Close Reading

They give you VISA to study , JAWAI nahi banaya tenu

I’m sorry, but this had to be done, the reason being there SO MUCH abuse by those taking advantage of the student visa system, the fact so many of them REFUSE to assimilate, like my generation who was born here had built a community where were able to bring the good of both cultures, here we’re seeing MORE BACKWARDS behaviors \n\nLike the amount of nonsense done is insane, like my own community was progressive and now regressive

I’m sorry, but this had to be done, the reason being there SO MUCH abuse by those taking advantage of the student visa system, the fact so many of them REFUSE to assimilate, like my generation who was born here had built a community where were able to bring the good of both cultures, here we’re seeing MORE BACKWARDS behaviors \n\nLike the amount of nonsense done is insane, like my own community was progressive and now regressive

If their studen visas expire and they don't leave, they should be deported - this is the law. If they were told differently, they were decieved either by your, or by our government. Or by both.?

This is not a legitimate protest, they went there for study it doesn’t guarantee their long term stay with this visa status. \n\nJT has taken some actions lately after having a serious mess to PR and Citizens.

Speaking of waiting lists, I applied for a student visa in Germany in August 2022. I got the appointment in July 2024.

Go home, go home, don't waste Canadian's time, go back to India and then apply from your country for PR or any other kind of visa, your illegal agitation doesn't work for the system of Canada .

Deportation? No their Visa is expiring.

There is a conspiracy going on and no one wants to admit to it. Some secret group of elite people has bought out the government and manipulate the Indians to go to certain countries to the west. Once they have enough numbers they will take over. Imagine the visa students they demanding citizenship but protesting in the millions? Government do not even have enough military for crowd control, let that sink in.

The Permanent Residence Visa for skilled immigrants began as a paid residence to help Canada clear its huge debt burden at the time. It was an idea and some politicians said it worked. But taking in the refugees from failed States is another category altogether. Refugees from South American countries, Somalia, Congo, Rwanda, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan and recently Ukraine have put another class of social welfare recipients without adequate skills. Then the monthly child benefit encouraged some of these unskilled Immigrants to get more babies. BTW....I lived in Canada for 13 years but returned to Kenya 7 years ago. Also, as you rave and rant against immigrants, remember there are real White Canadians living everywhere in the world some entrepreneurs and some working for NGOs. Canada failed by not making economic decisions about taking in refugees.....it wanted to appear charitable without learning from the past.

International students are given student visas here in Canada on condition that they will leave Canada upon completion of their studies. They now have completed their studies. It's time to go back to their country as they agreed on when they applied for student visa.

my experience in Germany is actually very positive. I had studied in Netherlands before moving here. I find it more welcoming in DE as NL. My colleagues are super nice and helpful. I would not be here today without their support and trust. Also NL is more expensive to live than Germany, at least in my time. After having a master degree, I paid over 600 Euros for 1 year job-seeking visa in NL. In Germany, a multi-year visa costed me 50 bucks. Childcare, as far as I understand, is very expensive for non-Dutch or non-EU family. I often see kids going to kindergarten only 2-3 days/week there. Here in Germany, I found easily a place for my son from age 1. Education is totally free. In NL, my master course costed 16.800 Eu/year for non-EU (luckily I had full scholarship), for Dutch students it was 3000 Eu. I remember my classmates went protest back then because of the high tuition fee. And for the language, yes of course it is difficult. But it takes 1 year of regular learning to become sufficient in daily life. And the result is very rewarding. I, myself, did not pay a penny for that, I learnt simply by borrowing books from city library. So it is possible.

Yes deport over due visa

Pls help me av apply for visitor visa in Canada pls what can I do now

Wow international student ! Protesting to the government and they like them to changes THIER policy to benefit them !!!! The government created THIER foreign policy to benefits THIER own people ! IT IS VERY UNFAIR FOR YOU ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT! STUDENT VISA AND TOURIST VISA TO PROTEST WHILE SCAMMING USING FOODS BANKS AND BRINGING THEIR FAMILY HERE WHILE THE REAL CANADIAN CAN NOT FIND WORK OR HAVE SHORTAGES OF HOUSING AT THE SAME TIME FOOD PRICE AND EVERYTHING ARE TOO EXPENSIVE AND PAYING HIGH TAXES OR WORKING AND SLEEPING IN THEIR CAR BECAUSE OF NO HOUSES TO LIVE !!! Try to solved your problem by going home ! Do not force the host country to changes everything for your benefits and at the same times disadvantage to THIER own people ! ????????

They have NO rights to protest. Immigration was not gauranteed to them. A German national in India showed solidarity towards farmers, his VISA was cancelled and he was deported. All the students protesters should be deported bcoz they were here to study not to protest.

STOP GIVING THEM ANY KIND OF VISAS!!!!

Student visa means you study and return to your own country. Samjay?

When you move to ANY foreign country you should know it can be temporary ( even if you plan to eventually immigrate n take up citizenship) . no country is obligated to give citizenship to people on visa... It's their country where they can change any rule that suits them n benefits their citizens.

Trying to influence government policy in a country that is not theirs... that's called subversion. They should be deported immediately and not be eligible to apply for visas or residency again.

As a Canadian citizen from an Immigrant background myself, I’m all for Immigration. However, Immigration cannot be coming for the vast majority from a single country, which is India, as per Immigration Canadada own stats, 70% of international students visa were delivered to Indian students, what about the rest of the world ???? Everywhere you go you see indians, dollarama, tim hortons, walmart, and indians are not discrete. That’s why we Canadians have had enough with Indians, this mass immigration specifically from Indians needs to be stopped!

In Canada, it was way too many, way too fast. All of a sudden there were tens of thousands Indians everywhere and it freaked out Canadians. They were dominating low skill jobs which blocked young Canadians and students from employment, and cost the tax payer millions/billions in subsidized income and welfare for foreign workers. The Liberal government are idiots and incompetent at running the country, and now Trudeau is backpaddling to try to fix what he has broken. There have always been Indian migrants to Canada, but they must enter the proper way to apply for citizenship in manageable numbers. Indians must also understand that temporary workers and students does not mean you are Canadian citizens, and you will have to return home when your visa expires.

It is obvious the Indians want to get out of India, a country over populated lack of opportunities , and the few that can breakthrough the mountain of bureaucracy just in order to get a visa to come to Canada or the United States and once they are in Canada, they go underground and get lost in their community which they start working with slavery wages and that is what happened here in Canada and Trudeau has damaged the image of Canada worldwide

Actually it's not a new Federal policy. Many came over on student visas. Now it's time to go home.

These countries are criminals they lure foreign students to their universities promising them pr and longer Visas this is because these nations have no money they rely on borrowing that is why Western countries have huge national debts,if people come to your university they deserve something in return because you can't just want people's money without offering anything in return and these people don't come for the so called quality education,no,if you check employees like doctors trained in India,Zimbabwe and even Burundi are working in Canada using qualifications from their home countries,one only does a verification,this implies that these nations also offer quality recognized qualifications,India and other nations must now ban their citizens from studying abroad and you will see that these western nations will collapse education is number 3 forex earner in Australia and also in Canada,people must study in their own countries

Tution is fair to every student comes from any country. Not only Indian. Studying is studying, not immigrantsion. No one told you have right to get a work visa while you get the studying visa.\nDon't do anything shame to your nation.

This is Canadian Government's policy change on Student visa status. Due to economic reasons in Canada. Nothing to do with Indian students. It applies to all foreign students in this country.

These afe mosyly Punjabis and Gujaratis who are here usong forged documents.. when they come to canada as students they are expected to go back after PGWP.. Canadian govt should revoke study visa of anyone protesting... As an indian orgin canadian i support this..

Time has changed. After Covid19, inflation went too high. Unlimited migrants have led to housing to a catastrophic level. No idea, why this many were allowed on student visa. Already, refugees are from war-torn areas, which has led to pressure on the economy. They need to help. I feel sad for those who will be affected by the new rules.

I do not get it. Since Indian students on study visa are not even voting Canadian citizens, what power does their backlash has? Should Prime Minister worry about backlash among voters or non voters?

Long story short. She applied for a visa to another country. She isn't telling what country she chose. She is going to tell us what country it's gonna be within a couple of months when she gets it. Hope i saved your time ^^

No, they don’t have a right to stay in Canada. Once the Visa expires they go back to their country. These visas are ridiculous, stop handing them out like Chiclets. student visas should never have been linked to permanent resident pathways, 3/4 of these people haven’t seen the inside of a classroom since they landed here. Biggest international scam ever and the colleges and government are in cahoots.

Time to maintain visa regulation to unruly person not fit to manage code of conduct in foreign land . And , host country to shan illussion of immigrant work force solution.

These are fake students and equal participants in the biggest scam involving commission consultants, bank officials, and the fake diploma mill colleges. So please do not portray a rosy picture of higher education as these students can not even speak English properly. They are doing courses that hold zero value to get jobs that too from fake no credit colleges whose sole purpose was to make money with this scam. Whole ecosystem of corruption was created under this scam, there were even bank officials taking bribes to show enough funds in students account just by transferring money just for one day for students visa purposes. These students are acquiring no higher skills, but only filled the cheap labor jobs. They also lied to immigration officer that they have enough funds to live and will return to home countries after the course is finished. Rather, these students misused the local public services like food banks meant for poor people.

These students and workers who do not respect the Visa rules must be deported for protesting and must be deported and never be allowed to enter Canada again \nThese people bring shame to India and must not be allowed to travel abroad again

How such elements are chosen for Immigration visa by your Govt. They welcome criminals from India. Pl comment on aspect.

They are students they have student visa so they have to get back to their country when visa ended.\nIndia must control its population btw

Student protests? Or so-called student's protests? Many people go to Canada on fake student VISA by forged school/university. Because of these people real students are getting affected.

I know so many students who pay employers money to get their visa changed. They need to be looked by local authorities. Sorry we need the jobs for our Canadian people. International you have no right.

It was agreed once the accept the visa, so once expired, leave the host country. Nothing to protest about.

Go After The FRAUD & SCAM Big INDIA Corporations (College Schools) such as Brampton, Markham and Alberta, etc.\nDon't BLAME = Justine Trudeau.\nAUDIT= International Students, Travel VISA, VISA = FRAUD

Actually these students already told the visa ooficers that they will come back and apply their knowledge in there home country. These people are shameless selfish

The whole idea of studying abroad is settling down abroad for students from the third world countries. However students don’t realise that a country cannot accommodate every one as a permanent residents. It is absurd to think that way. Protest means objection but why is there an objection when your visa expires?

Students came on study visa. They can ask for work permit extension

I came to Canada 18 years ago from South Asia and work really hard to be in a position where I’m now. I’m not opposed to the immigrant anyway but why almost all the immigrants will come from a particular region? I don’t even recognize this country anymore. Canadian morales are down. So many people came so fast instead of learning Canadian value they are imposing south asian problem in Canadian society. People in South Asia laugh at Canada, and called Canadian govt cute and innocent cause they believe what every temp/student put their application and blindly bring them in Canada. I know thousands of ppl came to Canada by tourist visa and then stay in Canada. Govt even giving them monthly allowance. And I’m paying thousands of dollars in tax. Basically I’m in the same level of a person who do not pay tax but enjoy all the luxury in Canada. It’s a fault of This govt.

Really!!? Those Indian students came as a student and with high hopes of starting fresh in Canada!!? They have no right to protest. If their visa expires, they should go back just like any other international students.

Permanent resident status and citizenship is not a right, it is a privilege. These students are on student visa and have no right to demand/protest against Canadian govt. policies. Go home after your studies and the expiry date of your visa, whichever comes first, then apply for PR on the basis of merit.

They're invaders. They're not being deported, they're asked to respect the terms of their visa.

Student visa is a temporary visa ..... it not the canadian citizen problem that indian student can not understand their visa condition. There is a reason why there is english requirement to be accepted into school in canada.. everything is in your visa condition read it and understand it!!!

Students saying they have education loan, house as collateral, then why did you lie in you SOP. The reason why they granted you visa is because you mentioned that your parents or sponsor have enough savings or income to support not only your education but also your living expenses.