Close Reading

We immigrated to Canada to create a life we would not have been able to have back home. However, not only did we not obtain a better life, we lost the opportunities that we would have had back home if we had stayed there. We came here to be able to buy property, to have secure employment in the fields that we were trained for. We came here to have better medical care. At this point, to see a doctor, we prefer to fly back home and to get diagnosed and treated there because of the long wait times and doctors who are reluctant to prescribe tests and are just passive. They just care about the paperwork they need to complete instead of diagnosing and treating patient. We immigrated to lower our stress levels but they doubled and tripled due to debts, the risk of being laid off or fired so easily . I work 10 hours a day, but I live in conditions that a jobless person is living. The salary I earn does not help me improve my life and to buy a house and to generally improve. The issue is that Canada is being dangerously overrated and is being marketed for what is not true. Hopefully with social media the realities will get out and reach people.

I lived and worked in TO in a few areas for several years. I left in 2016. I am glad I left before it got bad. I started witnessing more racist comments on subway and platforms were becoming too crowded. After 30 plus years I moved to live in a rural area before moving to live in a similar setting to where I grew up in Oakville. I do love TO and it has so much to offer. I worked downtown and just could not keep up. I spent my spare time walking along the beaches especially Scarborough Bluffs and skating at Harbourfront on a weekday. These are fond memories that I will cherish.\n\n I heard that the shelters were over crowded and unhealthy places. I met a nice man in my building who was successful, lived on street for 13 years before successfully integrating into low-income housing. I learned the most from his stories and met some of the most fabulous people in the worst buildings. I had to leave for safety and mental health reasons. I could not see myself remaining in TO without support. \n\n I made the right move in the right time. Not everyone can afford city living. My quality of life and mental health are better but I cherish the friendships I made in TO. My Grandfather was a Mcleod and I am amazed how much you look like my mother when she was younger. She modeled for Ford and volunteered for a local Vet and hospital. I wish you well. I appreciate your honesty. Since I left, I have driven by TO on 407 a few times. I just didn't have the right mix of education and work to survive in the city any more.

We will not work with my one that doesn’t have that agenda well said ❤

Saskatchewan is still reasonable, and with crown corporations, there are some excellent employers to work for.

Lived and grew up in Vancouver. Finally completed my apprenticeship as a Heavy-duty Mechanic. Couldn't find a stable career in the lower mainland so ended up moving towards Northern BC (Prince George). It's completely different over here but I'm happy I can work everyday and housing ain't that bad compare to Vancouver ?‍♂️. At this point, I'm happy with whatever I can get. ?

Can someone change from work permit to study permit?

Unfortunate Truth about Canada as a Canadian who lived here in most provinces due to work. The USA attracts Canadians as a better financial ability & lifestyle and less harsh long winters!

I agree with you grew up in Saskatchewan and worked in Alberta as a RN. Left for USA love the weather in California and capitalism.

So centrally planned economies don't work. Wow. Who would have guessed.

replace the work immigrants with hardworking citizens

It boils down to the Liberal Party, which has been in power since 2015, e.g.:\n- high immigration targets and housing/jobs/healthcare/etc can't keep up.\n- decriminalization/destigmatization of drugs (especially in Vancouver)\n- political correctness, censorship, gender ideology, health mandates, soft on some crimes but harsh on thought crimes, etc.\n\nAs for other things like weather and challenges in finding a job, these were always the case but Canada really started to go down when Trudeau became PM.\n\nI migrated with my family as a teen. Parents (engineer and nurse) couldn't find a job in their field. Mom had to start as a care aide while she re-certify as a registered nurse even though she has a masters and taught nursing in a college in the Philippines. Dad had to settle as an appliance technician.\n\nThe 4 of us lived in a single-bedroom basement suite, but we bought a half-duplex in Vancouver in a couple of years, which would be practically impossible these days.\n\nI make a decent amount niw and own 3 properties, but if I have to buy my house at its current market value ($1.9m), I can't afford it. Even that half-duplex, my parents sold it at 6x during a down market years ago.\n\nThen there's crime and drugs: I've worked in the downtown east side of Vancouver since 2006 and the last couple or so years has been really bad - it's like a zombie apocalypse. Glad I work remote and have moved to a suburb around Vancouver. That said, I'm highly considering moving but it's hard with kids and aging parents.

To much dame taxes the homes are crazy over priced most of the time it’s cold . Oct, Nov, Dec, Jan , Feb, March April cold only May Jun and July and August its worm .I would just move to a different country I think k the states have better option at least you can move to a wormer state and get a less expensive house. My friend moved to Florida and was able to buy a house . 3 bedrooms and 2 bath nice weather to. She is a teacher there. I am thinking about moving sense I work from home as a IT data analyst I can even get a better job that gives me more money over there……. Yes there health care is expensive but at least there wait times aren’t so long . You can. Buy a house for 300,000

This is mostly the marginal explanation. What is actually causing the problems in Canada is PRECISELY the expectations of a high standard of living absolutely everyone has, including brand new immigrants. Who as if they were owed a palace immediately begin complaining about the work they have to do and the fact they're not immediately appointed the king of Canada. To put simply, we have an incredibly spoiled population, a population that expects low prices for everything and has a terrible productivity overall and does not wish to work in the kinds of jobs that every economy needs in order to fuel everything else. Food production is the so-called inceptive value. The more food you produce, the more people can consume it, and this in turn flows through the economy to enable all the other kinds of economic activity. We have to bring in hundreds of thousands of temporary foreign workers from Mexico just to be able to harvest. In the past, Canada allowed immigration from all over the world of people who were mostly poor, refugees, and those desperate for a new life. They worked all the time doing every kind of imaginable job in every kind of condition. They built this country with their perseverance and hard work. The immigrants today, are selected on a points-based system, and the idea behind this is that someone with two university degrees, or trained in a profession, even if they don't work in their field in Canada because they're all sorts of barriers to transferring your education, are not very likely to be criminals or antisocial types. Criminals or antisocial types. In other words, Canada has chosen to attract high quality candidates on the assumption that they would be less likely to become criminals, while they in turn, having been picked from the best in their society, arrive in Canada with very high expectations, and discover that actually they're going to have to work in all sorts of other kinds of jobs and will probably not work in their field, even though that's what got them the points to come to the country. The country. This is the brilliant system brought in by Stephen Harper's conservatives, which brings in people with high education, and allegedly high skills, especially high language skills, so the government doesn't have to pay for their language training, but it doesn't consider the fact that these are very often people with other choices, who are not willing to work in construction or farming or service or retail or all those kinds of things that we desperately need workers in. The reason why we can't build enough housing has nothing to do with local governments and property values. It has to do with lack of labor. This education system, for some unbeknowned reason, is absolutely terrible, and provides basically no skills, training or education for the vast majority of high school students such that when they graduate high school, their forced to go to university or college. Since they have absolutely no training. In most parts of the world you finish high school and you have a trade, or you have some skill to begin working, the kids here know nothing. Nothing. Other than emotional safety, intersectional language, and wokeism. On top of that, the government has brought in every kind of environmental restriction and regulation on account of incredibly loud, but actually small minority of enviro lunatics, who most of the time use these environmentalism as a cover precisely for protecting their high property values in very luxurious and special places around the country, and they oppose logging and all sorts of resource extraction under the guise of environmentalism. But it's actually to preserve their special privileged position often in some wilderness or island, where they might be the only one or a handful of families who got lucky to somehow own a property. Property and so they oppose everything on account of environmental reasons. But it's just to keep people out and preserve their own privileged place. This country also as most others suffers from the illness of dishonesty and lack of integrity brought about by a culture of marketers where nothing is the way it is said to be. Everything is a fine print. And we have gotten used to this as normal. We've gotten used to having credit cards, charges, 25% interest, we've gotten used to being ripped off constantly by all the corporations for everything, and nobody complains and they just borrow more and they just bottle it in and now it's finally coming out. Out. People are fed up of the enviral lunatics. They're fed up of people who complain and bitch one moment about the pipeline and then complain and bitch the next moment about the high cost of gasoline when the pipeline is temporarily shut down for servicing. The problem with Canada is Canadians.

If applicant is not working then can he apply for it…?

Im glad that people are being dissuaded from coming to canada.if you work hard and avoid big cities its great here. We dont want grifters like the harkles here. Why would anyone want to move to vancouver or toronto anyway?

It's the same almost everywhere, I am now a German citizen , but I was at indian embassy in Germany for only giving up my indian passport. The man who works at reception behaved like dog to me and not let me even enter the embassy even after my request.

My income for working on stairs is a bit over 5 thousand dollars for 5 months work. I've been on stand by for the last 7 months. I live in a minivan and am living on my capital, not my income which is a joke.

This is crazy...but it's all a set up to kill Americans...democrats is working with other country to destroy America from the inside out...but our men has been training for this...democrats are traitor

Canada is fine if you have enough money. If you have no money you are a debt slave. \n\nIt's basically a 3rd world country where people with money are fine and people without struggle to afford rent and food even if they work full time.

I hate the transportation system in Toronto. They have no concept of how to build a train/subway system. They spen billions on never expansion of the 401 when the could be using that money on a train system that works

That reporter working for bibi

There’s nothing stopping young Canadian people from studying in India, working part time jobs and accessing their food banks.

From reading the comments doesn't seem like people understand that SA is allied with the US and Israel. Minister says they're not going to work with people whose agenda is removing Palestinians from their land but they are in fact doing just that. SA could easily put pressure on the States but has chosen not to. Actions speak louder than words.

You're spot on with your points. I would like to add one more consideration, focusing on the state of elementary and high school education. \nWhile I acknowledge that teaching is a high-paying profession, it's disheartening to see that teachers, along with nurses, are frequently involved in protests. \nI understand that nurses are often overloaded with their work, but the practice of leaving students unattended to participate in protests can pose challenges for the education system. \nIt's concerning that, in the last three years, my kids' teachers haven't been able to complete their subject curricula even once.

Lol they do not want anything to do with terrorists.\nThats why no country willing to accept them. Not arab or in the west \nEgypt has its own border with Gaza and never gave them daily work permits or access to hospitals.\nJordan ruled the west bank and Egypt ruled gaza from 48 to 67 but non of them even thought about establishing a palastinian state ?\nLook at Jordan. When the accepted palastinian refugees those refugees started a crvil war and killed the king.\nBy the way today 60% of Jordan population are Palestinians.\nHow is it that thier own country do not accept them ?

your time and work are worth appreciation and watching for saving emotions and money!

Chalo, in the end, their got their visas, she attended the funeral, and the officer will face disciplinary action. Let's get back to work.

This journalist either is naive or is working with Israel's agenda.

❤! HI! LET ME 2 START WITH WORDSWORTHS : REALITY BITES!!: OR REALITY ALWAYS BEHIND THE COURTENS OR NONE HOLDS HAQQ/SATHYA/ TRUTH ALWAYS TIMES & PLACES. OR COUNTRY/ NATION TO NATION ITS 11:09 FIFFERS A LOT BECOZ OF MANY MANY MANY SEASONS THATS +VE & -VE AFFAIRES.. WELL: A&A (ASIA & AFRICA) R VERY VERY BACK UNCIVILISED THERE4 THEY R BACK 4 MANY MANY YEARS. \nAS INDEED: THE WORLD 1ST CLASSES NATIONS R VERY ADVANCED THEN A&A ? \nTHE REALITY IS ALL 200+ NATIONS GOT +VE & '- VE WORKS. OR CIVILIAED VS UNCIVILIZED OR LOW DEVELOPED OR HIGH DEVELOPED NATIONS. IT DIFFERS WITH SOIL CUM WATER 4EG: LETS START LOCAL LEVELS= IDLY /DOSA /WADA IN S.INDIA WILL GET VERY HIGH TASTY BUT ONE PERSON GOES TO M.S SAME IYEMS WILL GET TASTELESS. \nSO IF BOMBAY ITEMS USSAL/ WADA PAV WILL GET MORE TASTE IN BOMBAY SAME ITMES S.INDIA WILL GET TASTELSS IN TN+ TS+ K'TAKA. S.INDIA HOTEL NEVER ORDER TEA LIKEWISE NEVER ORDER COFFEE IN IRANI HOTEL !?? WELL: LETS GO 4 INT'L LEVEL IF SOME ONE COOK MUTTON IN AFRICA TASTELESS IF BEAF IS TASTEFULL ?? SO SAME B THECASE IN USA/ CANADA / UK. EVEN 4 BODY WEARING CLOTH DRESS CODE ALSO. IT DIFFERS A LOT. LETS C NOW BAD BAD PRACTICES: IN USA -VE AFFAIRES IS GUNFREE NATION GREAT SINFULL SYSTEMS. CANADA CCP CAPTURED.!?? H/STAAN -VE WORKS H VS M .(SINCE 1947) \nMUSLIM NATIONS -VE WORKS \nSHIA JAMAATS VS SUNNI JAMAATS (SINCE 1400 YRS OVER & NOW ALSO STILL FIGHTING GOES 4EG RECENTLLY: THERE WAS\n: BUS FULL OF SHIA JAMAATS WERE TRAVELLING IN KARACHI- PAAK ONE ARMY PERSON JUST CAME WITH M/GUN & KILLED 100 BUS TRAVELLERS THAT TOO IN TIME OF PM AS DR. N SHAREEF BHAI TIME & PLACES. SO BEST THING P.M SHREEF BHAI CAUGHT THAT SUNNI JAMAT ARMY GUY & PUT HIM IMMEDIATELY IN A JAIL & SENT JAILS KEY TO FRANCE PALACE 4 JUSTICE CAUSE. SO ALL ABOUT BAD VS GOOD AFFAIRES WARS. IN M- NATIONS/ ARAB NATIONS. \nSO CANADA IS 4TUNE NATION BECOZ WHEN ANY NATIONS FIGHTS & PUBLIC GETS BIG PROBLEMS THEN CANADA IS THE 1ST NATION TO SUPPORT & HELP IMMEDIATELY TRY 2 C WHEN THOUSANDS ASIAN GOT LIFE VS DIE ?? IN UGANDA IN 1972 AT PRESZ EDI AMIN WAS SRTONG PRESENT 4 TO REMOVE ALL ASIAS THEN THAT HOTTEST TIME & PLACE CANADA IS THE 1ST NATION WHO SUPPORTED & HELPED SHE SENT MANY PLAINS TO PICK UP TO SEND ALL ASIAN PUBLIC TO OTHER NATIONS WHERE EVER THEY WANTTED TO DROP IN AT THAT NATION BUT NONE COUNTRY CUM FLAGSHIP CAME OUT 4 TO SUPPORT & HELP ALL ASIANS. THATS BIGGEST CREDIT CANADA GOT FRM U.N.O TOO@ @ TOTALLY. NOW ALL UGANDAIANS ASIANS SETTLED IN DIFFERENT NATIONALITIES. BIGGEST C.C TO TWIN GOVTS & TWIN N.G.OS AGA THANKS PLZ Y.A.M

What are you talking about?! This is so devoid of any and all facts, it's literally laughable. We have a housing crisis because too many people want to move here. DEMAND is WAAAAY up, thats why the housing is expensive (see how that works?). We have been ranked second best country to live in, only beaten by Sweden. We are the 24th most ecpensive place to live (not exactly on top). This guy needs to learn how to research. Wow. Dude, I think it's time to go back to school.

What has happened in Canada is actually quite simple. Companies sell products and services. Companies require employees in order to sell those products and services. The difference between what the companies can those products and services for and what they pay the employees is profit. The owners of the companies want to maximize this profit, therefore want to pay employees as little as possible. Scarcity is labour is one of the driving factors behind what employees are paid. One way to decrease scarcity of labour is to bring in massive amounts of immigrants. That is exactly what Canada has been doing for decades. The owners of the companies take profits and invest it in real estate. This makes real estate unaffordable for the employees whose wages have been suppressed. Lower wages also means less money from taxes available for services like health care. We allowed our politicians to be bribed into allowing massive levels of immigration. Stagnant wage growth resulted in lowered consumptive capacity in the economy. This lead to stagnant economic activity and lowered investment into things that would make the Canadian economy more productive. What we have now is unaffordable housing. Lack of jobs. A failing health care system. An educational system where the bar was lowered to accommodate the lowest common denominator. Increased crime and substance abuse resulting from the subsequent hopelessness. Several families living in a single house. People working several low paying jobs just to try to get by. People with full-time jobs that are forced to choose between being homeless or starving to death. The immigrants that are still coming here are sleeping on the sidewalk in front of homeless shelters, or maybe scraping by delivering UberEats.

It's funny. Everywhere I go in Vancouver, they're hiring for cheap positions!\n\nJanitors, baristas, fast food employees, etc.\n\nThose jobs could easily be taken by undocumented immigrants, but the system insists on needing a work permit for those.\n\nAs if foreigners would apply for a work permit and wait a year to take those jobs.\n\nIf the government facilitated something like ITIN or an easy and fast work permit (only for those jobs), half of the job crisis in Canada would be solved

SOOO many bad things about Canada! I agree with you. In a nutshell: A terrible healthcare system (eternal waiting periods and no doctors), No jobs available (only if you want to work low paying security or fast food jobs), the worst climate on the planet, high cost of living, taxes and NO housing! Quebec also has a serious language problem. So leaving Canada makes PERFECT SENSE.

Immigrant come to Canada for one thing only - Money Thinking a job here with the exchange rate of their own countries money is almost double What they fail to see is The cost of living here is also double...Add in the factor of low skill paying jobs And how things work We have a flood gate of new comers Soon you will have Canadians moving out

canada needs skilled n hard working peoples not a lazy like u

I am just wondering if I am an civil engineering major with experience 10 years, is hard to find a job that fits to my major. Or am I more likely to work as a constructor worker when I got to Canada. I am really considering to move with my wife and son to Canada

Unfortunately, some Canadians are relocating to Nicaragua and it doesn't work out very well for either side.

Just watch the Question Period in our House of Commons on September 27th, 2023. When Trudeau finally showed up to work after three days of hiding in his cottage, after he allowed for a Nazi to be honoured in our Parliament.\n\nHis answers tell you all you need to know about our leadership.

I think it's great that people who don't love Canada are leaving. We don't need you. I'm working to change things, to improve my life in Canada. One improvement is to reduce the crowding. If you're just here to economically exploit the country, then I'm glad you're leaving.

You are great, you are doing great work my dear brothers. my India is great. You have open eyes of so many peoples

Great video, and thanks for letting the world know that Canada is going down...!! So sad for us Canadians who worked so hard to keep the country better

I'd want to live here if I could afford to have my own home near where I work. It's bafflingly overpriced and unrealistic and I DO make ~6 figures a year at my day job! Absurd!!!!

I had the opportunity to visit Toronto this past September. The trip began with Canada Air cancelling my flight, causing me to arrive at 1:30am the next day rather than 7pm the same day. Then couldn't get my cell phone to work although it works in every other country I've visited. Finally finding a hotel, it took me and my host (who is from Toronto) over half and hour to find the entrance because of the hotel's reconstruction and no signs. I had always thought of Canada as US-lite: all the good things without our problems. I quickly realized that it was like being in a third world country with flashy buildings. My hosts were looking for a way to get out as soon as possible.

You fail to see that many Indian IT employees see Canada as a Stepping stone till the US Visa gets cleared . I know many fellow indians who first work for microsoft in Canada , then once they have canadian PR moved to microsoft headquarters in US. Same is true for Indian students . It is easier and cheaper to get a MBA or Masters in Electrical engineering in UToronto than in a top US university . Most Students who travel to Canada for education , leave for jobs in US .

Very insightful! (And refreshing.) I’m a Canadian but travel internationally for work, and the points raised are valid.

It worked.

Regardless of what that was intended for, it looks like a knife and can be used as one. If i was there wearing that i would have been arrested also. I would need a special permit to wear that where i live an work, but it would bot be allowed in scholls or govermnent buildings because it can be used as a weapon, by its owner or someone else. Its about safety, not racism. Hes a religious man. Probably harmless, but you cant wear that for safety reasons.

Pierre does a great job at holding himself together, even though he has to cooperate with the gay minister. I know if i had to work with trudeau id be heart pounding angry.

Is it possible to get work while you are studying in the college

Why are they coming here? They can't work and they won't have no place to live or eat? It's miserable for homeless people already ?