Close Reading

Who has closed borders ? Egypt lebenaanon ? ? Who's stopping the Palestinian leaving?

They don’t want to leave their land so badly that Jordan and Egypt are lining APCs and tanks up on the border of Gaza and the West Bank to make sure the Palestinians don’t try to leave. \n\nThe Arab world wants to keep the Palestinians in suffering so that they can use Israel as a distraction because their own record on human rights is much worse.

Very funny they’re all using Palestinians don’t want to leave their land as an excuse. PLO tried to take over every country that once granted them refugee.. Jordan, Lebanon and Egypt with Islamic Brotherhood. Nobody wants that in their country again..

I want to leave this SH!@#$ hole as long as the Tyrannical Tru de Q will be in power. I may actually just cancel my citizenship altogether should the opposition not win in 2025.

The palestinians do want to leave their land but they cant since the border with egypt is closed and no one wants to take them, egypts president A Sisi said it himself... open the border and then we will see what the palestinians really want.

How is everybody missing the false logic that he quietly inserted.\n\nHe states a premise that Palestinians do not want to leave their land. In that case, why not open the border and see if Palestinians come in. If they do not, then his premise is correct, if there’s a mass exodus, then there’s premise was just a way to shift responsibility.\n\nJordan and Egypt occupied the Westbank and Sasa strip from 1948 to 1967 what stopped them from creating Palestine or simulating those countries into theirs? Why was there no prosperity during that period?\n\nThe truth is that the refugees follow the 1948 and the land that was going to be given to the following. The conclusion of demand of Palestine has been in a tug of war between various factions for the last 70 years.

Such a strange answer. Why not let them decide? If they don't want to leave thry can stay but if some choose or need to leave why not let them? That's a blockade. Give them free choice.

Actually why should the Palestinians leave their land? They are not immigrants, neither are their parents and grandparents and ancestors. This cannot be said for the Israelis.

Facts: Palestinians that want to leave cannot leave because hamas will not let them leave, and the arab world won't take them !

Why should the Palestinians leave their land, what kind of question was that?

The refugees DO want to leave but the Arab nations won’t accept them and that’s a fact

The Palestinians want to leave \nThis is just an excuse to not open borders xd

They should leave because they'll be nothing left

Idk why these people are trying to force the image that the Palestinians want to leave \n\nThey don’t want to leave their land it is simple as that

This is the right answer. The Palestinians don’t want to leave their land period

I am certain she wasn’t expecting that answer, that one I also didn’t expect myself but I am 100% with him. No person wants to leave their country unless they are forced to or just want a different experience elsewhere but all people want to live in their country its just the politicians always chasing their citizens away.

you leave now? I left in 2022 Feb. holyshit the healthcare is crazy. If poors are fucked in the US, everyone is equally fucked in Canada.

Sheikh is saying that let them die with hunger and no treatment. Kids dying and elderly are suffering. They need to stay back n tolerate? Huh! It would be better to leave rather than living like animals in Gaza.. but these sheikhs don’t want them.

What about the ones who DO want to leave their land? (Refugees). Will they open their doors to them? (No)

why the palestine have to leave their land... they have to fight to stay

So why did lots of people leave Ukraine? They can't leave because none of them want them because they don't trust them. This guy knew what was being asked. The reporter should have came back with, no I mean just for the duration of the conflict. His answer wouldn't have changed

Israel is trying to make the occupied territories as unlivable as possible for the Palestinians so that they leave and then Israel fully annexes the territories and makes them a part of Israel!… That’s how Israel was created and that’s how Israel has slowly but surely grown bigger!

Perfect answer. Why should they leave their homes.

I was born here and am looking to leave.

What if they want to leave?

They are not leaving their homes land get that through your delusional head

Hamas must leave!

Easy to stop.... leave Israel alone

Why should Palestinians leave Palestine to make away for others? Its their home.

Looks like during this war they have lost their land. This dispute is being settled on the battlefield. Arabs not tolerant to a Jewish ruled society needs to leave

But it's fine for other Arabs in Syria and Iraq to leave their land but not the Palestinians. Hypocrisy.

Meanwhile the west think ita best if they leave as refugees and go to europe or america. Lol

He is 100% correct. The Palestinians have every right to live in their land and no one has a right to force them to leave their land?

After being legally refused a job in Canada because of my ethnicity, I decided it was time to leave.

The palestinians dont want to leave their land? Unless its to flee to the west! Smart arabs

If you’re so sure that the Palestinians don’t want to leave Gaza, then why don’t you open the borders and let them decide for themselves?

Ye, but you didnt mind the Syrians leaving.

Yes ask kids in Gaza if they want to leave or not.\n\nDoes Israel need to be held accountable for war crimes? YES\n\nIS IT Israel’s job to protect Gaza’s civilians? NO\n\nWhy is Hamas not criticized for not providing proper protection to its OWN citizens. \n\nHow is this a Israel’s responsibility?\n\nPeople are so stupid.\n\nI don’t support this war. But Hamas needs to be held accountable for neglecting it’s citizens.

This is what isreal and USA want, they want the palastian to leave, so they can move in.

Most of them actually do want to leave. The Arabs are cynical abd hypocritical using them as pawns

And if the Palestinians did leave their land, they would never be allowed to return

Everybody licking his ringpiece \n\nOf course they dont want to leave their land. But the ones that do. Why dont any arab countries take them in if they are so concerned?

He went straight to the point. They have the right to leave on their land.

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.

I criticized the genocide of my Sikh brothers, sisters and children in riots in Delhi in 1984. That incident is the one that led few sikhs but not all to ask for a separate nation that should be named Khalistan and I want the media to not to call those sikhs “extremists”in foreign countries, we can call them Sikhs asking for separate country, they can not be called “Khalistanis” either because Khalistan doesn’t exist. Also, sikhs and Hindus always got along well. In all India, there are sikhs living everywhere just like Hindus. There was never a conflict or dispute between them. I grew up in a society where my neighbors are all mixed Hindus and Punjabis. As much as Sikhs visit Hindu Temples same goes for Hindus visiting Gurudawaras. How about our film industry, there are so many sikh Punjabis like the Kapoors, the Malhotras, they don’t want to leave India also. I don’t want to my Indian sikhs to make a separate nation. I want the Indian police not to discriminate against certain religion and not be biased. If a Hindu policeman saves a Hindu criminal and wrongfully and falsely put a non Hindu person in jail then it’s purely wrong and discriminatory and same thing goes for a Sikh policeman. How about our soldiers, majority of our soldiers are Hindus and Sikhs, they are protecting India and it’s citizens. I want people of all religions and backgrounds in India to live peacefully and get along.

Palestinian don’t want to leave their land, on point!

Well spoken SIR,\nShe has the nerve to say that the Palestinians people should leave and become refugees

Oh just say occupier just leave

Why do they have to leave, why were they bullied since the thirties? It's been shoved down my throat since birth Israel is right, until a few years ago. I did research, wow effing wow that the US has been involved.

That’s exactly what the Israeli government wants repeating what they did in 1948 Nakba killing Palestinians and displacing and driving them out of their homes once they leave that’s it they are not allowed to come back. Thank you for the befitting and excellent answer to this ridiculous question that many Israeli supporters try to claim ?\n?️??????️