Close Reading

I am more concerned whether that is an honest question or a push agenda to do so. That is a simple logic, it IS their (Palestinian) land, of course you can not force human to leave their land to be refugee.

Israel must leave occupied Palestinian territory, stop the blockade and treat Palestinians as humans.

The weight has to be lifted by Hamas returning the hostages and stopping them from using their very own people as human shields and fulfilling their agenda to fill their pockets with billions He sounds like an intelligent man — does he not see the real solution here? This is a clever answer to make sure that the Palestinians don’t inconvenience other Arab nations isn’t it obvious that no one wants them? Where is the brotherly love?

The Palestinians don’t want to be used as puppets/pawns/ human shields/ etc. free them from Hamas oppression. Let them live in peace.

So she’s basically saying \nThat if Palestinian people don’t leave out the country they will continue to slaughter them .\nIf the Palestinian people don’t leave \nIsrael screams (ham)and continues to slaughter them . And if any person says stop that’s un humane isreal screams anti semitism ?

What precedence would be set if a whole nation is killed or uprooted and scattered about due to imperialist arrogance? It is the same mentality that wiped out indigenous people across Earth and transported people across the Atlantic for economic gains. It is the same arrogant spirit operating here. Love for every human on this Earth.

100%. Canada is being destroyed at an ever increasing pace. \n\nJustin Trudeau has been a criminal for many years now and has brought government controlled media and a rapid erosion of human rights to the country, even somehow after being found guilty of violating the authority of his office.\n\nBTW, throughout history, government controlled media has always been described with a familiar word that has lost much meaning through mis-use: fascism.

What? People are dying fellow Arabs have no wish to extract their Arab brothers from Gazza . Its sad but shows lack of Arab humanity.

If avery journalist put himself in Palestinians position we will see much less stupid questions \nImagine you are peacefully living your life have a house and a job and family , you got bombed has to leave and the world instead of calling for a ceasefire , want you to live in tants as a refugee in an other country for the rest of your life , Palestinians are humans they have deginity

HEY, IGNORANT PEOPLE: IN EVERY OTHER WAR IN THE MIDDLE EAST, OTHER ARAB COUNTRIES TOOK IN CIVILIANS FOR THE DURATION OF THE WARS. THE ARAB NATIONS ARE MAKING SURE THAT HAMAS'S HUMAN SHIELDS SUFFER AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE TO MAKE THE WAR AS DIFFICULT AS POSSIBLE FOR ISRAEL.

BEAUTIFULLLLL \n\nIf your heart or mind doesn’t agree with what that Human Man said\n\n\nYou’re a disgusting Racist no matter how much you tell yourself You are Not \n\n☝??☝?

Saudis Have got human rights down pat.

Ask him some tough question about Yemen and if he cares about one of the greatest humane crises in the 21st century! Israel isn't alone in its barbarity!

No one blamed the European countries when they didn’t want to take in Jews and just gave them to the Nazis…\nWhy would I as a European blame the Arab countries for not taking in even more refugees, when it just helps Israel to get away with more human rights violations and displacement of people ?\nBut generally I have lost all my fate in western media. Even if the stick to the fact they leave out important information if it doesn’t suit Israel. Sad thing is I don’t even believe they get paid for that…\nI can only hope other people will be smart enough to realise this and punish our politicians for the involvement in this

Whom they(Palestinians )gonna ask for human rights, the countries who talks about Human rights (west and liberals) are themselves killing people. We resort on west for Human rights it is them who control Human rights, so to whom you gonna complain about HR

What a crock of crap coming from a representative of a country with the most oppressive human rights; they just don't want Palis in their country like most of the Arb world which look down on them. What a silly response.

Sometimes the answer is right Infront of us but for some reasons we humans always want to complicate things.

But why hasn't the Arab world taken action yet? After witnessing 66 days of slaughter of innocent human beings? The whole Muslim world, except Yemen, has no dignity whatsoever. All of these Govts can only speak,that too only some of them are doing. I just wonder how everyone of us is going to answer Allah about each and every innocent life lost, injured and displaced. Just look at our faith, that has weakened to the point that more than 2 billion Muslims feel helpless about the situation. It is obligatory on each and every one of us to perform Jihad and protect the people and land of Falasteen with every drop of blood and bone we have, but we can only say words. This is why we must carry on with the boycott religiously, with regards to whatever we can boycott, except social media ofcourse. And we, as in Muslims must look for ways to pressure our govts to help Falasteen. We must help them financially too. May Allah make us stronger in our faith in Him, provide us with opportunities, strength and courage so that we can all unite together properly to pressurize our govts to make use of our military resources for the reason Allah blessed us with them. Ameen.

7th October attack on Israel was an inside job of Israeli government in order to capture Gaza. It is impossible for a bunch of people to enter Israeli border from 17 different location s which is guarded 24/7. Thousands of Palestinian people are being captured as hostages by Israeli Army the true terrorist of this era the real NaziIf this statement is true that hamas is the reason israel is killing humans in palistine, then why is the Israeli terrorist army present in the West Bank and why are they forcefully evicting people from their homes? It is extremely unfair that being born Muslim is considered a curse in today's world. What Israel has been doing for the past 70 years is unacceptable. If a similar situation occurred with the United States or any Western country, would they receive financial and military assistance? This can be viewed as genocide. It is a cruel and perplexing phenomenon that people choose to turn a blind eye to the innocent children who are being killed.

The reporter speaks of the Palestinian's plight as if it was a natural disaster with no human agency behind it.

Western journalists are Western politicians masquerading as journalists. They don't care about human lives, they are only concerned with pushing Western geopolitical interests.

Why must Palestinians leave their land and let Israel win easily ? No . Yes some choose to flee and be refugees in other countries when Israel should be stopped from what they doing . How about sanctioning Israel ? How about declaring israel a terrorist organisation and bring Netanyahu and the other prime minister infront of the human rights court for war crimes ? Why must the victims be further victimised ? Western mentality is truly toxic and evil . U go after the aggressor and stop the aggressor .

Soy boy Trudeau equates to eighty percent of of your woes a human wrecking Ball

This guy looks like the human version of Goofy ?

Absolutely true! This is intelligently and humanely well said.

Its shameful the rest of the world leaders are making humane responses while the US is funding the killing of innocents. Im so ashamed of my country. As ive grown up seeing lie after lie after lie. I just have no trust left of this government.

Playing politics with civilian lives. Evacuating civilians from an active war one is not only the most humanitarian thing to do, but it is the most human thing to do. We can argue about the symantics later, but the international community has a moral obligation to evacuate every non combatant from the area. Jeez, you're all brain dead with this. No wonder so many civilians are dying.

It's a very good answer. Doesn't hold a lot of water coming from Saudi Arabia, in terms of pushing for obvious human rights, but it doesn't mean they're wrong in this case.

It's the same rhetoric of Eurocentric hegemony to paint a narrative of blame, guilt and shame as if it's the peoples fault, instead of blaming and shaming the ones committing these atrocities against humanity. Their questions are formed to fit the narrative that fits their agenda.

***National Post***\nMuslim leaders should've condemned Hamas instead of fomenting hate\nIf they had spoken out against terrorism, their advocacy of the Palestinian cause would carry much more weight. \n\nPart of the reason we are seeing division, hatred and unrest in the streets of Montreal, Toronto and other communities across Canada is due to the collective failure of Muslim leaders, in Canada and around the world, to condemn the despicable Oct. 7 terror attack by Hamas on Israeli civilians. \n\nIt was a horrific and cowardly attack by a terrorist group — not by all Palestinians, Arabs or the wider Muslim community. It should have been condemned and contained immediately. Muslims who pride themselves as followers of a peaceful religion should have empathized and consoled the grieving Jews. \n\nThere was a lot of time to do this. There was a lengthy delay between the attack and Israel’s ground offensive in Gaza. Instead of taking this time to condemn Hamas’s slaughter, Arab and Muslim politicians and government leaders promoted anti-Jewish hate to shore up their political support. This is nothing less than encouraging antisemitism. \n\nMuslim political and religious leaders, barring rare exceptions, chose to contextualize, equivocate and, in most cases, justify Hamas’s barbarity. What we have, as a result, is widespread hate bordering on violence in Canada — a country where communities have historically lived side-by-side in peace. \n\nThe situation got worse due to the statements made by community leaders like Amira Elghawaby, Canada’s special representative on combating Islamophobia, who did not hide her partisan and divisive outlook by clearly siding with the protesters on Canadian streets, characterizing them as “peaceful demonstrations,” even though we have seen people supporting Hamas, calling for genocide against Israeli Jews and harassing and intimidating Jewish-owned businesses. \n\nOn Twitter, Elghawaby approvingly cited a quote from a Toronto Star column reading, “The stories I have heard are both fantastical and true. Muslims (and others who silently sympathize with the loss of Palestinians lives) are being disciplined, maligned, isolated and targeted at work.” \n\nInstead of reaching across the aisle and consoling the Jewish community, she has instead chosen to focus her public comments on rising Islamophobia. \n\nSeriously? Remember the Muslim family who were killed in a hate-related attack in London, Ont., a couple years ago? All communities, including the Jewish community, across the political and religious spectrum unambiguously condemned that hate crime. And it brought a sense of relief and security to Muslims in Ontario. \n\nRemember how, after more that 50 people were gunned down while worshipping at mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, in 2019, political and religious leaders from all faiths stood behind Muslims and consoled them? \n\nAlso, after the Quebec mosque attack, almost all communities in Canada chose to stand with Muslims. There were images of people in Alberta who formed a human chain to protect Muslims. Similar scenes were witnessed elsewhere in the country. Jewish community leaders spoke out, loud and clear, in support of Muslims and against hate and bigotry. \n\nBut that is not what Elghawaby did. Instead, she makes it sounds as though it is Muslims who are the victims, while failing to mention the barbarity unleashed on Oct. 7. This is not leadership. This is not her mandate. Her job is to promote tolerance as enshrined in Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. \n\nNow imagine a scenario in which Muslims did what they ought to have done in the first place: condemned the Hamas attack, sided with the Jewish victims and dissociated themselves from terrorism. Their voices for the Palestinian cause would have carried much more weight. \n\nWhat we are seeing instead is a rising tide of anti-Jewish hate on our streets, promoted and peddled by Muslim leaders themselves, either by gaslighting the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, or wallpapering it with the political colours of the Palestinian cause. \n\nLet us all come together, not to let hate be poured onto the streets of Canada, but to stand united for a secure and prosperous country. \n\nNational Post \n\nRaheel Raza and Mohammad Rizwan are members of the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism.

The reporter is either pushing for the agenda of ethnic cleansing or doesn’t understand what belonging to your land means.\nThe 70% of the Palestinians in Gaza don’t want to stay in Gaza they want to exercise their basic human right to Return to their own houses and land that was stolen by the Zionists. They look through the concentration camp fence and they see their own village turned into a Kibbutz. This denying of return is a crime against humanity

Exactly,who stealing the land,in this century the colonialism,apparheid are practicing and supporting by west counties whom feeling they have moral, humanity,modern etc they plight,in reality they are Savage

Israël thinks the Arab countries must take all the Palestinians so they can have the land no way give the Palestinians them human rights and stop the hate and killing Free Palestine ??

Imagine a war torn family with 2 kids and the mother and father reach one of their borders, All they want is safety food and shelter. Nobody cares about the motherland when your family is in danger, will they give them asylum or refuge in that case? Or will they keep saying the root problem needs to be fixed to them and send them back to get killed with their children, this is a horrible answer. Palestinian people are humans too and giving them refuge does not mean giving them your land.

He’s right but as a believer and human he should do much more and hold USA and Israel to accountability..stop being their puppet

Let them say that the war is against Muslims. It is a coward's act to destroy Muslim countries by plotting from backside. They even killing kid who playing football . So they want land. No humanity's . So sad for world leaders

What an idiotic question, this question is common in the west by the way. The colonisers are trying to guilt trip others into helping them with their ethnic cleansing!\n\nThe Arab world has let the Palestinians down by not standing up for them. At the same time the only one to blame is Israel and the US because if the Arab and Muslim world stood up then we may be in WW3. This is a lesson for humanity, we have come to the brink of a world war just because one country wants to clean people native to the land by killing them and removing them from their land.\n\nLuckily we believe in Allah and we know Allah won't let oppression go on forever and definitely not let oppressors go unpunished.

The human world, the people with a heart, with logic, with empathy, are concerned about the Israeli Destruction Force, backed by the Worlds Bully America, supporting and encouraging Genocide of the Palestinian people.

The US, UN, and all humanity preachers should be ashamed of what they are supporting.

Honestly it sucks for Canada.. I mean this country has probably everything any country could wish for. From surface to ressources to access on both side to the two main oceans, having a border with the first world power (it can be a problem but a good thing as well) and while climate isn't always the best, it should he a paradise living there.\nAs a French with what I believe is the best and most generous medical service in the world, to think that Canada spends MORE than us and have it a lot worse is crazy.. How did they manage that? France isn't renown for its efficiency..\n\nOne thing not mentioned though in the video which I find even worse than all of that, is how Canada slowly slipped down in freedom status.. More than any other country!\nCanada lost 6 spots in a single year in the human freedom index and got kicked out of the top 10 to land at the 13th spot.. At this rate they'll be out of top 20 in the 2023 report..\nAnd we all know you can easily lose freedom, but regaining any of it is close to impossible.\nGood luck Canada and Australia, you guys are in the same boat at this point

Hardworking, honest , and respectful....are qualities, along with accountability, absolutely absent in Indian culture. Caste system does not teach you respect for fellow humans nor humane behaviour. Etc.

Capitalism is a failed system! It is destroying humanity.

I live in Toronto and it is by far the best place to live in the world. Don't care about high taxes. Go to San Francisco or LA and make sure you don't step in human feces everywhere. You are way off base

It is very painful to us Canadians to recognize that this nation has gone to hell.\nUnless immigrants come from war zones or natural disaster stricken countries, we are going to end up with a very empty second largest country in the world, and even though a lot of disenchanted new immigrants are leaving Canada after a couple of years.\n\nThe key word here is greed, that is destroying this nation. The pursue of the American Dream is contagious, not only by geography but because a lot of people, around the world, still believe in such a naive concept.\nOne has to observe what is happening in the USA to realize, that following its trends, inevitably will take us to the same dangerous reality : a country and a system hated and increasingly becoming isolated.\n\nCanada still has the resources and the human presence to do much better, before it is too late, mind you.\nGreetings from Toronto.

Unfortunately, Montreal is going down too... Been here for 18 years and it's getting worse (lots of road work, homelessness, opioid crisis, rental prices increasing (which fuels the homelessness crisis..) I don't go downtown anymore, it sucks and I don't feel safe. Even the Plateau neighborhood where I live now has a lot of homeless people, needles found in parks, HUMAN poo found in the same parks...). A lot of shops and restaurants are closing too... It's sad! I never thought i'd want to leave Montreal, it has a lot of great things but I want to feel safe when walking at night or taking public transportations...

Human rights in Canada are worst

One of the many issue’s with allowing these people through is the threat of drug traffickers, Human traffickers etc who are hiding amongst them the vetting system is long and over worked, limited resources that the USA ?? are struggling with its a No win situation aside from the moral and humanitarian factor America has the right to refuse entry even under the Geneva convention criteria

This is the curse and the trash of unchecked, free rein hyper-capitalism !!! Few boast about having $800 billion, 900 bilion, 1 trillion, 3 trillions which ofcourse they sucked out of the pockets and blood of these human trash by selling them useless hazardous goods and abusing their abilities and energies for decades !

So, what if they come into USA! It doesn’t matter to me or anyone else. Bottom line is/are they going to be part of infrastructure of USA Citizenship of Reagan’s new Deal Bill of Humanity?\nVenezuela, government really Thinks they can overthrow USA. Yes, they can in masses of people. But! It doesn’t say that the masses of people will have housing, jobs or a place in USA’s economy/physical infrastructure. Eventually, they will all return back to Venezuela or die in the USA. As well as many it has happened to them. Hate to say it. Sad situation.

Human nature , no big surprise