Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 35 of 64
Americans will now stop buying Canadian Goods because there is already pressure on groceries, also, products from countries like Australia and Europe will now come flooding into the USA.
Americans will now stop buying Canadian Goods because there is already pressure on groceries, also, products from countries like Australia and Europe will now come flooding into the USA.
Predicts economic consequences of trade tensions including consumer pressure and market shifts between countries.
@bigwickcrypto Mar 4, 2025
Perhaps it is time for USA citizens to sell their Canadian residential real estate.
Perhaps it is time for USA citizens to sell their Canadian residential real estate.
Suggests real estate divestment strategy based on economic/political concerns about US-Canada relations.
@louisemason2918 Mar 4, 2025
Is this guy for real? Doesn't he realize that we don't need Canadian food or Canadian steel or Canadian oil? We do that s*** to help you. We can produce all the natural resources we …
Is this guy for real? Doesn't he realize that we don't need Canadian food or Canadian steel or Canadian oil? We do that s*** to help you. We can produce all the natural resources we need right here, we don't have to import them.
Questions Canada's economic necessity while asserting U.S. self-sufficiency and framing trade as aid.
@stevewarshaw6495 Mar 4, 2025
Products need to be made in CANADA! Please start up factories and farming across Canada for all products. Excuse me…smart is not the word I would use
Products need to be made in CANADA! Please start up factories and farming across Canada for all products. Excuse me…smart is not the word I would use
Advocates for domestic manufacturing and agricultural production as economic policy, with implicit criticism of current approach.
@cathylaycock5598 Mar 4, 2025
PAY UP.. EVERYONE GETS MAD WHEN THEY HAVE TO PAY.. FAIR TRADE.
PAY UP.. EVERYONE GETS MAD WHEN THEY HAVE TO PAY.. FAIR TRADE.
Comment frames financial obligations as fair trade and addresses economic burden-sharing between nations.
@mryo3223 Mar 4, 2025
Trudeau thinks Canada can survive a trade war? ???. Canada doesn't have anything that the US can't get for itself. Unless they want to start selling snow to the southern states. We help them by …
Trudeau thinks Canada can survive a trade war? ???. Canada doesn't have anything that the US can't get for itself. Unless they want to start selling snow to the southern states. We help them by buying their crap. We dont need it like Canada needs us. We subsidize their economy in more ways than one. And Trudeau is willing to learn that the hard way it looks like.\n\nOh well, Gues Canada Wont have much of a choice but to become the 51st state
Argues Canada's economic dependence on the US and vulnerability in trade war, with implicit threat of absorption.
@boostinman7132 Mar 4, 2025
Liberals are using immigration to build up voters hence why the give these people better living conditions than Canadians, give businesses incentives to hire them over Canadian born and even give them better and faster …
Liberals are using immigration to build up voters hence why the give these people better living conditions than Canadians, give businesses incentives to hire them over Canadian born and even give them better and faster healthcare while the tax payer dies waiting to get life threatening surgeries.
Argues that immigration policy creates economic disadvantage for Canadian citizens through preferential treatment and resource allocation.
TL3000TL Feb 27, 2026
YOUR LIFE STYLE IS MORE EXPENSIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU MUST PARTY, YOU MUST TRAVEL, YOU MUST GO ON VACATION, YOU MUST HAVE HUNDRED OF TATOOS THAT COST SO MUCH!!!! YOU MUST ALWAYS BUY NEW CLOTHES, NEW MODELS, …
YOUR LIFE STYLE IS MORE EXPENSIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU MUST PARTY, YOU MUST TRAVEL, YOU MUST GO ON VACATION, YOU MUST HAVE HUNDRED OF TATOOS THAT COST SO MUCH!!!! YOU MUST ALWAYS BUY NEW CLOTHES, NEW MODELS, NEW MANICURE PEDICURE, NEW HAIR CUTS, NEW CELL PHONE EVERY SEASON, NEW CAR, NEW THIS NEW THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU LIFE STYLE IS HOLDING YOU BACK, NOT THE IMMIGRANTS, THE IMMIGRANTS SPENT LESS AND HIDE THEIR MONEY!!!!!!!!MOST OF THE IMMIGRANT UNDERSTAND AND KNOW HOW TO CALCULATE THEIR MONTHLLYY MONEY!!!!!!!!! WHILE SOME CANADIANS WHO GREW UP AS A MIDDEL CLASS, ALL WHAT THEY KNOW IS SPENDING!!! AND ESPECIALLY WHEN SOME ONE LOVE PARTYING ALCOHOLE SMOKING AND THE LEGALIZED WEED, KEEPS YOUR MIND IN A TOO RELAXING MOTION NO MOTION YOU ARE MUTE FOR MONTHS TILL YOU LOSE YOU JOB!!!!THAN YOU GO CRY TO MOMY AND DADY!!!!!!!!! MOST OF IMMIGRANT COME FROM POOR COUNTRIES AND HARD LIFE THOUGH THEM THE VALUE OF THE PENNY!!!!!!!! I WAS MARRIED TO A CANADIAN HUSBAND, NO MATTER HOW MUCH HE MAKE MONTHLY, SINCE HE WAS WORKING IN SALES, HE WILL ALWAYS ALWAYS FIND A SPENDING AVENUE!! WE WERE SUPPOSED TO PUT MONEY ASSIDE FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR CHILDREN!!! HE WILL ALWYAS ALWAYS ALWAYS FIND A WAITING DEEP HOLE TO PLACE THEM IN!!!!!!!! HI LIFE WAS VERY VERY EROGANT!!!!!!!!!BUYING NEW CLOTHING TODAY, YOU WILL FIND THEM TRAINNING ON THE GROUND!!!EVEN MY SON WAS 7 YEARS OLD AT THE TIME, HE TOLD ME MOM THE TIE YOU BOUGHT MY DAD RECENTLY IS ON THE GROUND!!!!!!THAT SPEAK FOR ALL HIS CLOTHING!!!! HIS MOM WAS THE MAN OF THE HOUSE HE USED SAY WHEN HE WAKES UP IN THE MORNING WHEN HE WAS YOUNGER, HE WILL FIND HIS MOM PICKED UP HIS DIRTY CLOTHES AND PLACE THE FRESHLY WASHED CLOTHING BESIDE HIS BED!!!! SOME PARENT DID TOO MUCH FOR THEIR CHILDREN,, AND THESE KIDS GROW UP TO BE LESS MOTIVATED, FOR WHAT THEY GOT EVERYTHING WHEN THEY GREW UP,!!!! AND THE POOR DIDN'T HAVE THAT SO THEY WORK HARD TO HAVE THAT WHAT WAS MISSING IN HIS CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH!!!!!!!!
Argues that Canadians' expensive lifestyles and poor financial discipline, not immigrants, are the real economic problem; contrasts immigrant frugality with Canadian spending habits.
mahboubaattafi Aug 25, 2025
Whatever. You’ll have to give in soon and accept all of the demands. Your economy can’t survive without ours. We can survive without yours.
Whatever. You’ll have to give in soon and accept all of the demands. Your economy can’t survive without ours. We can survive without yours.
Frames negotiation as economic leverage, asserting US economic dominance and Canada's dependence as basis for capitulation.
@percyramos1296 Mar 4, 2025
Inflation is to the roof, Make food and housing affordable, please people just help impeach him, he is golfing while the american people are struggling everyday.... He is just trying to pass stupid laws that …
Inflation is to the roof, Make food and housing affordable, please people just help impeach him, he is golfing while the american people are struggling everyday.... He is just trying to pass stupid laws that keep getting blocked by courts, Come on Trump supporters try helping fix it by calling your local office and impeach him, I bet anyone else is better than Trump, we know the country needs changes but we are still the biggest economy of the world the richest country, Why do we have to feel like is normal not to have affordable food and housing?? The basics of life... All the immigrants are gone, They even left by their own will, and Some Americans left to other countries, Mexico, Europe, Asia..... What do you guys want?? Having an empty country once was the biggest economy of the world?? Is just crazy even a blind person can see he is destroying the whole country..... He is not even a good business person we all know he didn't payed taxes, he went bankrupt so many times he knows how to scam people, Saying the USA government doesn't work because he feels like it, Just travel people so you can see the difference between usa government and other governments around the world........
Primarily focuses on inflation, housing, and food affordability as core economic grievances, with calls to action and international comparisons.
@KenRa469 Mar 4, 2025
Trudeau should be our next Prime Minister...!!! ?\nOur economies are so inter-twined because it WORKS! So many American companies have set-up plants in Canada in order to profit from doing business here. It's not just …
Trudeau should be our next Prime Minister...!!! ?\nOur economies are so inter-twined because it WORKS! So many American companies have set-up plants in Canada in order to profit from doing business here. It's not just products that we MUTUALLY benefit from selling to each other, the US generates significant profits from its many operations in Canada, and those $Billions of dollars in profits that go back to American Investors is not included in the 'Trade Imbalance' that is a justification for the tariffs. With those profits included, I'd bet Canada is the nation with the imbalance not in its favor...
Detailed economic analysis of US-Canada trade relationships, profits, and tariff justifications with data-driven critique.
@garymaclean6903 Mar 4, 2025
We are losing entrepreneurship. Government restrictions and the lack of building. They just keep bringing in people to raise the population. All these new people who don't want to contribute and just live in the …
We are losing entrepreneurship. Government restrictions and the lack of building. They just keep bringing in people to raise the population. All these new people who don't want to contribute and just live in the system. To many, to fast
Argues that immigration policy prioritizes population growth over entrepreneurship and economic contribution, with concerns about system dependency.
Tbone1492 Aug 25, 2025
How is it a trade war when all countries have the sovereign governments right to tax. Every country will ofcourse look for their own interest first. Looks like Canada is going to have a crash …
How is it a trade war when all countries have the sovereign governments right to tax. Every country will ofcourse look for their own interest first. Looks like Canada is going to have a crash landing economy.
Discusses trade policy, sovereign taxation rights, and predicts negative economic consequences for Canada.
@KevinBala-j2j Mar 4, 2025
We need to be asylum seekers in are our own Country from our own Hostel Government and Collect 7000 a month to live that's how expensive living is in Canada and what Canada give to …
We need to be asylum seekers in are our own Country from our own Hostel Government and Collect 7000 a month to live that's how expensive living is in Canada and what Canada give to the immigrants while the Government cuts our program to pay for the immigrants only giving us 1/3 the immigrants get Also when Quality of life is so low we cant afford to have children
Focuses on cost-of-living disparities, government spending allocation between citizens and immigrants, and inability to afford children due to economic conditions.
paulhoyle88TRUTH-or-LIE Sep 7, 2025
No matter how powerful the US economy is, its gonna crumble against tarrifs from all their western trading partners. Not the smartest move, Donny ?
No matter how powerful the US economy is, its gonna crumble against tarrifs from all their western trading partners. Not the smartest move, Donny ?
Critiques Trump's tariff strategy as economically self-defeating, using mild sarcasm ('Donny') to frame the argument.
@DaVe-is2xk Mar 4, 2025
There Canada pm. About happened after Ukraine we being suffer high tax high prices all teachers and medical don't extra play all grocery food price becoming more more higher now
There Canada pm. About happened after Ukraine we being suffer high tax high prices all teachers and medical don't extra play all grocery food price becoming more more higher now
Focuses on economic hardships including high taxes, prices, and cost of living increases attributed to government policy.
@viktoriyaivanovnaserebryak5781 Mar 4, 2025
This is even more of a reason why the United States should not be dependent on any country. We need to build in this country. We need to manufacture in this country, but all businesses …
This is even more of a reason why the United States should not be dependent on any country. We need to build in this country. We need to manufacture in this country, but all businesses take the shortcut and go where it's cheapest and in the long run. It cost us, but this is typical Americans. Short-term game, now it's catching up.
Argues for domestic manufacturing and self-sufficiency while critiquing American short-term economic thinking.
@bertram46 Mar 4, 2025
American trade imbalance needs to change. Sorry Trudeau
American trade imbalance needs to change. Sorry Trudeau
Discussion of trade imbalance as an economic issue requiring policy change, directed at the Prime Minister.
@Joe_Biden_is_Trash Mar 4, 2025
No its simple, you take as much as you sell. Simple financial mathmatics.\nIm sure the US can sustain not having canadian products.\nHere in the uk we dont want your goods if you dint buy ours.
No its simple, you take as much as you sell. Simple financial mathmatics.\nIm sure the US can sustain not having canadian products.\nHere in the uk we dont want your goods if you dint buy ours.
Discusses trade balance and economic sustainability using comparative framing between US, Canada, and UK trade relationships.
@68Red Mar 4, 2025
With all the tax that our people pay thats why can't afford to have kids then bring illegals to have all the kids and pay them for it no wonder we not having kids.
With all the tax that our people pay thats why can't afford to have kids then bring illegals to have all the kids and pay them for it no wonder we not having kids.
Argues that tax resources spent on immigrants prevent Canadians from affording children, framing immigration as an economic burden and demographic threat.
montahakarbarani948 Aug 25, 2025
« Prev 35 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)