Close Reading

I think if been here 20 years than need fast tracked to citizenship but on conditions of no felonies and contributing to American

They are indians in usa, I don't understand why they needed visa if they are NRI they should have indian passport and if they have usa passport and have renounced indian citizenship, why did they not apply for OCI. i guess they never planned to come to india that often and this is just an one of affair so they didn't bother to get the OCI. Idiotic in my opinion, if god forbid they get in any trouble with the general hostility towards indians growing especially in USA, they should keep the option to just pack up and leave without all this visa issues on a moments notice.

Sooooooo i take it Baron and his mom are going back to her country? Remember she came on a work visa when they met. He fast tracked her citizenship. Hes the biggest hypocrite!

One time, I went on 1 day business trip to Canada ( i have American Citizenship, but born in Europe). Good Lord, I was asked so many ridiculous questions, and most were related to my former old country!!! Absolutely total idiotic nonsense!! I was told later, Canadians officials don't like people coming to the beloved country on business, they figure you come to destroy their Socialist Cabal and establish Capitalism!! Sacrilege!!

I am a senior and live in Vancouver, BC and my son who has dual citizenship lives in Seattle, WA. His wife and him will move back to Canada when he retires. I visit Seattle and enjoy going there. The shopping is great fun especially with all the big store headquarters being there and we can't forget Trader Joe's. I don't drink alcohol anymore, but the cost, volume and availability is crazy. He also lived in New York and lived a train ride away to the suburbs (great system) and was a lovely area to raise a family. Visited NYC and loved it. I've lived in Montreal and just love big cities. In saying all that, I think were all basically the same, however I could never permamentally live in the US. I can no longer afford the outrageous travel health insurance to travel to the USA because of my age and health issues. I have a primary doctor and four specialists that I see on a regular basis, waiting for a hip replacement and none has cost me a cent. Oh yes, I get free dental care. I wouldn't move to the states, but would sure like to visit again. Politics is a whole other subject.

Attn NZ Govt! Take notes and do the same. Revoke the citizenships for these Invading Pests. Do not recognise arranged marriages! Dairy, Bottle Store owners who sponsor their aged relatives to come into country and then are soon after claiming the pension?! The business is then sold to another Indian cousin and the process repeats with the arranged marriage/spouse soon gaining citizenship and then their aged parents being sponsored workers in the Dairy (and gaining citizenship) that really has added NO business benefit to our economy. The indigenous people of this country did not sign a Treaty with Asia, it was signed with an appointed Governor on behalf of the Crown of England. Therefore, stop allowing the onsale of our land to foreigners of the Parties to the Treaty.

Yes! Yes! Yes!! End birthright citizen's!! These moochers come in through a hole in the fence and expect us taxpayers to pay for the to give birth and then get automatic citizenship..NO MORE!!!

No citizenship for non American by blood!!!\nGive them residency instead.

They should stop birthright citizenship to anchor babies

The student program should have never been a path to permanent residence. Every Study Permit application should have the three below terms and conditions:\n\n1. Purpose of the Visa: This student visa is issued solely for the purpose of pursuing your studies at [Institution Name] in Canada. It is a temporary visa, and its primary function is to allow you to study and engage in academic activities. It is not a pathway to permanent residency or citizenship in Canada.\n\n2. Temporary Nature of the Visa: Your student visa is valid only for the duration of your enrolled academic program or course of study. Upon the completion of your studies, you are required to leave Canada immediately, unless you apply for and are granted a different visa that legally allows you to remain, such as a work visa.\n\n3. No Pathway to Permanent Residence: This student visa does not confer eligibility for permanent resident status or citizenship in Canada. You are not permitted to apply for permanent residency or citizenship while holding this visa. If you wish to apply for permanent status in Canada, you must do so separately and in person at your country of origin in accordance with the immigration laws and procedures of Canada.

End this birthright citizenship! Millions of illegals are rigging the system. An American taxpayer like myself has to wait well over a month for my first ob appt due to them draining our medical system.

This whole birth right citizenship is absolutely ridi ulou. Even hear in Australia where is outrageously progressive we dont have it!!

Every European country big mistake is giving to citiizenship to the outsider if they stop getting given citizenship they wiill go back there home country

They've come to Canada to get what they were promised by Trudeau the wealth of mainly Europeans that came since 1867.\nYes Trudewu using his latest MP Marc Miller wants to give them citizenship so they'll vote for Liberala and are able to give citzenship status to family ? still in Middle East and Africa.Nigeria #1 for imkigrants.

Its good. Why should they go to Canada? They think Canadian citizenship is the short cut to get US green card. It’s better to be India and work for our economy

Indian all over Canada they take all Canadian citizenship jobs as you can see in Walmart or timhorton and many work places and their services suck\nWhere is my country now ?\nIs it Canada or a territory of india

1000 % agree cutting out the citizenship who born here with their illegal parents…the kids should be deported with their parents although they born here. They are not legally citizens!

Good. Anyone in country on a Visa, student visa (which would have included Kamala Harris since her parents were PhD students at the time of Kamala's birth), illegal, tourist or no one whom is not a citizen should be allowed birthright citizenship

Stop bringing them in at break neck speed. STOP FAMILY unification for parents or have a ten year time line and all further cost to be bourne by sponsor. REFUGEES who get residency should NOT get citizenship until all cos?t as refugees be repaid in full.Time to get serious about immigration.

He did not say deport together, he said they can go together, the kids can comeback when they are 18 and have proof of citizenship.

It’s tough 1.5 billion people can easily over welm a country of immigration personally I don’t blame them how ever my son went to a US collage an he did not get a pass to citizenship maybe they should be given a number an when the job market picks up give them a call back

Canada keeps giving citizenship to terrorists/extremists. You reap what you sow.

Birth right citizenship is for the birds.Please stop this Mr.President.

The most ridiculous thing is women who come from several countries just to give birth and then leave for their countries with American citizenship. ???

Strange question... Why Canadians hate you? Now you see what your people are doing in the countries of Europe... Defecating and urinating in the street... Celebrations of religious rites in a place that is not their place ... Smashing facilities.... Entering with false certificates... The recognition of most of your people that the intention is only to obtain citizenship and demand rights ... Dancing in the streets... Erasure of Canadian identity..... And this is not only in Canada but in most of the countries of Europe. You enter like poor people and then you start stirring up problems and you still ask why people hate you

Old type Immigration and Citizenship rules created for White Community of Christianity, Jews Peoples in European, American, Australian Continental's Countries. But now it's used by Non White, Non Christianity, Jews peoples in above Countries. All benefits goes to Non White and Non Christianity, Jews Peoples. We want now changed the rules. Cancel all Immigration and Citizenship visas to Non White and Non Christianity, Jews Peoples in all above countries. Visas with long time Contract period only to Non White and Non Christianity, Jews Peoples. All problems are solved.

Should Canada reduce the citizenship wait period to 1 year instead of 3?

too late.. way too many fraudulent students already got PR & citizenships lol

1- Trudeau should be sent to India 2- stop ⛔️ all immigration programs to Canada until cleanup done 3- deport all student and temporary workers and refugees from countries where there are no conflicts or trouble 4- start cleanup of Trudeau damages, yes it’s still possible to act by retrieving permanent residence and even canadian citizenship from those who came as student, temporary workers or refugees. Only those who entered Canada as legal PR after being through the normal RP process deserve the Canadian citizenship and the RP… after all cleaning done, Canada should review all its immigration programs, and open its doors to only those groups who didn’t abuse the Canadian system example europeans

It was never meant for them. It was meant for Black Americans, not illegal immigrants who found a loop hole to get their anchor babies citizenship.

The 14th amendment was created to protect post civil war blacks and ensure that they were recognized as American citizens!!! PERIOD!! How can some third world alien slither across our borders ILLEGALLY and demand citizenship for their progeny??? Soon there will be no more debating any of this nonsense and there will be civil war which will end all of the debating!!!

America patriots will end illegal alien birthright citizenship one way or the other. Americans are done with the BS!!!

You’re fine most people agree that birthright citizenship should end. There have been multiple polls and surveys on this subject. It needs to end.

OMG BIRTH RIGHT CITIZENSHIP there is going to be plenty of people “Leaving On A Jet Plane” this will be the song! America voted

? wide open ?\nWE know BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP IS A ( RUSE ) \nTHEIR USE TO RUNNING.\nWHAT MAKES AMERICA BELIEVE THEY WON'T RUN\nIF AMERICA SHOULD HAVE A PROBLEM.\nRemember: They have a HOME AMERICA IS ALL WE \n ???HAVE???

What about Trumps wife and in-laws, why should American citizenship via marriage be considered more valid than born citizenship?

Trump being the son of immigrant parents would have his own citizenship revoked as he himself is an anchor baby.

Sorry but they are not entitled to canadian citizenship, its a privilege not a right , plain and simple, visa expired GO HOME!!!! Plain and simple

Sorry but they are not entitled to canadian citizenship, its a privilege not a right , plain and simple, visa expired GO HOME

He won't get rid of it and the 14th amendment doesn't provide for birthright citizenship.

If your not born from at least 1 American parent you should not have citizenship sorry but not sorry get them out

If you wish to immigrate to the U.S., you will need to obtain citizenship funds, housing funds, and other things to get you in line with the law.\n A country has its own rules, and to do as one pleases, even if it means breaking the rules of the country, is frowned upon by the people of that country.\n The problem is that Japan and other countries, such as France, are experiencing a number of tragic events due to the immigration problem.\n Recently, a 10 year old Japanese girl was raped by a 30 year old Kurdish man, and Japanese citizens are living in anxiety everyday. Like the U.S., every country is now very annoyed by all the immigrants! Immigrants impose their own culture. Why is it that these immigrants are allowed to stay in the other country, and yet they are not allowed to care about the culture and rules of the other country ? If that is the case, it would be better for both parties to live in the country of their birth from the beginning for the sake of peace.\n\n＊most japanes ppl said American people do the right thing.you chose right person for president! now japanes need facing their own problem,

The misinterpretation of laws are in direct conflict with early emigration laws in America particularly ‘The Emigration’ Act of 1866 and also naturalization act of 1790 if people keep going back in time using past laws to justify this the more it confuses things. All I know is the intent of the laws need to be accurately interpreted so that it’s clear who they were meant for when they were written because from the way I read and interpret them there is nothing that directly allows for the offspring of illegal and undocumented parents to be granted automatic citizenship. Especially since this is happening while our country actually has immigration laws and a process for them to follow. Some where where in our ‘politics’ this has gotten all screwed up and definitely needs to be fixed.

if your parents are here illegally, and you're born here, you should not be granted citizenship!

I googled number of countries with birthright citizenship and I counted over 80, he is truly a dumb phq.

Birthright citizenship has been SEVERELY abused! End it!

President Trump would need to amend the constitution in other to remove birthright citizenship, because the 14th amendment's grant of birth right citizenship to all people born within in the country.

I agree…no more birth citizenship. We need to reform the country. Americans first. No sugar coating anymore.

I wonder if they will renounce their citizenship?

citizenship rights was for slaves whose children will be born in the USA during slavery. The context is different if you came in illegally.... President Trump is right... Congress should support him