and my g/f moved to our very first apartment like 15-20 years ago and its been outa the budget ever since. Used to be in every middle class home across Canada
Combines personal experience with broader economic commentary about declining middle-class affordability and cost of living in Canada.
macrostiffproductions2978 Aug 26, 2025
No doubt about it, Canada is for Canadians. If you wanted to, you could deport millions of immigrants, but let's be real about the cost. The Canadian economy, its pensions, its farms, and its health …
No doubt about it, Canada is for Canadians. If you wanted to, you could deport millions of immigrants, but let's be real about the cost. The Canadian economy, its pensions, its farms, and its health sector all rely on immigrants to pay taxes and fill jobs. It's not some big conspiracy about population replacement; it's just about the economy. You can't have one without the other. Canadians aren't the only ones dealing with this. In Asia and Africa, it's a different kind of immigrant, the ones with money who buy up land and property, driving locals out of the market. They're not given an ear either, because money talks. It’s always been about the money and the power, and Canadians should understand that perspective too. The culture or religion of a few bad apples shouldn’t be used to tarnish every immigrant. We do need to do a better job screening people, but it’s not fair to paint everyone with the same brush. In the U.S., Indian immigrants are top earners and incredibly successful, but people still complain that they’re "taking their jobs." So, if an Indian person is a failure, they're a problem. If they're a success, they're still a problem. They can't win. This old colonial mindset is alive and well. It's tough for some people to process that a person of color can outsmart them and rise up by their own bootstrap. But when those same folks go to Asia or Africa, suddenly they feel that old nostalgia and are much more comfortable with the social hierarchy there. It would be ideal if no one had to leave their home country for a better life. When we have more justice in the world for everyone, maybe we won't have to keep having these conversations.
Primarily argues that immigrants are economically necessary for Canada's economy, pensions, farms, and health sector, while also addressing moral fairness and comparing to other countries.
zuckthebetacuck2789 Aug 26, 2025
To all the Trumpers; you voted for this. Higher prices for most goods and some services.
To all the Trumpers; you voted for this. Higher prices for most goods and some services.
Attributes higher consumer prices to Trump voters' electoral choice, framing economic consequences as direct result of their decision.
@chrisboncamper4282 Mar 4, 2025
They made it so we can't have kids, then the gov subsidizes CORPSorations with our money so that CANADIANS don't get hired. D E P O R T. Enough is enough. I know many LEGAL …
They made it so we can't have kids, then the gov subsidizes CORPSorations with our money so that CANADIANS don't get hired. D E P O R T. Enough is enough. I know many LEGAL immigrants, friends, who get the concept of assimilation and why. I'd NEVER go to another country and expect special treatment or rights. This isn't going to end well.
Focuses on economic grievances (hiring, subsidies, cost of living) while invoking assimilation expectations and deportation demands.
cubabound2049 Aug 25, 2025
YOUR LIFE STYLE IS MORE EXPENSIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU MUST PARTY, YOU MUST TRAVEL, YOU MUST GO ON VACATION, YOU MUST HAVE HUNDRED OF TATOOS THAT COST SO MUCH!!!! YOU MUST ALWAYS BUY NEW CLOTHES, NEW MODELS, …
YOUR LIFE STYLE IS MORE EXPENSIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU MUST PARTY, YOU MUST TRAVEL, YOU MUST GO ON VACATION, YOU MUST HAVE HUNDRED OF TATOOS THAT COST SO MUCH!!!! YOU MUST ALWAYS BUY NEW CLOTHES, NEW MODELS, NEW MANICURE PEDICURE, NEW HAIR CUTS, NEW CELL PHONE EVERY SEASON, NEW CAR, NEW THIS NEW THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU LIFE STYLE IS HOLDING YOU BACK, NOT THE IMMIGRANTS, THE IMMIGRANTS SPENT LESS AND HIDE THEIR MONEY!!!!!!!!MOST OF THE IMMIGRANT UNDERSTAND AND KNOW HOW TO CALCULATE THEIR MONTHLLYY MONEY!!!!!!!!! WHILE SOME CANADIANS WHO GREW UP AS A MIDDEL CLASS, ALL WHAT THEY KNOW IS SPENDING!!! AND ESPECIALLY WHEN SOME ONE LOVE PARTYING ALCOHOLE SMOKING AND THE LEGALIZED WEED, KEEPS YOUR MIND IN A TOO RELAXING MOTION NO MOTION YOU ARE MUTE FOR MONTHS TILL YOU LOSE YOU JOB!!!!THAN YOU GO CRY TO MOMY AND DADY!!!!!!!!! MOST OF IMMIGRANT COME FROM POOR COUNTRIES AND HARD LIFE THOUGH THEM THE VALUE OF THE PENNY!!!!!!!! I WAS MARRIED TO A CANADIAN HUSBAND, NO MATTER HOW MUCH HE MAKE MONTHLY, SINCE HE WAS WORKING IN SALES, HE WILL ALWAYS ALWAYS FIND A SPENDING AVENUE!! WE WERE SUPPOSED TO PUT MONEY ASSIDE FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR CHILDREN!!! HE WILL ALWYAS ALWAYS ALWAYS FIND A WAITING DEEP HOLE TO PLACE THEM IN!!!!!!!! HI LIFE WAS VERY VERY EROGANT!!!!!!!!!BUYING NEW CLOTHING TODAY, YOU WILL FIND THEM TRAINNING ON THE GROUND!!!EVEN MY SON WAS 7 YEARS OLD AT THE TIME, HE TOLD ME MOM THE TIE YOU BOUGHT MY DAD RECENTLY IS ON THE GROUND!!!!!!THAT SPEAK FOR ALL HIS CLOTHING!!!! HIS MOM WAS THE MAN OF THE HOUSE HE USED SAY WHEN HE WAKES UP IN THE MORNING WHEN HE WAS YOUNGER, HE WILL FIND HIS MOM PICKED UP HIS DIRTY CLOTHES AND PLACE THE FRESHLY WASHED CLOTHING BESIDE HIS BED!!!! SOME PARENT DID TOO MUCH FOR THEIR CHILDREN,, AND THESE KIDS GROW UP TO BE LESS MOTIVATED, FOR WHAT THEY GOT EVERYTHING WHEN THEY GREW UP,!!!! AND THE POOR DIDN'T HAVE THAT SO THEY WORK HARD TO HAVE THAT WHAT WAS MISSING IN HIS CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH!!!!!!!!
Argues that Canadians' expensive lifestyles and poor financial discipline, not immigrants, are the real economic problem; contrasts immigrant frugality with Canadian spending habits.
mahboubaattafi Aug 25, 2025
We are losing entrepreneurship. Government restrictions and the lack of building. They just keep bringing in people to raise the population. All these new people who don't want to contribute and just live in the …
We are losing entrepreneurship. Government restrictions and the lack of building. They just keep bringing in people to raise the population. All these new people who don't want to contribute and just live in the system. To many, to fast
Argues that immigration policy prioritizes population growth over entrepreneurship and economic contribution, with concerns about system dependency.
Tbone1492 Aug 25, 2025
Liberals are using immigration to build up voters hence why the give these people better living conditions than Canadians, give businesses incentives to hire them over Canadian born and even give them better and faster …
Liberals are using immigration to build up voters hence why the give these people better living conditions than Canadians, give businesses incentives to hire them over Canadian born and even give them better and faster healthcare while the tax payer dies waiting to get life threatening surgeries.
Argues that immigration policy creates economic disadvantage for Canadian citizens through preferential treatment and resource allocation.
TL3000TL Feb 27, 2026
4 HOURS LATER.... our stocks have gone through the roof!
4 HOURS LATER.... our stocks have gone through the roof!
References stock market performance as evidence of economic impact, suggesting positive economic outcomes from recent political events.
@Stefano10ace-e9l Mar 4, 2025
With all the tax that our people pay thats why can't afford to have kids then bring illegals to have all the kids and pay them for it no wonder we not having kids.
With all the tax that our people pay thats why can't afford to have kids then bring illegals to have all the kids and pay them for it no wonder we not having kids.
Argues that tax resources spent on immigrants prevent Canadians from affording children, framing immigration as an economic burden and demographic threat.
montahakarbarani948 Aug 25, 2025
Most of the immigrants landing here in Canada are not boosting our economy but just becoming a liability taking the country backward rather than progress. Tye government should stop immigration including refugees, at least for …
Most of the immigrants landing here in Canada are not boosting our economy but just becoming a liability taking the country backward rather than progress. Tye government should stop immigration including refugees, at least for a while. Not that I don’t want to help these people but we just dont have the resources for now to accommodate them. ‘m shocked to hear that 817,000 people landed in Canada. Add three zeros to it because these people pay at least a $1000 as administrative fee to government IRCC. So that is $817,000,000 Canadian Dollars. Close to a Billion. What is government doing with this money? No Government, we Canadians dont want that money in our GDP. He has enough natural resources that can sustain ourself. Stop selling cheap oil to US. And back to people who come here as immigrants. You are in a different country to have a new life. There is no point in protecting here in Canada about the things happening in your home country. Have some common sense. It’s just an other news for media. When you do such things, Canadian resource are wasted like cops have to make sure the protest goes peacefully and many more. People who are not part of it are getting affected. And to all immigrants please please please, speak in english. I know that you all are comfortable speaking in your native language. Speak that at your private place. Not in public place or work place. That is basic manners. Dont speak out loud in phone in public places. It’s not manners. Funny that people are asking to change the classes taught in French😂 This proves that they are not students but in disguise, as students. Here in Canada, to loot Canada and weaken the country. If you want class in english in a french speaking province better move out of Quebec.
Extended critique arguing immigrants are economic liabilities, calls for immigration pause, questions government spending, and expresses resource scarcity concerns.
nibinaugustin Aug 25, 2025
Illegal immigrants have better health care services than my 90 year old mom who paid taxes most of her life. 6 million Canadians without a family GP.
Illegal immigrants have better health care services than my 90 year old mom who paid taxes most of her life. 6 million Canadians without a family GP.
Compares resource allocation and healthcare access between immigrants and Canadian citizens, framing as unfair distribution of public services.
wallybartfay56 Feb 24, 2026
7500 a month for immigrants. How much do canadians on welfare get. TELL ME.
7500 a month for immigrants. How much do canadians on welfare get. TELL ME.
Compares welfare benefits for immigrants versus Canadian citizens, implying unfair economic disparity through rhetorical questioning.
Johnrider1234 Feb 27, 2026
Well managed? it costed us over 200 billions in taxes and only made life more costly! It also did put great stress upon the very same institutions our elites told us they the immigrants would …
Well managed? it costed us over 200 billions in taxes and only made life more costly! It also did put great stress upon the very same institutions our elites told us they the immigrants would work for
Critiques immigration policy's economic impact, citing high costs and increased living expenses, while questioning institutional capacity claims.
Vilhjalm-l9o Jun 21, 2025
What about old people brought here, never worked one hour in Canada, but receive pension, medical and dental benefits, or stay on welfare?? What about emigration business that evolved in BC like mushrooms after rain?? …
What about old people brought here, never worked one hour in Canada, but receive pension, medical and dental benefits, or stay on welfare?? What about emigration business that evolved in BC like mushrooms after rain?? Who's paying for this category of emigrants??
Questions about fiscal costs of immigration benefits and welfare, framed as economic concern about who pays.
romedison Feb 17, 2026
American trade imbalance needs to change. Sorry Trudeau
American trade imbalance needs to change. Sorry Trudeau
Discussion of trade imbalance as an economic issue requiring policy change, directed at the Prime Minister.
@Joe_Biden_is_Trash Mar 4, 2025
Looks like I'll be buying European or Chinese
Looks like I'll be buying European or Chinese
References consumer purchasing decisions in response to political/trade concerns, engaging with economic consequences.
@MarioMancinelli82 Mar 4, 2025
« Prev 40 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)