Close Reading

So we subsidize Air Canada to travel them home. Where they will be sheltered from the Harsh Canadian Laws. Back to the loving arms of their native country.

THOUGHT EXPERIMENT: If 100K Canadian students went to India for university and demanded the same rights these Indian students are wanting, what would the Modi government's actions be? Methinks fire hoses and tear gas would be the answer. Non citizens visiting in any country have no ***RIGHT** to be in the country they are a guest in. They have alternatives, like going home and enriching their own native lands.

When your forefathers arrived in this nation it had 100% original Canadians, the native. This land was stolen from the natives while the white race slaughtered them, well, you know the rest…\n\nNow you are complaining about others settling here, that is very rich…

Irony is when you realise that the immigrants themselves are complaining about mass immigration! Imagine what would happen if native American tribes complain about white people colonizing their land!!!

White people who are saying that it’s there country. Where they came from? They are Europeans. Originally it belonged to natives which Europeans took from them by force. Stop saying that it’s our country. Go back to your history first.

I think that the indians coming to Canada are hardworking, and integrate into society, Canadian universities have benefited more from them than they have from Canada, Could there be a cap on number of legal immigrants though? Yeah possibly? but then put a cap across various nationalities as well\nHowever one could Argue That millions of Europeans came to Canada and left the natives in poverty, Also the west which loots resources and stuff and then they have to make their living elsewhere \nAre the migrants peaceful? Yes, do they love Canada? Yes\nYou can argue about the volume of immigrants, but then that's the Immigration and Govts fault to a certain extent

I'm always amused when a White North American complain that they are being overrun by immigrants and feel like foreigners in their 'own country'. Imagine how the native Americans felt....

I feel sorry for the Native American tribes - too many whites came in an took over.

“student visa” fraud leading to mass influx of fake degree people stealing jobs from natives that live there

just like europeans adapted to native Canadian culture. What a joke .

Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Tamils fron Sri Lanka, Punjabis, Malaysian Indians, Singaporeans Indians, Fiji Indians....and many are all look like Indians. So don't misjudged that they are only from India. Canadians whites are not the natives. The natives of Canada are the known as red Indian tribes like the Apaches, hawk, Cheyenne and many more , where are they?

Canada belongs to Native Americans, not white people.Its funny white people talk about it

LOL, so the white or native people are broke, poor, homeless, junkies. Good job for the newcomers coming in and making something of themselves.

White guys kicked the native indians out, so why can’t indians kicked the white guys out? ?

Imagine how the natives felt when they were replaced ? modern day colonization

She should go back to her country since Canada is stolen from native indigenous people!

I wonder if the Natives asked the same question during the 15th century ?

Let's accept the fact 90% Canadians are immigrants....the actual citizens are Native Indians.... Not to forget that Punjabis are hardworking and tax paying community....that contribute much to Canada's development....

I bet natives felt the same way back in the days lol

Lmao , imagine doing genocide of native Americans and telling others to leave

I really don't care if I can't wear or have a knife neither can anyone else or let me carry a knife one or the other making special laws for one person be it religion or what ever the excuse just is not fair I don't care who is in the right or wrong here what's wrong is making laws the cater to some and not all native Americans can't carry ceremonial knifes so why can he

You obviously havent been to the united states! The land stolen from the native Americans and given to foreigners!

There's harrasing and there's telling them how it os from a native citizen,you go to theory place and you cough wrong your in trouble,,most of these won't go hone and actually help as they love the benefits and won't be allowed back in..

Having a visa does not guarantee you entry. The purpose of the visa is to give you the opportunity to knock on the door and ask for entry. Then the officer has the right to make that decision 'yea or nay'.\nAll of the information you are giving is nothing new.\nI am living here for 35 years and those questions have always been asked. My siblings have been in Canada for 60 yrs...the questions have always been the same.\nIf certain countries' natives have a high rate of illegal overstay, people coming from those countries will be thoroughly vetted.\nThey are lucky the officer let them know upfront, that illegitimate overstay means rejection for the next application. Usually they do not give that advice, and when you apply the next time after overstaying, you are rejected without explanation.\nIf you want to stay longer and you have no schisms going you apply. That's all.

To all of you in the comments section who are ridiculing non-European immigrants to Canada, I will remind you of your heritage. You are all either first generation European immigrants or 2nd, 3rd, 4th (and so on) immigrants to Canada. The only native Canadians are the aboriginal people. So stop acting like this was your country first, rid your hearts and minds of Rac1sm and mis3ry, and embrace cultural and intellectual diversity. There is a lot of strength and power in that. Long live Canada! ??

Imagine what fear mongering shit the natives would've said when the settlers came. Or when the brits came to India...wait...its only unfair if one minority gets a place to themselves. Not like more than 80% of Canada is still white as hell.

My heart goes to Natives when they saw Europeans invading their native land.

Not denying that the situation of Canada has worsened over the past few years. but watching this video, it puts into perspective that change is part of country’s growth. Imagine how the natives felt when they saw all those people taking over their homeland. So history repeating itself ?.

And why don't Canadians follow the native Indian culture?

Lack of competitiveness of native Canadians who use government jobs to keep themselves secure. Military jobs which invite their wives and husbands to work, and all kind of discrimination and segregation towards non-Canadians and immigrants. Law 101 of french language in Quebec, etc. Canadians are in general very discriminative towards immigration, and that has a cost.

European are not only in canada. Also USA Australia New Zealand Brazil Soth Africa and some other places.where are those natives in these countries?the canadian natives are suffering since 400 years

should interview the native americans(not idians ironically), about their thoughts on all of this.

Did the White Canadians adopt Native American culture and language when they moved to Canada??

Canada belong to the NATIVES apart from them we are all immigrants. if are are white you should not be too proud Read about the history the ethnic cleaning of the natives.

We should have adapted to the native indians then. Stranger in your country lol...

I’m Ojibway ORIGINAL Indians of georgein bay the real CANADIAN native people to this land!!! Trust me they have not been ignored and there are plans for a push back.

To all those people saying the Indians took your jobs. You’re full of crap. Tons of work in this country to do. You are just too lazy to look for the right one. As much as I dislike seeing some of them making a bad name for the rest of Indians. The ones I know are very well educated people who come here to work. I’ve never seen a homeless Indian or one walking downtown drugged out of their faces. Every crack head and homeless person I see in any city in this country is straight up white, including the ones in your video. Go figure. Also, what you feel now is what the natives felt when you white folks came over, only difference is that nobody is rapping or killing your kids and separating families. God bless you all.

In the comments there are a lot of people who think that it was ok to replace the natives but it’s not ok to replace their non-native asses. Weird stuff.

So first I am not Indian but if the natives can’t get off their arses to get a job or develop their own businesses then they can’t blame the immigrants to leap frog them into a better lives so moaning about this self inflicted misery and the Canadian ?? government should make local a priority to develop rather than importing immigrants into the country if they can’t develop their own native population..

Canada does need lots off immigrants to stave off a demographic collapse. But immigrantion means housing issues. And it's not like the US or Europe where most of the immigrants will be on the lower-side of the skilled labor pool: the average immigrant to Canada will be better educated and have more earning potential than the average native. They're going to make more and buy better houses. That WILL cause social problems, no matter what you think of the issue.

The question is who's native land is it?

I feel bad for the native americans ?

Interesting video, lots of Indians or people of Indian orgin are also leaving Brampton. They also state it's too expensive. 30% as per news of late are moving back to country of orgin. On the idea of adopting culture, did eurpeans adopt culture of Natives, where are the Natives, to which land did they go to? The culture of those who created residential schools what culture of values is that culture? Was it not that Natives of this land forced off the land, forced into schools taken away from the parents? What happened to treaty rights? We were welcomed here. We did not invade. We did not force our culture on to others. True many immigrants have come is this the fault of those who choose to have pets and no babies? is it the fault of governments promoting smaller house holds in which no parents live with the childern to help raise grandchildren due to expences. It was the coroporations that made the split of family here. This is also causing Indians of older generations to leave the parents, to live a free lifestyle. who will rasie the children? and who will help the parents when they are too old? 100 years back Christians had the same culture of Indians. Parents, grandparents and babis lived in the same household helping one another. Less cars, less insurance, spliting the costs, no baby sitting fees, no old age homes. Know even in India adopting the west coroporate culture have old folks homes. The media and TV in bed with coroporations have made people selfish that they will not stay together. Indians are in the same postion as whites. The older gen is left to fend for them selves, in the coming gen who will baby sit the kids, they to will get pets, it will be too expensive for them to have kids.

I wonder how the native americans felt ?

A) No doubt there are many Indians who dont adapt \n\nB) But who gave whites the permanent right to kill natives and bury them and call it their place?

I live in Surrey BC. I'm surrounded by Indians. Not native Indians. I'm talking about Indians from India. They are becoming the majority of the population in Surrey.

Stop complaining you did that to the first nation / native tribes now enjoy.

Most people who complains about migrants are usually bums , they don't want to work but once they see migrants start a business or work somewhere all of a sudden they want to take that opportunity from them , if all native people work hard and take all jobs ,their government would not have to allow migrants to come in

Did the white Europeans adapted to the natives society ? Lol ? . The pot is calling the kettle black

Israeli Jewish people's are from Europe, after worldwar2 they settled there under British empire, Palestinians are native to that land ??,..