Close Reading

Many of the emigrant they also come from the USA to Canada. Not o only from Canada to the USA.

I wish they'd put money in Emigration.

Name calling is the left calling card ! Call me racist , fascist, i DO NOT CARE , all what i see is a rapid decline of a proud country that i emigrated to over 40 years ago and worked hard and happily to belong to.

Why is it so difficult to have reasonable conversations about this? Most of this video is completely true — but so many comments show love to that bike guy who was factually incorrect and pointlessly racist. But on the other hand, so many woke types don’t even want to admit the problem. They also don’t want to talk about how the government is complicit. Every nation has a right to define itself, and how much immigration it wants, and how that immigration happens. It is beyond ridiculous to not speak the primary language of the country you emigrate to. But why say weird shit like indians eat shit?? Or that 1.5 billion people are all the same? The rationale behind early immigration was to be very tough and selective about who enters and lives here. They welcomed students because it brought in a lot of revenue so that’s a win-win, but to LIVE they had to prove they were an asset to the community. Now the whole thing is manipulated. You don’t have proper vetting for the students because of fake colleges that just want to make money. You don’t have proper limits on immigration and criteria for jobs/skills because companies want to make money. Politicians just do whatever strategy gets votes. But for some reason people either only get woke about the positives of Indian immigrants or only negative, sometimes racist about them. It’s fair to acknowledge that rampant, unchecked immigration ruins the culture. Like Indian driving culture is fucking terrible. You don’t want to bring that shit over. You can also acknowledge that early immigrants and their kids are often completely American/Canadian, from their native language, accents, education, references etc. And that Indians are generally a low-crime, high-employment, high-tax-paying immigrant group. And we ALSO acknowledge that that’s changing because of the type/number of people coming in, and the financial and political incentives which support it. It causes valid resentment. These fucking human smuggling rings are real af. Wokies don’t ever talk about it. But I wish we could have this conversation without the racism.

As a Canadian, i had to leave and emigrate to Norway to go back to a time where I’m not scared to lock my doors. I hate what Canada has become

Canada should impose education for emigrants of Canadian culture. Be like Japan- you come here, you practise what we practise, you follow Japanese rules, if you can’t- then leave!

What about old people brought here, never worked one hour in Canada, but receive pension, medical and dental benefits, or stay on welfare?? What about emigration business that evolved in BC like mushrooms after rain?? Who's paying for this category of emigrants??

I heard canada is the worst place one can emigrate to

This is a multifaceted problem for us. Firstly we keep emigrating people in, to deal with a declining population, instead of addressing the issues directly resulting in declining population, like the housing problem, cost of living, under paying jobs, and astronomical Post secondary prices to get basic diplomas I know for a fact that 90's babies will be the last generation to have more then one child. Another issue is the recruitment centers in India, funded by Canadian corporations looking for cheap labor, promising the world to struggling Indians only to back out of every promise they made, and put the burden on the government and Canadians. This plus a lack of population control in India, is set that to have Indians to be over 25% of the global population in the next 50 years.

TBF most of them are good people, and want a better life. I have no quarrels against that but I think maybe 5 figures a year is lots, not this 800k+. That being said, most of them here are relatively upper middle class since its not cheap to emigrate from India.

White guy Ancestors Emigrate (Infade)the Country of the Aboriginals!! Canada!!

So when it comes to foreigners in Canada, Canada is apparently not much better than the fascist Trump regime❗❗As an American this absolutely discusts me! We apparently forget that both our countries are founded on emigrants❗

100 Yrs ago we could help-people by setting them on their feet at home or letting them emigrate. But since then Africa Sth America and the ME each multiplied >1,000 times and there's no way we can solve their problems now. And blaming people who helped them and wasted their money and efforts and blood only to get maliciously defamed and spat on, hasn't helped their case.

Over 118,000 emigrated, 18,000 deported, lots of students and visa holders left. Over 300,000 deaths in Canada last year.

It’s so funny this government is blindly allowing false refugee claims Even in countries where there are no violence whatsoever many have claimed refugee status . And this liberal government even without proper encouery let them get that status are now enjoying our hard earned tax money free housing cash dental schooling college furniture even laptops??? accepted them as real refugees leaving real genuine refugees and law abiding educated hard working emigrants in the fray . Shocking Canada 🇨🇦 The emigration minister should resign cause some of them may have police records gangsters rapists we do not know Time Canada imported good decent hard working emigrants without police record

Lot of people....the original citizens feel the burn since the world around them is changing. It's natural that they harbor these ill feelings. Most of them are ill informed and have these racist views. It's true for every immigrant community that emigrated from Europe as well. You have Irish immigrant towns, little Italy's, China towns, little India's, polish neighborhoods in Chicago etc ...these kind of neighborhoods are all over north America (USA & Canada). This is natural. Assimilation happens in 1 or 2 generations. Economic expansion and fulfilling social security benefits for the older generation needs population growth and a new younger workforce. This is achieved thru immigration of skilled labor force of all kinds. Population dynamics and demographics keep changing all the time and it has happened thru out human history. Now we are living in an interconnected and inter dependent world. It's better to adapt to change and move on and retain your loyalty to the country they migrated to and contribute positively to their economy and try to assimilate as much as possible and be aware of the sensitivities. This new immigration is from Asia and they are of different ethnicities and cultural background unlike european immigration that happened earlier. So some backlash to these new people's is to be expected and there will be lot of scapegoating and stereotypical epithets that will employed to demonize the new immigrant groups. We all have to adjust assimilate and move on in this great circle of life.

I am a college student in the southeastern us in a small town. We have many many many nepalis coming and using it as a springboard to emigrate (usually illegally) across the us. They do not speak our language, integrate, work, or understand our customs. Not integration, no immigration.

This is not emigration , this is invasion..................Canadastan

Wonder what native Americans stories were like when Europeam emigrated to north America

Indians will ruin your country. There is a reason why they have an exploding population and their govt encourages emigration. They want money from abroad by all means, even by scamming elderly westerners. That is how they maintain gdp growth

Emigrants ( Dutch, Portug., Pakst etc) complain about new emigrants. LOL

Yes in the 80’s as a new emigrants we had to work for our living. We never ever thought to get help from the government we are all integrated in to a Canadian society. We paid taxes from the day one that made us true Canadian citizens. Which I’m a very proud of. In my street two houses own by East Indians They don’t take care of their properties like us taking care of our property. Should I assimilate in to there’s way of life ? Or they should assimilate into our society? The answer to this question is very simple . Assimilate to our way of life or move back to India.

So white people from Europe are complaining about emigrants lol

If 2% of Indians emigrated to Canada they would make up half the population.

Last warning to the Anglo-Saxons: your days are counted. The Anglosphere and the Commonwealth as you knew it is totally doomed. Start learning other languages and emigrate to nations where your daughters won't be targeted by the "cow-dung-bobs-and-vagene" folks. They're nasty, but they're too lazy to learn Spanish, Portuguese, Korean, etc.

How about the Emigration problem? Immigration from another country is one thing; Losing a worker to Emigration is another. This is what happened in the Netherlands: After the war, there was massive unemployment. (since not everyone is fit to work in construction) So we sent 5% of the country away, mostly to Canada. Most everyone who emigrated was fit and of working age. A lot of them where farmers. Twenty years later there was a massive labour shortage. Our country needed fit men of working age. So we got immigrants.

I’m a recent Indian immigrant and I’ve lived in Singapore, Malaysia, the USA, and now Canada. I’ll admit that a lot of what’s said here is true: there are far too many cases where Indians abroad show a lack of civic sense, break rules, or behave in ways that don’t respect the host country.  Personally, my family and I have always assimilated wherever we’ve lived, respecting local customs, following rules, and contributing positively to the community and I hate it when immigrants don't assimilate into the local culture and reside in their own enclaves, I mean what was the point of emigrating then?? I truly value the peace and order these countries offer, and I want to give that back. Every community has good and bad examples. The responsibility is on us as immigrants to lead by example, integrate genuinely, and show that we can be respectful, responsible citizens. That’s how perceptions change for the better. It sucks that a whole racial group can be disliked because of some bad apples — and in our case, unfortunately, there are quite a few.

I am an Indian. I request the people in all the developed countries of the world to make extremely tough emigration laws, so that the people who are legally acquiring citizenship of your country are not dependent on the taxes paid by the original residents of those countries. Plain, simple and honest. Now, if you are allowing every tom, dick and harry from any country to live in your country, then the chances would be high that, unproductive/criminals of the other country to start to get citizenship. Please DO NOT blame entire India for changing the demographic landscape of Canada, or any other developed country. Please make extremely tough laws, like in USA, to sift out the unwanted people. India is dirty, everyone knows. Indians are corrupt, everyone knows. So, please allow ONLY young Indians who are smart/hardworking enough, who can win a Nobel prize/Olympic Medal/set up businesses, for Canada, to take the citizenship of Canada.Take example of Dubai. Lawmakers of Dubai are intelligent/honest. Please......

Canada is finito… if I truly could afford to, I would emigrate to another country for a better lifestyle for my kids. I can’t tell what it’s gonna be like in another 15-20 years. I can’t even afford to get my car fixed, which I use for business to make a living 🤦‍♂️ My problem isn’t with immigration - it’s more with crime, taxes, cost of living and the lack of making it easier for People to live and spend QUALITY time with our families. Greed is killing this country 🪦

As an immigrant I highly agree…IF YOU CAME TO ANOTHER COUNTRY FOR A BETTER AND PEACEFUL LIFE YOU SHOULD EMIGRATE, RESPECT AND BECOME PART OF THAT COUNTRYS’ CULTURE AND NOT TRY TO DESTROY IT. Cause I’m sure that tourist who visit certain countries are expected to do the same . For example if I wanted to travel to a Middle Eastern Country I would have to wear a Burka or another form of head covering even though that’s not what I’m use to. So yea…If you can’t respect Canada for its culture STAY IN YOUR COUNTRY OF BIRTH AND STOP TRYING TO CONFORM CANADA INTO SUCH.

Why are they getting ANY of my tax money? The only thing my Dad go t when we emigrated was a job, a skilled one, and no one handed him that.

Thank you, Prime Minister Trudeau. It’s impossible to deal with narcissistic psychopaths. I must emigrate out off this fascist oligarchy. Whatever republicons are taking has dissolved their SPINES and turned their single brain cells into spam.

I wish I were a Canadian. But then, I have wished that for the last 40 years of my life. Too bad I could never make the point score necessary to emigrate. I am ashamed to live in the US. Trump has to go, by any means.

I wish I could emigrate to Canada but I am stuck here in America with that damned fool Trump.

We don't need spending money for Ukraine Trudeau spending money without limits when Canada have big problems economy inflation double homeless and emigration problems we must be realistic what is good also for AS County \nCANADA FIRST ?? ? ?? ? ?? \nCANADA ALWAYS ?? ? ?? ? ??

We have hard of you. Economy down inflation double homeless emigration problems ????you destroy CANADA ??100% You must take consequences for damage County and apologize Canadians for abuse people for wrong informations about situations critical crisis from your liars??????You are loose controls a leader CANADA ?? you are loose County and Canadians people ??????

I have two sets of great-grandparents that emigrated from Canada. Does that qualify me for Canadian citizenship? I support Canada.

This is amazing. This prime minster talks as if Canada did nothing wrong and US decided to bully them for no reason. If everything's fine and dandy, we wouldn't have done this. Trump did what he did because of \n\n1. Drug trafficking from north + illegal emigrants\n2. Unfair trade deficit in times when our national debt is unsustainably high. \n\nWhy so high? Because we've been giving Canada SURPLUS for decades. Can't do that no more because we have to save our country now. Don't mischaracterize this move, fools.

I'm glad you mentioned the emigration and brain drain part. I'm a 30 year old engineer and I'm tired of living in Canada, I don't even identify myself as culturally or politically canadian anymore. Here's to me hoping I move to the USA with my useless degree and start over my life.

Boomers in Canada are very nimby thus making housing so much harder to build, leading to younger generations emigrating to other countries like south of the border. Also eating up lands zoned to industrial, and thus making industrial rent more expensive to the remaining patches of land available on city outskirts. \n\nMaybe it’s time to review the policies overall. Canada has been treating its older generations like kings, with their large lawns and healthcare which they frequently use…while younger generations and immigrants work like a slave.

Funny that you do not mention 2 millions emigrants who entered Canada illegally from the US in the last 9 year.

Very well organized by UN emigration compact NOT voted by you but payed by you. With money that DOESN'T EXIST, gov has to borrow it.

Imagine emigrating from Canada to the USA :D

Illegal Emigrants Didn't need a passport to fly into Canada so that's what they Did then they made a Run for the US Border.

Houston Texas has a lot of African illegal emigrants, Portland Maine also has a fuck load of illegal Africans

I am Québécois, and things here are quite different from the rest of Canada. For example, we have a law here that clearly forbids wearing religious signs when in a position of authority. Even a teacher, because they are a figure of authority for their students, could not wear the Roman collar, a cassock, a hijab, a niqab or anything else of the sort while in school. In the streets or any other public place, there is no problem at all. Everyone is welcomed to express their difference of culture or religion in the way they dress or in whatever other way. They are treated with the same respect and kindness as anywhere else in Canada. It is only that the separation of religion and state, and religion and authority is paramount here. Everybody is free and can express themsleves freely. But don't use that freedom to impose your views onto others. \nSo, when American judges are chosen for the federal court specifically because of their christian fundamentalist biases, it doesn't resonate well at all for me or the majority of Québécois. When the rights of the LGBTQ+ community are being questioned or jeopardised. Or a previous federal judgement like Roe v Wade is being overturned for religious reasons... it is a definite turn off for all of the Québec people to even remotely consider the United States as a destination to emigrate to (supposing that one would want to leave our beautiful country).\nMore and more, America, that used to be recognized as the land of the free, appears to be retrograde and restrictive and definitely not so free.

And This is one reason Americans voted for Trump!! This is a invasion and it won't stop until America ramp up deportations, prosecute any American aiding immigrants, and chastise Mexico for encouraging ppl to emigrate!! This is only the beginning, And if Americans don't develop tough skin, Third world countries will continue to come in mass hordes!!! TURN UP DEPORTATIONS!! PUT MILITARY ON BORDER, PROSECUTE ANYBODY AIDING IMMIGRANTS, GET RID OF BIRTHRIGHTS!!! IF NOT, SMH

The USA can hire a large A-380 passenger plane to deport illegal emigrants out of the USA. This will reduce the cost of transportation and much relief to the passenger on board with two halts for refreshment during the journey. However I agree with the notion of hand cuffing and leg cuffing to reduce untoward incidents during the journey.

When my Grandparents and most of their siblings emigrating from England they considered several places Australia, Canada, Rhodesia. USA was not a choice, they would not even think about it - this was in the 1950's

I used a crowbar to emigrate into the CNN offices. The police took me away in handcuffs! CNN must be fascist dictators!