Close Reading

In Reality all this Khalistan movement is started and funded by the powerful enemies of India, not even 1% Sikh want this.\nThey cant defeat India so trying to divide and make it weak

People saying it khalistan \n\nThe for sure khalistan is looking more developed tham India?

Punjabis are true Indian nationalist. We understand u deserve justice for whatever happened in 1984. Every wrong done should be punished but didn't which in turns obviously brings further uncontrollable aggression. But still feels U can't think of just Khalistan; Whole India is yours; You have sacrificed a lot for India; Indians love you and have respect for same.

Want To Know Why They Don't Ask Place Where Guru NANAK JI BORN THAT DON'T BELONG KHALISTAN I WONDERED SO WHY INDIA ALONE

Agreed with the video for the most part but what were the changes the government made reaching out to the people of Punjab things didn’t change much like the capital and water rights also the Khalistan movement becomes even stronger because when the people of Punjab ask for rights like the farmers protest people labeled all of them a Khalistani so they feel they are not treated as equals in India

New Jersey is actually mini india....... Brampton is actually Khalistan

The question is, if all the sikhs in India are not demanding khalistan , than why they have to prove they are Indias.\nFor example Punjabi singer !

Indian government is not honest and never be honest in future, because the leaders are uneducated and selected from the gangs not from the universities. There are most difficult entrance tests for admission in IIT and AIIMS for developing a good engineer or doctor but there is no such test for selection of leaders of the countries. India is not growing but it is going down year by year because most of the citizens has been lost their culture. Today you are seeing one Khalistan demand in future you may see such voices from other states also because there is always injustice from the government side. The biggest problem of Punjab is drugs not electricity or good roads , there is no single institution in the country who is educating the teenagers about drugs with a dedicated one hour class in a school. This country is sowing terrorism for future due to bastard leaders and sold media .

I am proud i am ❤Indian Punjabi Sikh , I love my india, punjab mai 99.99% Sikh khalistan ko suport nhi karte , kuch bewakoof hai Jo porkistan ke behkave mai aker khalistan khalistan chilate rehte hai , humare punjab mai khalistan ka koi mudda na hi koi movment chal rhi hai ...but fir bi godi media or jahil anbhakti hum sikho ko khalistani bolte rehte hai , punjab mai aj bi har ek Ghar se Indian army mai hai , jab punjab ke kisano ne apne haq ke liye kisan andolan Kiya tha tab bi humara godi media or andbhakt hme khalistani bol rhe the

Sikhs are amazing when u contact at individual level. But I had bad experiences about them in Canada. They are very territorial about Canada and doesn't respect other Indians. They were rude just because I am not Sikh. That was a totally different experience than what I had in India. And whatever problems Punjab has faced almost every state has faced them. That's not an excuse for Khalistan. Pesticides and Cash crops are grown across India. Wake up guys. Earn your respect. Respect is not by making songs and drinking all the time. You've to work hard for it.

Indian Government always ignore punjab\nno jobs in punjab\nonly drugs are supplied in all over punjab\npunjabi’s love india\nour grandparents have seen 1947 nd 1984\nbut new delhi doesn’t care\n\nid new delhi wants to remove khalistan then they must take some bold steps to improve the living standards in punjab\nthey should block the drug routes in international border area\nthey should start some good industry in punjab so that young punjabi’s can live and work happily in punjab

Not mini india it’s mini Khalistan sh..t

The double standards being meted out to Sikhs in India only highlights the demand for Khalistan.

Mini India nahi khalistan hai cannaddaa

Mini india nahi mini khalistan hai ??

Yeh sach hai Punjab ko kuch nahi deta india es liye supporter jiada ho jayege khalistan k

not india western khalistan enter own risk?

Mini khalistan h ye mini India nahi

Mini khalistan not india

young brother Hindus are 60% of NRI in Canada. But let you know we all are punjabi first. they all loved helped each other. Hate is new thing on religion base for Punjabis. Talwinder singh parmar we never even heard of him I lived very closed to his house. One day at the airport this guy appeared with eight nine people with garland and were told he is separates . Dr Jagjit singh chauhan was presented as a leader that wants Khalistan . He was high level Congress leader. After so much life lost hate created This bastard went back to India and died peacefully in his bed. While thousands of innocent peoples life was taken and labeled as terrorist that are killing Hindus. I am atheist but i hope i go to hell to meet Indra and sons along with some others from her party All this hare dead and destruction of Punjabis is all because of one evil lady. that wanted absolute power and control in India. She spend Billions to create hate among Punjabis.

Also advantage was taken by Pakistan after 1984 to support Khalistan movement along with UK and US trying to have a whip at India.

Indian govt put that bomb in air india flight. Khalistan zindabad. Hindu shaitani murdabad

I m sikh and I support our sikh nation KHALISTAN.....we not forget 1984 ..and never India to forget this.

excellent analysis of the Punjab problem... Khalistan is not at all an issue in punjab.. economic reforms is the need... Punjabis n Sikh are brave patriotic people of India...let all Indians know this... by labelling every Sikh as Khalistani, we will be doing more harm to our country...\noverall a great video

Main accused of kanishq bomb blast was ripudaman malik who received 400 crore from government of india and obviously government denied,\nRipudaman Indian citizen was cancelled in india and become wanted\nLater as soon as bjp come in power they provide ripudaman malik Indian citizen in 2019 and he met few rss leaders in delhi then visited panjab, later he caught carrying 400 fake sikh script which is illegal to sgpc via china and got killed in canada by private killers\n same with jagjit chuahan, he started spreading khalistan name in india and Western country after he loss MLA election, his citizenship was cancelled by government but as soon as bjp came in power they provide him Indian visa and he met rss member in delhi then he start living in panjab again and died natural death according to age, he also mentioned he's descendant of maharana pratap and he is willing to bring back his 'asthiya' to india, wonder how every khalistan top leaders including subramaniyam swami were directly linked with rss or they planed all this back then in 80-90s

a bomb India rao nay blaste ketay c ,hum punjab vich khalistan chahiya

Already these Khalistan supporters have their own state in Canada then why do they need separate country in India?

Hi, bro you are doing a good job, you told many knowledgeable things some of them are right but some are not. You can make a single video on Punjab regarding that Punjab was also one country earlier time. In 1947 Punjab was combined to India. People who are asking for Khalistan they are just asking for their old Punjab.

Love you boss. Khalistani bolte hai. As you said we don't need but Canada jana hai and leave India. Indian signal follow karta nhi aur kya karega. Hum Canada ko khalistan bana denge

As an indian sikh i confirm India is anti Sikh now and earlier too Khalistan Jindabaad

I really like the video !!! It’s the first time some one in India and being a Hindu tried to be unbiased about the Sikhs . Thanks for this????. But still this video was not successful to touch the main issue off the Sikhs and that is Why the Sikhs did not asked for Khalistan or a separate State in 1947 ???????? The answer is that time Sikhs were not considered different than Hindus !!!!!! And Sikhs were not alienated and targeted . The issue of Khalistan raised because of anti Sikh agenda of Central government where they patronize Hindus and alienated Sikhs !!!!!

Sant jairnail singh Bhindrawale never demanded khalistan and not even single FIR was filled against him. He was just targeted by government at that time and destroy his image by saying him terrorist. He just wanted punjab to be drug free and educated but government did not want this. We as a sikh are never supported by any party . They hate us. That’s why we want separate state. I am from todays generation and who said only elders want khalistan . Still now if we ask for rights in punjab , we are sent to jail,, they we support khalistan moment which is ultimate solution because it’s reality people of india and Indian government can never appreciate our contributions towards country which are always in majority.

No one in India wants khalistan and true sikh people will never demand the same. What i feel is that sikh people have always been radical but they have always fought to unite and save the oppressed never demanded for a different nation. Even our gurus never captured any land. I hope that everyone follows ek on kar teaching of guru nanak dev ji and all this issue of khalistan comes to an end ?

India ka naam hi change karke Khalistan kardo. Problem solved.

I am a Brahmin married to Sikh I can assure you Sikh never wants any Khalistan these NRI bas..rds are just looking for opportunity to debalance India because Muslim and Hindus are already in bad terms they want Sikh and Hindu should also be in Bad terms

Very well researched..Such things need to be shared in mainstream media to derail the propaganda run by the Anti India elements...Sikhs are one of the most patriotic communities in the country. People should refrain of relating them to Khalistan..\n\nMoreover, It's high time for Indian Govt to focus on issues faced by Punjab so that Punjabis can have more confidence in them and they don't get the feeling of being discriminated.

Khalistan my foot.. Kashmiri pandits plight is the worst in world still they love India all these silly excuses asking for seperate country cannot be tolerated

Great video and very grateful to Nitish Rajput and team for bringing up the real issues.\nAlso for letting people know that Sikhs in the majority are not in favor of Khalistan. Not every Sikh is in favor of Khalistan and the ones wanting it are not at all present in India.

Best video watched so far and its true only sikhs outside of India wants khalistan not Indian sikhs

This was the exact situation which I explain my friends. I hope every person who has watched the video might get a little idea of the current situation of Punjab and Sikhs. And I must say that majority of Sikhs loves India and doesn’t support the Khalistan Ideology. But I still hope that Sikhs who suffered in 1984 must get justice (because delayed justice has brought some people with disappointment) and there should be more development in the State of Punjab.

Australian intelligence agencies also recently announced that Indian officials targeted their own Hindu temples in Australia with graffiti just to tarnish Sikhs image when the Australian pm was visiting India so Australia authorities would share their intelligence information on Sikhs living in Australia. India is just making fools out of western leaders because they’re too gullible.\n\nJust thinking if Hindus can do that to their own places of worship what they wouldn’t do? Like maybe even blowing up their own Indian airline in 1985 killing all passengers and then blaming it on Sikhs so they wouldn’t get any sympathy from the world when Indian government attacked the Golden Temple of the Sikhs in 1984 killing thousands of Sikh men women and children just to teach them lesson also so nobody would then support their cause for a homeland (Khalistan)?

Jisko bhi khalistan chahiye... Woh log india chodke canada me khalistan banaye. Indians ko india me hi rehne. Apna ghar canada me banao

I hate Sikhs. All of them love khalistan and try to destroy our India. ?

You are not SIKH or PUNJABI if you support indian media , hindu raster but you against khalistan because you know actual conditions of punjab but ignore them , and most of people jo bol rhe hain ki hum sikh hai but india se love krte hai ye wo unme se most of accounts vaise hi fake hain, hum lokk india ko hate nahi krte we love india and most of freedom fighters v punjab se hi hain india me but you don't understand conditions of Punjab so ik cricketer aggr catch nh pkkd pane pe khalistani ho jata hai or uske baad 3 3 baar brickets todne k baad wo indian ho jata hai tu app samj hi sakte ho loko ka mindset kaisa ho chuka hai

video is right but the khalistan supporters jo canada beth ke propoganda kar rye he india ke khilaf nd india ko galt bolte he bahar jaker so ise kuj ni hoga so Canada ho ya India he sab indians hi raho jaha marji country me but apne bharat ko mat bhulo or galt na kaho ,nd i know ab ispe khalistani bhed chaal hi bolegi ? ?

brother please dhyan se baat ko sun na, brother you are the best, mai punjab se hoon, tumhari baaten sch hai bro or tumhne boht mehnatbse research ki hai video k liye, bro mai har ek ko yeh batana thik nhi smzhta kioke bro har koi image bnayi betha hai or sun na hi nhi chaahta or boht log sirf andh bhakt ban gye chahe kisi k bhi ho sirf ek side dikhtinhai isiliye unhe smz nhi aani yeh baatein, mere veer aapne boht sahi baatein ki hain lekin aaap bhi socho k godi media ki traaah ese boht se kaarn hain k kuch baatein aapke tak bhi nahi pahunchne dete, mtlb aapko bhi kyi baaton ka pta nhi kioke sach kisi k saahmne nhi aane dete hmare india ka media hi kuch ese ho gya hai, bro but ek baar dubara deeply sochna or ek video or bnana k mai punjab se hoon mujhe boht pyaar hai hmaare desh se india se hindostan se, lekin bro boht kuch esa ho raha hai hmaare saath k hume or kujj bhi solution nhi dikh raha khalistan k ilaawa, bro hum sikh hain hum desh k liye jaan bhi dete hain or dete bhi rahenge apne logon k liye , but dhyan se socho hamari jagah par rakh kar apne aap ko, k hmaare guruo k granth sahib ka apmaan kiya jaa raha hai uska kahi par koi hme insaaf nhi de rahe, boht se qatal ho rahe hai sikhs k, or naam gangstro ka lgaate hain, uska koi insaaf nhi de rahe, or jail me se gangstrs ka interview dwa rahe hain woh ban nhi hota lekin agr koi sikh kuch bhi sahi baat bole toh uska channel ban kar dete hain, koi bhi violence na kre sikh toh bhi use khalistani bol dete hain, peaceful treeke se koi kahe k nshe drugs khatm kro punjab se uska koi soloution nhi de rahe iske ult agar koi rokna chaahe jaise k mainya tum soch lo k boht ho gya mai ab awaaz uthaunga drugs k khilaaf ya kisi bhi baat k khilaaf jo glt ho rha hai toh pta kya krte hain, usko fake case bnaake jail kar dete hain ya kuch na kuch krke mrwaa dete hain, or agr mai ab soch lu k mai bolunga aaj se sb ko sch sch btauga toh bro mujhe bhi mrwa denge ya toh or ya fir mujhe gangstr mrwa denge, ya fir jhutha case dekr andhr kar denge, or aap dekh sakte hain k har var esa hinhuya hai, ye( co-incidence toh nhi ho skta na, or esi boht si 100 baatein or hain , isiliye hmaare paas koi hume or koi solution toh btaa do

Main bhi Punjabi sikh hu main india ke sath rehna chahta hu\nMain khalistan bilkul nahi chahta\nMain kya pura Punjab 99% nahi chahta khalistan bane\nYeh to bahar ke Sikh hai wohi esi harkat kar rahe hai\nI proud to be indian

Sikh having highest population in Canada in terms of India and also they are facing racism , discrimination, language problem, low salary such issue in Canada this would mean they may demand a different khalistan in Canada also..

Jab koi Punjabi apni problem ke upar baat krta ae to usko Khalistani bol dete ae.. bina matlb k Punjabi singers ko target kiya ja raha ae. Sidhu moosewala ne sirf 3 mint baat ki thi Khalistan k upar OnAir channel pe(he only talked but never demanded separate state), aj tak usko ek dead bande ko Gali di jati ae. Sidhu k daddy ne ek saal pehle army se retire hye ae. Yeh kisi ko ni ptta.. Sidhu ne corona time sabse jyda Help poor hindus ki kri. Par Kya bole abb..Ik normal indian ko andaza bi ni ae Punjab aur Punjabis ki india ko Kya Kya den ae..

I must say you have a good skill of spreading Indian govt propaganda in a way like it was out of great research. We are are fed up of all these sharma verma and rajputs sitting in Delhi spinning conspiracy theories against sikhs. According to your rogue analysis the entire NDP party is infiltrated with Sikhs and sikhs are holding canadian govt to ransom. Is it not true that successive hindu majoritarian govt have done genocide and extrajudicial killings of sikhs in 1980s and 2000s for muslims to appease the hindu majority voters. After pannu made a video to threaten hindus to leave India entire Canadian parties condemn it and assured safety of hindus in Canada. In comparison every single day a hindu leader of Indian parties calls muslims to go to pakistan and labells sikhs as terrorists and no judicial system or political parties and so called independent journalists like you have guts to call it out. Its not the sikhs to want so much khalistan its the treatment of India and its majority with sikhs that creates the demand.