Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Policy Critique

5,980 comments
Page 18 of 299
common sense, If an individual has been found to have a bogus claim, then deport them.
common sense, If an individual has been found to have a bogus claim, then deport them.
Advocates for deportation of individuals with rejected asylum claims as a straightforward policy position.
paulcollins7372 Feb 24, 2026
I'm canadian here in Canada - most of us despise trudeau and are struggling to survive under his high tax regime. We want trudeau to sit down and shut up and stop robbing us Canadians …
I'm canadian here in Canada - most of us despise trudeau and are struggling to survive under his high tax regime. We want trudeau to sit down and shut up and stop robbing us Canadians of a living and of our election. We have wanted an election for months now. He has denied us that.
Self-identified Canadian expressing criticism of Trudeau's tax policy, economic impact, and denial of elections.
@Wild_Vegan_Child Mar 4, 2025
This is a disaster of a video, poor and wrong info. Its a poorly made video. Quebec controls its own immigration, and it has different target amounts and is slight different from the rest of …
This is a disaster of a video, poor and wrong info. Its a poorly made video. Quebec controls its own immigration, and it has different target amounts and is slight different from the rest of Canada They don't explain that there are two different programs. one for students one for temporary workers (very new and is being phased out and going back to being a mostly agricultural temp worker program) and one for everyone else. the text showed said the girl is a temporary worker when they also said she came as a student and graduated, and was working after graduation as part of the permit. Also Quebec has its is own immigration programs that are slightly different from the rest of Canada
Detailed critique of video accuracy and policy explanation, pointing out omissions about Quebec's separate programs and permit categories.
zochbuppet448 Feb 11, 2026
Buying a weapon with intent to use it as a self defence device is Illegal in Canada, take the part out of the video where you said “I’m going to buy this knife for X …
Buying a weapon with intent to use it as a self defence device is Illegal in Canada, take the part out of the video where you said “I’m going to buy this knife for X reason” and it’s no longer illegal.
Comment provides legal analysis of Canadian weapons law and critiques the video's presentation of self-defense legality, engaging in policy discussion.
HOBOBIG Jan 28, 2026
There wasn't just the choice of more babies or more immigrants. There was a 3rd clear choice: less government. THAT was the correct course of action to reduce the cost of living and take the …
There wasn't just the choice of more babies or more immigrants. There was a 3rd clear choice: less government. THAT was the correct course of action to reduce the cost of living and take the tax boot off of peoples' throats so they can start families.
Argues for an alternative policy approach (reduced government) rather than immigration as a solution to demographic decline.
rafalklepinski7372 Sep 8, 2025
I love the direct democracy comparison because yeah, having a referendum on only issues that Mrs. Smith thinks are important makes you just like Switzerland! Why don't you have a referendum on your rate of …
I love the direct democracy comparison because yeah, having a referendum on only issues that Mrs. Smith thinks are important makes you just like Switzerland! Why don't you have a referendum on your rate of pay and the pension you will receive, as a politician, Mrs. Smith? How about you have a referendum about the US-style health insurance you want to introduce? Or how about you have a referendum on the style of democracy you have and ask people if they want a true direct-democracy and let them be able to have a vote on any issue or law, at any time? Yeah, I didn't think so...
Uses sarcasm and rhetorical questions to critique selective direct democracy implementation and politician self-interest in policy design.
@coolblue-198 Feb 20, 2026
OK people, remember the last 9 years. He is the same guy who has ruined the country. Go ahead vote Liberal and the lies and graft and waste continue. He is an actor playing his …
OK people, remember the last 9 years. He is the same guy who has ruined the country. Go ahead vote Liberal and the lies and graft and waste continue. He is an actor playing his role. No substance behind him. He is still the most hated and inefficient leader we have ever had.
Criticizes government leadership and policy record, with implicit call to vote differently.
@antonyacoboski7794 Mar 4, 2025
Thanks to J T 8 years as prime minister. We are suffering his mess he left here.
Thanks to J T 8 years as prime minister. We are suffering his mess he left here.
Blames the Prime Minister for current problems, critiquing his governance and legacy.
GbotoesNet Oct 11, 2025
There are a lot of issues around immigration. Firstly, the IRCC filters receiving low skilled people, second most of them are located on main cities and provinces, most of the country is empty and finally …
There are a lot of issues around immigration. Firstly, the IRCC filters receiving low skilled people, second most of them are located on main cities and provinces, most of the country is empty and finally if you are gonna keep your traditions here, do it inside your four walls. I begin to understand why Québec is willing to be independent.
Analyzes specific immigration policy issues (skill filtering, geographic distribution, cultural integration) and references Quebec's independence movement as comparative context.
manuelb.703 Sep 6, 2025
It should be in the millions. End the TFW programs and one way tickets home for a thank you but we're done. One time taxpayer cost not monthly.
It should be in the millions. End the TFW programs and one way tickets home for a thank you but we're done. One time taxpayer cost not monthly.
Criticizes Temporary Foreign Worker programs and proposes ending them with deportations, framed as cost-saving policy reform.
ryandonald-rb3wq Dec 30, 2025
In my opinion, the conduct of certain IRCC agents and management reflects a serious lack of competence and accountability. Their ongoing actions—or in some cases, inaction—may rise beyond mere administrative negligence and could reasonably be …
In my opinion, the conduct of certain IRCC agents and management reflects a serious lack of competence and accountability. Their ongoing actions—or in some cases, inaction—may rise beyond mere administrative negligence and could reasonably be viewed as violations of public trust. It’s my view that they should not only be subject to disciplinary review but also held legally accountable for any misconduct or breaches of duty that have harmed Canadian citizens.
Critiques government agency competence and accountability, arguing for disciplinary and legal consequences for misconduct.
ericf924 Oct 17, 2025
Hey, why don't the journalists find out how much money the federal government?And provincial government give to international students in grants and loans.Why are canadian citizens paying for foreigners educated in our country? Educational Grant …
Hey, why don't the journalists find out how much money the federal government?And provincial government give to international students in grants and loans.Why are canadian citizens paying for foreigners educated in our country? Educational Grant and loans should only be allowed for canadian citizens only.
Commenter raises concerns about government spending on international students versus citizens, framed as a policy question about resource allocation and fairness.
lilylily82341 Feb 17, 2026
I am not republican or democrat and not a blind supporter of any leader. I criticize Trump as well-BUT - No one damaged Canada as much as this guy! He did so bad that he …
I am not republican or democrat and not a blind supporter of any leader. I criticize Trump as well-BUT - No one damaged Canada as much as this guy! He did so bad that he had to resign- he’s not even worthy of being the leader of Canada! He is simply using the opportunity to cover his incompetence! PATHETIC! This guy is embarrassing himself and his country!
Systematically critiques Trudeau's governance record and competence, claiming he damaged Canada and is now using speeches to cover incompetence.
@CCP2024P Mar 4, 2025
Awesome ? you just brought on retaliatory tariffs. Stupid move.
Awesome ? you just brought on retaliatory tariffs. Stupid move.
Criticizes tariff decision as strategically foolish due to predictable retaliatory response.
@Oscar40694 Mar 4, 2025
The temporary foreign worker program is what's wrong with Canada.. it incentivizes businesses to hire foreigners over citizens.. the government literally pays for over 50% of their wages... Tim Hortons abuses it the most
The temporary foreign worker program is what's wrong with Canada.. it incentivizes businesses to hire foreigners over citizens.. the government literally pays for over 50% of their wages... Tim Hortons abuses it the most
Critiques the temporary foreign worker program as economically harmful to citizens, citing specific government subsidies and corporate abuse.
TurkeysLeg Jan 28, 2026
7:00 I checked a tax calculator for Canada, $2710 is not a valid number for $21/hour for 40 hours a week anywhere in the country. The closest I got was $2708. Also, I would love …
7:00 I checked a tax calculator for Canada, $2710 is not a valid number for $21/hour for 40 hours a week anywhere in the country. The closest I got was $2708. Also, I would love to see a bill breakdown. "$9 for insurance" That is a bill... "I work 8 and a half hours a day" So... That means you work 42 hours a week.
Challenges the accuracy of financial calculations presented in the video and requests transparency in data presentation.
DemelicosHelsaint Sep 8, 2025
There were two things that Canada had to do to avoid Trump's tariffs. Increase our Defense spending and stop the flow of drugs and illegal aliens entering the US thru Canada. Trudeau only talked about …
There were two things that Canada had to do to avoid Trump's tariffs. Increase our Defense spending and stop the flow of drugs and illegal aliens entering the US thru Canada. Trudeau only talked about the drug issue. If Trudeau cancels the $ 40 Billion unsolicited contract to SNC Lavalin, and instead gives that $ 40 Billion to Canada's military to buy new weapons and train more soldiers Trump will, I am positive, immediately drop the tariffs against Canada!
Critiques Trudeau's policy response to tariffs and proposes alternative defense spending strategy to address Trump's demands.
@MarkKlimaszewski Mar 4, 2025
The Liberals have DESTROYED this country.
The Liberals have DESTROYED this country.
Directly criticizes government (Liberal party) policy as destructive to the country, attributing national problems to political leadership.
Zeromus5555 Jan 27, 2026
If you didn’t want to see us hurt then why did you ruin our logging industry?
If you didn’t want to see us hurt then why did you ruin our logging industry?
Criticism of government policy regarding the logging industry, framed as a betrayal of public interest.
@AntiMatter1 Mar 4, 2025
The first thing you absolutely need to do when you immigrate to a country that doesn't speak your language is to learn it. Period.
The first thing you absolutely need to do when you immigrate to a country that doesn't speak your language is to learn it. Period.
States a prescriptive requirement for immigrants regarding language acquisition, framed as policy expectation rather than personal narrative or moral appeal.
DBF5262 Sep 7, 2025
« Prev 18 / 299 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)