Close Reading

I have a small car small house and decent salary in india and never thought of canada or any foreign countries to settle abroad ?

Foreign countries mein life hard hai, job bhi karni hogi sab ko, ghar ke kaam bhi khud karne honge. \nMagar waha rules bahut strong hai, india mein rules nahi hai, koi bhi kuch bhi karta hai, traffic, corruption.

The last message that my Punjabi sisters and brothers in India are only bringing out their problems and are not anti Indian was the most significant message. Thank you for that. I hope we can stop being unkind. \nOur loose tongue (that easily calls any person anti indian or terrorist) is and will lead to our downfall. \nMany of our philosphers have advised us to guard the use of language and speaking... note that we are a country of love, peace, unity and hospitality. JAI HIND

canada ki 30 million population k liye 338 MP hai India ki 1.4 billion k liye bas 543 MP hai. Its high time we increase the no. of MPs in our Country

U hv lived for very shoet time. Basically few months. Adjustung in a new country definitely takes time. So its wrong to to give such a feedback.\nI too stay abroad. Even i felt the same whn i shifted to a new country in the first fewmonths. But now i hv liked it. People abroad get used to doing all the work on their own unlike india where we are dependent on house helpers. We learn to manage time. \nChildren are not under pressure in school. Their perspective changes snd in addition to academics they get to venture into many more areas according to their hobbies.

My humble request to all those Indians who are unhappy in Canada, may please leave Canada immediately and return back to India. The fact is this that when you are kicked and rejected in India then you think of shifting to another country. Canada is one of the best country in the world for those who are not scared of working hard. One who works hard progresses fast. This respected lady is used to servants and domestic helps, that one cannot get here. I am here for just 7 years and I am a senior citizen but me & my wife got very good jobs and enjoying life. No one asks about your religion, what you eat what you drink. So all those who like lazy life please stay back in India. Yes if you want to get a good job you have to upgrade your education. Girls alone are safe even at 2am in buses.

You should have stayed (in Canada) for your kid’s future. \nIndia has very little to offer for its young generation …. Corruption, pollution, poverty, lawlessness and youth unemployment are a few reasons why Indians should run away from India for greener pastures of western countries ?.

Very soon people will witness reverse migration especially to countries like India because India is doing extremely well in almost all fronts nowadays whereas the West is in total chaos.

Very well researched..Such things need to be shared in mainstream media to derail the propaganda run by the Anti India elements...Sikhs are one of the most patriotic communities in the country. People should refrain of relating them to Khalistan..\n\nMoreover, It's high time for Indian Govt to focus on issues faced by Punjab so that Punjabis can have more confidence in them and they don't get the feeling of being discriminated.

Khalistan my foot.. Kashmiri pandits plight is the worst in world still they love India all these silly excuses asking for seperate country cannot be tolerated

Sir, Australian life far better than others developed countries. But Yes, country-side concept is true to help PR in Australia. Bro...their has an invisible policy( any body cannot prove it)which works through immigration policy, treating as country to country...As an Indian I had a good experience in Sydney...We Indian have a good chance to come back in India. Now Good going in India than Australia...but truth is our neighborhood's country people are not lucky like us nowadays. Indian should not be worried because now India, Australia and Canada are same, those are good country , no difference for life and money. 5 to 6 yrs Jabardast Paisa kamao and India bapas aayoo, now is the best policy.

Anyway the moral of the story is .. india is shit country that’s why people leaving

I am a Punjabi Sikh and I choose India over any western country. Jai hind, I will work in India.

video is right but the khalistan supporters jo canada beth ke propoganda kar rye he india ke khilaf nd india ko galt bolte he bahar jaker so ise kuj ni hoga so Canada ho ya India he sab indians hi raho jaha marji country me but apne bharat ko mat bhulo or galt na kaho ,nd i know ab ispe khalistani bhed chaal hi bolegi ? ?

India may not be the best Country but i love India and will never think about leaving my Country.

Now Western countries known Canada as Curry india ??

One of the Major fact is that sikh people feel unsecure in india as a majority ruler country!!

West always want to weaken india ... thier true identity is to destabilise india... Canada is what the true face of western countries.... india should never trust the West...!!

I dont understand the point of all this today. 90% of Punjab fields are taken care by people from Bihar. It will become interesting when say by chance, if separate Punjab country is formed, then later on the current Bihar people demand for separate Bihar in Punjab then annex that Bihar into India. Also to keep in mind there aren't many Sikhs remaining in Punjab, most are converted to Christianity.

I request everyone stop calling khalistani to every sikh this creates tension among all of us and not good for our country…if they ask for any demand it doesn’t mean they are khalistan…stop becoming fools. Stop watching india media channels and social media pages.

India ke liye sikho ne bahut kurbaniya di hai \nLekin India me respect nahi \nWaki sabhi country sikho ki respect kar ti hai\nKabhi kisi bekasur ko nahi mara \nLangar lagate , yahan tak ke corona kaal me oxygen cylinder ka langar lagaa Diya tha Delhi me fer bhi sikho ke saath discrimination hota hai

Your video is biased and stupid at best. You should also cover the reasons for unemployment, and problems in Punjab. The problem is people from Punjab are so desperate to fly out of India, they have no intention or will to grow India's economy. How many IAS, toppers, businessmen you will see from Punjab? Its all about the mindset, look at other states like Delhi, Gujarat, Maharashtra for instance, population there is generating young entrepreneurs who are taking the country ahead. Its a shame that you are brain washing people, where you should educate people why because of such people India is at risk, they use India's resources to grow and when the time comes to contribute to country's gdp they fly to canada and other countries.

Grew up in a traditional sikh family in punjab with the generic beliefs about pakistan being the rival country and punjab's hate towards the incidents of 1984 &1947. Moved to canada when i was 12 years old. Now i hav friends from muslim community, hindi community, afganistan, nigeria, Chinese, japanese and some others as well. We r so close to each other and just enjoy each other's values. We eat what we want and be considerate towards each other's values. I wish something like that could exist in india too. Just geeting along but there is too much division. Unfortunately, seems like its only gonna get worse. Much love to every community in india as well as pakistan. Its possible to get along if we just acknowledge the facts and gain some unbiased knowledge. Thank you for making that first step possible Nitish❤

Struggle is there without maid and house help initially but if have the willpower it will work out ,you at-least got job within a few months if u had did some courses it would work out . I got job only after an almost a year. I never wanted to stay in basement and it’s very cold and u will get sick We need both husband and wife to get things done and manage things .Thats where u missed out on. U at-least had relatives there we don’t have anyone here . I had my kid also here alone in hospital no help. I am not saying it’s easy nothing will be delivered on a platter here but it’s better than India freedom, lifestyle,groups community and more over value for life.Try again if u want and get a condo or apartment at-least next time.I always loved winters and once u know how to dress and what precautions to take winter is very beautiful. So if anyone is coming to Canada please be open minded and keep in my mind it will take at least 3-5 years to settle in a different country and you can lead a happy life here.

Thank you brother, where national media will tag Khalistani to any person who wears a turban and criticise government or ask for their rights and the majority will then push the same narrative too, it’s sad how it’s still happening to this day where government is harassing Sikh youth and imprisoned our brothers falsely and in many cases they torture them just because they wear turban or belong to Sikh religion, barbarism like I saw videos where police tortured Singhs and wrote ‘Gadar’ , ‘Atwadi’ , ‘Khalistani’ on their backs with hot iron rods, even if someone support a separate nation like Khalistan which is approved and accepted by the supreme court of India this is what makes me to hate the government, WE LOVE OUT COUNTRY TOO AND WILL HAPPILY DIE FOR IT BUT ONE CANNOT LEAVE THE LOVE FOR THEIR STATE “PUNJAB” OR RELIGION BEHIND

As an ethnic Punjabi, I hope the violence of 1980s doesn't return. Some Punjabis are simply on isi payroll in foreign countries including some genuinely disillusioned one and can lead to more violence in Punjab. I hope they will listen to reason. Punjab is heart of India. Strong and secular India.\nJai hind.

Sorry history maybe correct but you have shown Sikhs national movement in bad light ..their movements we purely in notional interest ..not for their community alone as you have put it ...they made sacrifices for India which you have distorted as their self interest. Also there are more sikhs in India ...percentage is in relation to country's population ..work it out properly. Get your facts right

You made good video but it is biased towards india not totally 100% true you showing fact what is india wated to show rest of the world. In reality after 1984 rss india planted so many fake sikhs in panjab so you see in delhi some people stand by government no matter what & kanisha blast by india gov. to defame sikhs because western countries were supporting for seprate state after 1984 attack. India involving in each and every country where ever indian sikhs & muslim population last tym in germany gov. arrested indian spy agent keeping eye on sikh and musli. And biggest mistake you have done in the video is khalistan movement hasn't started after 1984 it was before 1947 you have to do more research when pak india was getting devided religion base there was sikh homeland demand that time some leader choose to go with india there was agreement with nehru to give panjab autonomy soverign state all power of panjab in thier land. Still it was written with india panjab will be soverign state in india not capture by india same goes for kashmir by british in writing. sikh were getting khalistan that time if we wanted we would have get it from british we choose to go with india.

Hello Ma'am, \nAgar aap basement main rate hu tuh phir shayed direct sunlight, fresh air from nature and window sighting kuch bhi nahi huti hugi. We are cutoff from outer world and closed inside.\nPhir kaise chain se rah sakte hain k Bahar ka koi nazarah nahi ,I feel horrible. Here in Dubai it is just like India very free and not feeling homesickness or no feelings of not in our country \nI am here for the past 33 years.

Indian people are not fit for a foreign life, they are used to comforts and laziness in India. So when they go abroad they are shocked and taken aback by hyperactivity of any foreign countries. Then they start whining and complaining and start making grumbling videos, which are instantly liked by the other lazy and easygoing Indians who are watching these YouTube videos.

Finally a well appointed explanation of the situation. \n1 thing I really want to know the people who are protesting for Khalisthan from UK and Canada .. will they come back from these countries and live in Khalisthan (just imagine if Punjab is separated from India to become Khalisthan)?\nWhy there is so much protesting in those countries and there's a no-show in India ?, where it really should be . \nThis determines its all political.\nMere Sikh bhaiyo sadda India Tyada India !! (Don't know if the Punjabi is correct)\nJai Hind !!

Bro Canada is 3rd safest country in the world and per capita of India is $2400 and Canada's $55,000. Only housing is expensive that too in major cities

Brother very good story on Punjab,but not only Punjab all India wants Good laws on Implementation on Labour, Good working hours, Good working wages and Action against those Industries Owner and Bad politicians who looted our India continuesly, And Last but least We Proud on Punjab and our Punjabis those give our Lives for Our Country means India

Punjab’s per captia is less coz of Punjab’s major institution and business went to the it’s capital Chandigarh , which was promised to Punjab but was later turned into UT. Punjab per captia is 2500 while Chandigarh per captia is 5200dollars … Punjab university , Chandigarh university , Punjab&haryana high court , punjabi music industry , punjabi film industry , punjabi politician , punjabi students has all shifted to Chandigarh , majority of business that operate in Punjab are headquartered in Chandigarh, the IT companies that were reaching Punjab had limited to Chandigarh .. even though Punjabis live in Chandigarh but this output is added separately coz it was turned into UT. I know some people will come no no Haryana also has no capital but Haryana number are more on paper coz Delhi spreads its legs ( NCR). Coz households fall in lower two wealth quintile in Punjab is 4.5% but Haryana this number is 9.3% .. while in Gujarat it is 25.6% and in Bihar it’s 75.2 percent … u can check india in pixels , the maps daily , my finology pages on Instagram they also attach sources with their information .\nThe other thing is that the reason punjab agriculture growth was 5 percent but it’s only 2 percent now coz it has peaked already .. China use to grow at 11 percent but now grow at 6 percent this doesn’t mean China is going to hell , economic growth stops once it hit plateau. The other thing is I don’t know why u keep saying that Punjab is mostly agrarian economy while 20%agriculture contributes in its economy .. Punjab has almost 13000 small and medium factories which is 9th number only low to the states which has ports and their average is 3 times the population of punjab .. the other reason it has the disadvantage of border state where if u see per captia income is less in those districts which borders with Pakistan .. investment is low on that side … Punjab also received 631 million dollars in fdi which is 6th 7th in country …. It is good to talk about problems but I guess media is trying to portray that Punjab is finished , their is nothing while reality is different .\nBTW video was amazing , u deeply researched it and make it clear that this khali bogey is also getting its attention coz of election coming up , they try to stir up the pot with amritpal but nothing happened it will all go away once election are done .

All countries have their own charm. But being an Indian I don't think there could be a better place in the world than India. Jai Hind !!

If you had an easy life in India where you had a maid, a cook, and others to do all the housework and other work then you will never settle in other countries where you have to do everything yourself!

I am from Punjab and I moved to Canada in 2020. I really appreciate that Nitin has tried putting forward all the major factors that are pushing today's youth to migrate to Foreign countries. Punjabis have not just migrated to Canada, Australia and England, there are so many people who have been going to Arab countries for their livelihood. The major push factors at this time I would say are unemployment, drugs and poor politics. Most of the people simply wants a good peaceful life for themselves being a part of India.

Why does anyone go to Canada if he has a normal livelihood in India Just for the sake of that you live in Canada a foreign country as I think you cannot do anything new there .

Please share all our sikh brothers who love india. We need to work on unit india. All powerful country they never fight but they spread fuel on another country fight so they still remain powerful so stop fighting inside we need to unite.

This same words said in last 5min of the video is said continuously by major gaurav aarya that sikhs and khalistanis are 2 different individuals funded by isi. And also in punjab 99% don't support such narrative. Some countries like pakistan uses this as a weapon as they can't win against India and spread hate among the citizens. \nSome country like US uses this to exert the pressure on India when India do some weapon deals with Russia. As an Indian we need to understand this and don't spread the misinformation in any form.\nRespect to nitish rajput for his research and narrating skills

If going on PR then we shouldn't compare everything with India. It's new country and new life so expect to start from zero and do through research before immigrating especially with family. Fixing home stuffs like plumbing, furniture and all is pretty normal everywhere in North America and Europe.

Sir, please make a video ?? china how to developed country and strategy explain china population contribution in gdp compare to india \nSir china se ham kiya sekh sakta ha please video ????????

what a horrible country India is , life is not worth anything there ,

3 things.. 1-if you have good income in india don't go. 2- if you are bachelor and have good skill and degree better to go. 3- if you are lazy person don't go because You will not get cheap workers like in India or the Gulf countries... because they do not have overpopulation like the Rabbits. Good luck ?

2 months is a really short time to give judgement on a country. You have to give yourself a year to adjust. You are lucky you went when your kids are big and can do everything on their own. We migrated to Australia 20 years back when our son was 1 my younger two kids were born here it was a struggle then but it was all worth it. I love India it is the place of my birth but Australia is home. I am sure many Indians living abroad feel the same.

1886 Sikhs comes to Canada, they were thiinging like you now, There will no sound while they were sleeping, F you guys , If you want live like master like in india why you come to Canada. You guys are thug like Modi then get out of these countries, Filthy H____s

TOTALLY AGREE WITH LADIES. ITS TOO BORING FOR PARENTS IN USA,CANADA, UK,AUSTRALIA, ETC.FOR SOME DAYS ITS OK.BUT,NOT AT ALL POSSIBLE TO STAY PERMANENTLY AS DAY TODAY LIFE IN INDIA IS FAR ENJOYABLE & COMFORTABLE & CHEAP IN INDIA,THAN ALL THESE COUNTRIES. MY PERSONAL EXPERIENCE TOO IN USA.

Ek cheez hai agar hum India mein bacche time se nahi aayenge to bechain hojate hain. Magar idhar bechain hone ki wajah hi nahi. Kuch fikar ki BAAT hi nahi. India is best always a country. But police, safety of women's children's, life ki value hi nahi hai.

Toronto has changed because of the immigration policies of inept Prime Minister Justin Trudeau... since he took power... Toronto is full to hell... bringing immigrants from Pakistani India and other countries that do not have the culture of people born in Canada…they only come to destroy the country and bring them with citizenship papers so they can vote for him and remain in power

It’s sad what the country once touted as the best country on earth has fallen to. I shudder what the Trudeau Govt. would do if they were to manage 1400 -1500 Mn lives like here in India. Their system failed to sustain a mere 40 Mn population. I am not a fan of the Modi Govt. in India but I think it’s time the current govt. under Justin Trudeau focused on the current crisis instead of fostering and sheltering the Khalistanis