Close Reading

In India also some muslims are thinking like you. Destination may be pakistan given to them in 1947.

What are you expecting?\nThis video is Hypocrisy When you go to a western country you have to assimilate with western culture.\nYou have to learn to live with church bells ringing not Azan!\nGreat you are leaving!\nYour parents were lucky they were given residency in the West then all of you used the social benefits \nBoth of you i believe hold Canada passpots ,that is a n Asset already!\n\nThere is no visible target in the west,it is exaggerated!\nMy families in Canada are free to practice their religion wear their ethenic clothes which they do all the time.\n\n\nEvery middle eastern ,pakistan i have met ,his primary goal is to be US SWEDEN ITALY NORWAY.\nWhst Genocide?\nWhat did Abbas do to fellow muslims he gassed childern women babies\nWhat about Sudan it is Genocide.\n\nMy thoughts are you should go to Middle east help Gazans,Syria ,Sudanese\nThen back to your home country Pakistan.\nYour neighbour India is another very good option to live.\nPlease give up your Canada residency if you stand by what you believe!

F*d up govt who brings muslims, indians, and pakistanis. They are taking over the canadian mix and making it another india, pakistan, or middle east. Canada is not European culture anymoren like it used to be

Never move to Pakistan, India, or Bangladesh. They've mesed up Islam into sects.

Because USA policy to destroy other countries on name of freedom, lybia Iraq how many, even India they support Pakistan terrorism that Laden was USA funded in starting

Is the same applicable when it comes to Hindus of India ? Because , this land was divided based on religion and a separate nations ( right now 2 ) exist - with one - being an Islamic republic . \n\nIs it too much to ask for Hindus and other religions to tell Muslims of India who voted for a separate nation by whopping majority (96%) when a poll was conducted by the British but still chose to stay in India ??? \n\nWhy should Indian majority be any concerned about the so called minority with 20% of population who create more ruckus than the real minorities like Jains and Parsis ? \n\nBy the same logic - Muslims of India should just go and settle in Pakistan!!!

If you flip the coin, it's very interesting to hear stories from expats of Eastern European decent living in Canada - And they're all desperate to return back to their country of origin because they say Canada is saturated with many migrants from the Far-East (China) South-East Asia (India & Pakistan) and Africa. They say they feel lost in all that. Some of these have applied for working visa's to the U.S. It seems every group of the human race has their own agenda for wanting to relocate to other places, mainly for comfort and security.

India is already suffering a lot. First they divided our land and created Pakistan on the basis of religion. Next they killed and drove away kashmiri hindus thus changing the demography of the land and now they want free kashmir. And the ones living in India are creating ruckus everyday of all sorts.

I am from Pakistan and I suggest India economy is very strong so I would suggest to work and stay In your country. India is a good place and if you earn good you will love beautiful life same in Pakistan if you earn good life is good here tok

Doesnt matter about the country. Punjab is 1 and wil always be one whether in india or Pakistan

Bc india Pakistan wale bahar jane k liye marte hai inki asli aukaat yahi hai....dono Maha ghatiya desh koi kutte k bhaav nahi poochta dono desho ko.....

Sikh people always get deceived, they are freedom fighters not a terrorist. India claims whole lands but never give them their rights. Sikh can’t go to Pakistan for their shrines. Muslim player can’t do sajda on the ground field just Hindu has fully rights. Stop these non sense. Stop making fools to minorities

sikho ke liye hamesha respect hai or lena hi hai to Pakistan wala part lena chahiye baki aap alag karke karo ge bhi kya piche Pakistan aage india to fir wahi problem or india kabhi bhi partition karne nahi dega kyu ki fir Pakistan wale kahe ge hamare sath ho jao fir wahi problem india ko face karna padega

For whose don't know Pakistan is part of India back in the day and when a mother sees her two children fighting, she can't choose a side or be bias as a result she will broken into pieces just like Pakistan and India. Imagine if Pakistan was not seperated and both relegions are respected, India will be a great good example to other countries

Ye bhi batao hamaray youngsters india pakistan kun chor rahay hai. Worst law and order situation in both the countries. No rights. Worst politicians and their worst politics. Worst police

Native Canadians needs to fight back but we won’t, instead we just leave and hand over our country.\n\nImagine being annexed by India and Pakistan of all countries without a shot being fired. \n\nMakes me proud.

I am from Bangladesh and I think we should not break our countries Into pieces, instead of making Khalistan we should unite India Bangladesh & Pakistan bcz unity makes strength and divide makes us weak. British left us like this so that we can be weak and we keep fighting in between us and this is what actually happening since 1947 before the British era Hindostan was for everyone Hindus Muslims Sikhs Buddhists Christians Jains Parsis etc but since they use divide and rule policy we all became enemy of each other. So now is this 21st century we should not put religion in front of success and IF India Bangladesh Pakistan becomes one country than the west and the east both will fear from HINDOSTAN❤️??????❤️\nJoy Bangla?Jai Hindh?Pakistán Zindabad?

Khalistanioo ko sirf India ka hi punjab chahiye ?pakistan ka Punjab gaand marane jaeeee ?? chutiya log hai pagadi k aandar gobar bhar k rakha hai????

This is not nice to show anger to G7 country that has all Indian states people... This childish spat between them for one Sikh murder costs huge loss to Tamil people living in Canada.. I urge MEA to stop this childish act maintain the stable and healthy relation with Canada because many Tamilians are working there in Canada... India should stop bullying it's allies and foreign policies else many countries will reject Indians and its will be huge calamity in economy, pride, resources and jobs in India for Centre and States.. India is main advantage that it can exports cheap laborers to other countries like France Australia etc where their govt agreed to replace their citizens by these Indians... MEA jaishankar should mind his tongue and stop abusing others and supporting India's irresponsible behaviour during summits and meet on wars and other event... Must take notes on Pakistan delicately balancing mighty and opposite countries KSA, US, UK and China... India is gaining newer enemies after Pak and China eg Ukraine dead against India now, Canada, Palestine, Turkey etc... Whereas Pak gaining new friends like Russia, Iran even Japan... Remember India, Tamil Nadu is there and you cannot take advantage of us... Please go and stop this nonsense and maintain smooth relation and safeguard Tamil people in Canada....

Tumara india sab duniya se alag hai sewae pakistan aur bangladesh ke ??????? hahahaha hahahaha hahahaha hahahaha

Air India crash behind Pakistan and india agencies were involved and they wanted to blow old air India plan look like ?

Very true and appreciated ? ? I am still feeling like I am true ? Canadian ? to khalstan at all times united Canada ?? united india ?? thanks gagjit singh ploted by Pakistan still Pakistan agencies behind look like some Hindu are also ?

Waah Kia bat he, India is India , mein Pakistan ki bat nahi Kar saki, Canada mein log apney ap mein rehtey hen,,,,,,,, from Pakistan

Also advantage was taken by Pakistan after 1984 to support Khalistan movement along with UK and US trying to have a whip at India.

Hum sab Ek hai. ?? Hindu Sikh Jain Buddhist. Sanatan Dharma se nikle hue 4 bhai. 10 o Gurus Hindu family se belong karte the toh uss hisab se ek hi hue hum sab.. Kalyan Singh Das Bedi jo Guru Nanak ji k pita the Kshtriya family se the.. hai na.. \nHamesha se iss dharti maa ko bachane k liye Sikh bhai agge aaye.. maine kabhi bhi kisi Sikh bhai k saath kisi Hindu se ladai hote hue nahi dekha.. I'm from 90's. \nR re Pakistan wale haste hai fayda uthana chahte hai.. woh toh yahi dekhna chahte hai India k tukde tukde ho jaye aur Khalistani wale yeh nahi samaj paa rahe hai kya? Pandit o k saath , partition k time Hindu o k saath bhi bahut julum hue the iska matlab yeh nahi ab ulta hum karenge... 1984 mein ek tarfa kuch nahi hua tha ... \n\nLekin ab humein ek jut rehna hoga.. Bharat Maa hai humari maa ko barbad mat karo kabhi dharam k naam pe. Maa ko weak maat karo aur. Forget past forget religion caste and all. We are Indians. God is same for us all. Jai hind. Vande Mataram ??

I must say you have a good skill of spreading Indian govt propaganda in a way like it was out of great research. We are are fed up of all these sharma verma and rajputs sitting in Delhi spinning conspiracy theories against sikhs. According to your rogue analysis the entire NDP party is infiltrated with Sikhs and sikhs are holding canadian govt to ransom. Is it not true that successive hindu majoritarian govt have done genocide and extrajudicial killings of sikhs in 1980s and 2000s for muslims to appease the hindu majority voters. After pannu made a video to threaten hindus to leave India entire Canadian parties condemn it and assured safety of hindus in Canada. In comparison every single day a hindu leader of Indian parties calls muslims to go to pakistan and labells sikhs as terrorists and no judicial system or political parties and so called independent journalists like you have guts to call it out. Its not the sikhs to want so much khalistan its the treatment of India and its majority with sikhs that creates the demand.

Hii me hindu hu delhi se past me 1984 me bhaut kuch hua tha hindu bhi gye dango me aur sikh bhi gye the jin jin logo ne sikho ke sath bura kra bhagwan usko kbhi maaf nhi krega aur sikho ne hindu ke sath us samye mujhe yeh smj nhi ata dango me bichari ladkiya fasi jin jin bhosi walo ne rape kra khule aam usko kbhi mafi nhi.milegi marege sar sar ke log chai woh kisi bhi dharm ke ho \n\nAur jo log khalistani h usko me support nhi krta na hi kbhi kruga kuki jo sikh h aur hindu woh ek hi maa ke 2 bete h humne past me sb kuch jhela nuksan hum dono dhsrm me tension bd gyi aur duriya aa gyi me aaj bhi mnta hu hume sath me rehna chaiye kuki \n\n1947 me hindu sikh jain budish hi h jo india ka h bus kuch muslim ka bhi jo desh se ghadri krega woh goli khayega jo koi bhi \nJo kuch hindu bina mtlb ke punjabi muslim ko aatankabdi mt bolo aur ek dusre ke coment se bacho\n\nI love sikh mujhe aaj bhi yaad h me chandigarh sector 17 me fas gya tha udar ek kothi thi me gumne gya tha saare paise karch ho gye the us bhen ne meri bhaut help kri thi mujhe paiss diye ticket book krawai delhi ki aur khane ko chai pani kr bhagwan humesha usko khush rakhe mene bhaut koshish kri but mujhe punjab aur uttarakhand psnd h punjab me mostly jata hu \n\nMe hindu delhi se hu koi kothi par jaye uske ghar jak3 pani mang le bus pani de dega but kha se aaye usko koi lena dena nhi hota h kuch log hote h help krne wale baki majk krne wale \n\nsikh me yeh h ki unme mostly ache hote h hus kuch h jinko khalistsni h bus 100 me se kewal 10 \n\nBhai pakistan hi dekh lo hume udar jaane ke liye visa lena pdta h \n\nManlo khalistan bhi bn gya but hum jo log gumne wale bnde h aaam ensan unka kya unko visa lena pdega upar wale ne dimag diya sahi se use kro har dharm acha hota h dharm me kuch log bhosi wale hote h\n\n4 din ki zindagi h khao pio enjoy kro faltu ke chakar me rahige ghand pr goli khaoge aur kuch nhi upar wale ne zindagi jeene ke liye aur kuch krne ke liye di h \n\n\nKisi ko meri bat ka bura lga ho lagne do jo mere dil me hota h me muh pr hi bilta hu filat toh coment krke bol rah hu

Bro Khalistan to ban kar raha ga \n2022/25 se halat dekhna suru ho gaye pakistan china v India ke war ho ge india 4/5 day me india ka hall Russia ke jasa ho ga \nUSA Ukraine ke taha \nPakistan ko weapons send karg dekhna lana \n2030 tak india ke 9 parts ho ge Soviet union ke Traha

Grew up in a traditional sikh family in punjab with the generic beliefs about pakistan being the rival country and punjab's hate towards the incidents of 1984 &1947. Moved to canada when i was 12 years old. Now i hav friends from muslim community, hindi community, afganistan, nigeria, Chinese, japanese and some others as well. We r so close to each other and just enjoy each other's values. We eat what we want and be considerate towards each other's values. I wish something like that could exist in india too. Just geeting along but there is too much division. Unfortunately, seems like its only gonna get worse. Much love to every community in india as well as pakistan. Its possible to get along if we just acknowledge the facts and gain some unbiased knowledge. Thank you for making that first step possible Nitish❤

You didn't talk about other activities that happened in 1971.\nPakistan wanted to separate punjab from india because they lost Bangladesh.\nThis is when pakistan started investing money for khalistan

SORRY, BUT NOWADAYS canada and uk,[ pakistan of the west ] seems full of THUGS, WAR CRIMINALS, ORGANISED CRIME, INTERNATIONAL DRUG CARTELS, TERRORIST, ISLAMIST, AND NAZIs. FOLLOWING is a list :- \nislamist terrorists from pakistan \neconomic terrorist fugitives from usa, India and Latin America \ndrugs and weapons smugglers from Pakistan \n khalistani terrorist from India \nislamist terrorists and the killer of their father of nation from Bangladesh \norganized criminal gangs from Russia, India, Vietnam \nLTTE terrorist from Srilanka \nNAZI's from Germany, Ukraine, Poland, and around the world. good going.

what afghanistan is to pakistan, pakistan is to INDIA, canada [ khalistan ] can be or will be turned into, for america .

Punjab’s per captia is less coz of Punjab’s major institution and business went to the it’s capital Chandigarh , which was promised to Punjab but was later turned into UT. Punjab per captia is 2500 while Chandigarh per captia is 5200dollars … Punjab university , Chandigarh university , Punjab&haryana high court , punjabi music industry , punjabi film industry , punjabi politician , punjabi students has all shifted to Chandigarh , majority of business that operate in Punjab are headquartered in Chandigarh, the IT companies that were reaching Punjab had limited to Chandigarh .. even though Punjabis live in Chandigarh but this output is added separately coz it was turned into UT. I know some people will come no no Haryana also has no capital but Haryana number are more on paper coz Delhi spreads its legs ( NCR). Coz households fall in lower two wealth quintile in Punjab is 4.5% but Haryana this number is 9.3% .. while in Gujarat it is 25.6% and in Bihar it’s 75.2 percent … u can check india in pixels , the maps daily , my finology pages on Instagram they also attach sources with their information .\nThe other thing is that the reason punjab agriculture growth was 5 percent but it’s only 2 percent now coz it has peaked already .. China use to grow at 11 percent but now grow at 6 percent this doesn’t mean China is going to hell , economic growth stops once it hit plateau. The other thing is I don’t know why u keep saying that Punjab is mostly agrarian economy while 20%agriculture contributes in its economy .. Punjab has almost 13000 small and medium factories which is 9th number only low to the states which has ports and their average is 3 times the population of punjab .. the other reason it has the disadvantage of border state where if u see per captia income is less in those districts which borders with Pakistan .. investment is low on that side … Punjab also received 631 million dollars in fdi which is 6th 7th in country …. It is good to talk about problems but I guess media is trying to portray that Punjab is finished , their is nothing while reality is different .\nBTW video was amazing , u deeply researched it and make it clear that this khali bogey is also getting its attention coz of election coming up , they try to stir up the pot with amritpal but nothing happened it will all go away once election are done .

This same words said in last 5min of the video is said continuously by major gaurav aarya that sikhs and khalistanis are 2 different individuals funded by isi. And also in punjab 99% don't support such narrative. Some countries like pakistan uses this as a weapon as they can't win against India and spread hate among the citizens. \nSome country like US uses this to exert the pressure on India when India do some weapon deals with Russia. As an Indian we need to understand this and don't spread the misinformation in any form.\nRespect to nitish rajput for his research and narrating skills

Graphic designer ne history nhi padhi lagta h \nBritish INDIA ke maps me Pakistan ko to include kiya par Bangladesh (west Pakistan before 1971) ko nhi include kiya?\nTimestamps for the reference of mistakes 1:20\nAnd 1:51\nTheek karlo isko\nGraphic designer ko bolo NCERT padhle ek baar modern history ki 1:52

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

Please make vedio on india pakistan relations in detail ?

There is always the chance that Pakistan's ISI is doing this to drive India and Canada apart.

As a Sikh i can tell you 2 things clearly - we don't want to be separated from India, 2) Khalistanis are criminals who're dealing in drugs from Pakistan etc.

Well done India! Canada has become a safe haven for terrorists. Trudeau & Canada are doing the same thing that Pakistan did by harbouring & supporting terrorists and look what happened to Pakistan. Pakistan has been destroyed and has gone bankrupt.\n\nThere is an old saying “you reap what you sow” just remember that Mr Trudeau!

When Bangladesh went into wars with Pakistan to become independent, Pakistan labelled the leaders of Bangladesh as 'Terrorists'. Just because they are labeled as terrorists in India doesn't mean they are. All they want is a sovereign country they call their own. Before we judge, we should find out more

Glad australia doesnt give VISAS like canada does. \n\nLast thing you want is coming out india/ pakistan to another country hoping to be same.\n\n??

Anti - India divisive forces are actively working in the countries like the U.K. the U S.A , Canada , Australia , Pakistan etc . They will never succeed in their attempts to divide India on communal lines again .

Allah pure pakistan di Awaam ko sucsessfull bnaye, canada, dubai , gulf, australia, UK... sab jagah Jaye aur kamyaab ho , aur pakistanio ki help kare achchi life ke liye.. all the best from India..

india has the capabilities to develop 12k+ range missiles...India should build that ignoring the world pressure...because only neuclear weapons can shut down American hypocrasy ...like north korea done previously....i know they have protective systems ..but any system does not fully protect them from a neuclear war...like pakistan strategy

If you are insinuating that India had something to do with this man's murder, that too so soon after Trudeau's explosive allegations, its laughable and deserves to be treated with the strongest contempt. Canada is now rivalling even Pakistan with the number of terrorists being given refuge and eventually, Canadian citizenship! Way to go, Canada!!