Close Reading

Why can't they better their own country instead of trying to jump into ours? My grandparents were immigrants, but came to the states the right way

During the 1930's media in various countries made immigrants and asylum seekers out to be this horrible thing and demonised them. This came after a huge recession in 1923, the Wall Street crash, and the subsequent dramatic rise of far right parties in various countries, specifically Italy, then Germany and Spain. \nFast-forward to modern times. 2008 saw another global recession. Once again politics swung massively to the right with countries like Italy (once again), Hungary, Austria, Poland and Sweden, voting in right wing governments, France ending in a run off that narrowly defeated the far right, Belgium and Spain looking likely to be heading into heavily right wing governments at the next elections, whilst the US and UK governments both saw their politics swinging far further in that direction, especially the UK right now whilst led by an unelected leader who is demonising people in ways that would make Trump look soft. One of themajor rallying calls: immigration. The way media report on this becomes increasingly demeaning and hateful. During the 1930's much of the European media and even as far as the UK was ramping up the scorn against the ever increasing influx of Jewish immigrants coming from Germany. Even into 1944 there was a vast amount of demonisation of them seeking asylum, despite the knowledge by this point that there were horrific conditions in camps where extermination was becoming ever more apparent. The Nazi German government in 1936 passed laws that enabled them to revoke citizenship and stripped away laws on human rights. It would be great to say that these poor souls who were being demonised in their own country were accepted into nations who could see what was going on and who wanted to help, but that just wasn't the way it went. Media played out as it is now, leading to rejection and a greater number of deaths as a result of this. The way the UK government is currently working, it actually sounds like the maxi government of the mid 30's during the time of the Nürnberg laws. \n \nThe world feels far smaller now with double the amount of people and with things like social media playing a huge role in the lives of many. The ease of access to people around the world has made issues seem to stretch to far more countries now, whereas back then it was a time of empires. I get that there will be many here who support Trump, many who support Biden, there will be Brit's who support Sunak and the rather vicious words of Suella Braverman, whilst others will be more on the side of Starmer (I'm well aware of all the other parties but they don't stand to gain as much). There will be French people backing Macron, whilst others back Le Pen. We could go through each country all the way to the battle between Fujimori and Castillo in Perú, and the stories are much the same, but how will history judge us when people look back to this time? Will it be another occasion where we demonised those trying to escape the horror of the place they had the bad luck to be born in whilst we were luckier? \n\nI know there is hardship everywhere. I'm struggling more than most and I know I can't keep living this way. However, I don't want to be a part of history people look back at and say ‘if only they did something to help prevent this.’. I would rather be a part of history people look back upon and say; ‘that was a boring time period where nothing important happened’. It's already too late for that. Instead I try to remember that, though I was born into a family who never really wanted me, I was lucky enough to be born into a country that could support me during the hardest times. When you look at immigrants, remember that every one of us has immigrants in our family tree somewhere.

Thank you democratic party. The democratic party has aloud this to happen. I say round them all up and send them back. Let them do it the right way not just run in and go on welfare and get free housing and health care. We can't take care of our own people how can we take care of millions of illegal immigrants? Just asking and saying

The same people saying that they should start a revolution in their own country forget that the US government was the one that started the problems in those countries in the 20th century, with all the CIA-aided coups and far-right military dictatorships. One must also not forget the problems that the United Fruit Company brought to Central America. If anything, the US should embrace these people with open arms. There always will be housing. If the US stopped zoning every square inch of its land as solely single family housing, we could solve the housing crisis and accommodate a lot more people, Americans and immigrants included. That being said, the federal government needs to allocate more resources to allow these people to enter in a proper manner, something which Biden certainly hasn’t done. This is the land of opportunity, people seem to forget that. I bet the coming of thousands of people into Ellis Island in the past two centuries wasn’t labeled as an ‘invasion’.

they need to go bk and fight for their own country. they have the same if not better natural resources we do. wth? my family immigrated here fron Greece ?? they came thru ellis island. they came the right way the legal way!

Don’t let any of them in. My family had to come to America the right way. Not as illegal immigrants. They don’t have the right to come here and use up tax payer money, they are not tax paying citizens. They should all be sent back

Its not right these scum think they can demand a right over legal immigration they demand this if they just put more effort into the country they are born into then mibbi they wouldn't need to leave then when they do come they start to celebrate Mexican or what country they left and keep there culture you know what just stay where you are

The amount of immigrants I see illegally enter and cross into El Paso are insane. I know this from living right next to it all. We are talking at least once a week seeing 8+ individuals at once or even more. . . Women, Men, young Teens and even children. . . They enter our homes to find a safe haven and flee from border patrol that is roaming the streets and it’s a constant battle of keeping your home safe from people that may or may not be good people. It’s unfortunate. My grandfather immigrated to the US from Mexico years ago and did so legally. He established our family here and any other relatives since have crossed legally and obtained citizenship. It’s a hard and long process but it’s necessary.

Oh no! This will be red meat for the right. Way to go migrants lol. This shows me how closely ppl on the other side of the border pay attention to US policy. I wonder if these scenarios are thought of when changes to immigration policy are implemented. Makes yah think. Sucks that there's places out there that drive ppl to attempt a mass entry into the US.

Poor people I sympathize with their struggles but they can’t do this shit! All the immigrants that paid their dues did it the right way maybe they should take notes! No Papel No Entry. They need to go back and take Venezuela back from those pukes!!!!

As a native Venezuelan who legally immigrated to the United States, served in the Navy for 22 years, and became a U.S. Citizen, and a contributing member of society, watching this enrages me. No one has the right to come into any country illegally. I get their plight, but they still need to enter correctly. I know Venezuela's situation is terrible, but either fix it (by whatever means you have) or apply for asylum. Forcing yourself into a sovereign nation is illegal.

Makes me so angry, I start to shake. Who the f are they to pretty much demand they be let across?...and look at all the women and children. Overwhelming majority are young men, yet the Marxist media won't report the truth. Sooooo many come here displaying their home flag...they don't come to assimilate and become Americans. I'm all for legal immigration, most of us come from immigrants to the US...but our families didn't come to go on government benefits and promote their home country/way of life over the US. They didn't demand entry and demand we take care of them....like it's our obligation. I'd welcome and love them if they came here the right way for the right reasons.

Don’t feel bad one bit for these people. My family come from immigrants that did it the right way. The United States has a capacity. Thank God I was born here.

These poor people just want a better life! Unless you’re a Navajo or another Indian tribe … we are all immigrants! ?.. right or wrong ? We all came from somewhere else … I’m an earthling ?Lmao .. but we are restricted to wherever we are from? Why can’t we roam the earth? The concept of freedom is just an illusion! ❤?☝️?! Crazy! The world is a vampire! There is no god! Live it up … YOLO! ✌️

Why are we seeing this right now? Really? It’s been going on for a decade like this. That’s why Donald trump wanted to build a wall. A wall will not stop all illegal immigration. But a wall will stop mass hoards from violently entering the country

The Marxists hiding as democrats, don't want Venezuelan immigrants, because they flee for communism, that is taking over the US and the west right now. The Venezuelans turn mostly into anti communist conservatives.

its crazy these people are just empowered now thinking its their right to come in illegally. im not against immigration. im against people doing this and getting front of the line ahead of actual citizens

As much as I HATE illegal immigration. Remember we are the reason the term banana republic exists, the reason Honduras is in the state it’s in, supported Pinochle, fucked up Panama, and created the Sandanista. \n\nSo if you don’t like this I assume you didn’t vote for one of the 2 parties that created this situation, right? After all personal accountability starts with your own actions including voting.

We have such evil policies against their countries that its only right that they come here... shameful... there is no wisdom Or healthy mental Skill set Left in this world..we watched the exhaustion of the wisdom of this world right before our eye's the last 30yrs..the media and politicians have been dumbing down the population here in America...the immigrants Know what they are doing...bye America

Biden finally got something right on immigration

Canada ?? and America ?? are responsible for these migration due to their invasion and regime change operations in different countries around the world ?. Immigrants are human, too. They Immigrate to work, to earn a piece of bread ? for their families, which is their basic human right ✅️. If Canada ?? and America ?? wanna stop them, then stop invading poor countries. Stop violating basic human rights. Thanks ✅️

As an hispanic that went through the process to live in the US legally this is disgusting. These are the same people that fucked our countries and now they are coming here to try to fuck America. I have seen how they bring their shitty behavior and bad habits. If you come to the US do it the right way and also follow the fucking rules, learn english and contribute to the society. An immigrant should be someone that adapts and contributes to a society that we didn’t build. Also, I bet some of those are criminals with horrible crimes committed in their countries.

He is NOT a refugee so Asylum is not acceptable. Nor is he an Immigrant. He is an illegal economic migrant - please use the right terminology. He left a safe country for Canada and he should be returned to the USA or his home country. No sympathy.

Only the true Canadians ( First nations) have a right to say whatever they want about immigration. If your parents came from somewhere (which is probably the case in canada) pls kindly keep quiet cos you're just one over privileged kid, who has no clue what your ancestors did to help you become Canadian! First return to your root, (if you're Italian, Irish, indian...) before saying you don't want people in canada. It's NEVER your country in the first place!

What's up? Oh the illegal immigrants? But wait a second...weren't you all saying that trump was a bad guy for acknowledging this? What happened to that rule? It doesn't apply anymore because it's a democrat president right?

once they get to the border crossing they will still let them in. Trudeaus agenda is mass immigration. Right now we have more immigration than any other country in the world. 500 thousand coming this year. Wait till you you see the price of rents and houses at the end of this year.

Where do people get off demanding to be let into a country? Every single country in the world has immigration rules. They are their for a reason. People need background checks, a skill set that is needed, and a way to support themselves once here. We have tried bringing relatives legally just on a tourist visa and they were denied. Even after we paid the application fee, showed bank accounts, etc. so anyone who just thinks they have the right to come here better think again. That’s just the way it is until reform. Opening the floodgates to anyone is not reform, it’s chaos. Would you let just anyone walk into your house uninvited?

There is a huge backlog on legal applications for a lots of immigrants who applied legally, families torn apart and have long weight. They are already in the USA, there are sanctuary cities, New York was just dumping them off there. We tax payers are flipping the bills for them while so many Canadians are living on the streets. Those who are mad and outrage by this, you can go ahead and sponsor them, that mean you are legally responsible for all their expenses. As Canadians, even when we cross the border we got to have our passport and we go through a lots of scrutiny. Fill out the paperwork and wait to be processed, because right now we are already in crisis with lodging and food. USA is the one who must take care of those who cross their borders.

6 years too little, too late.. but yaayy! Canada's tightest International Security right there. Thank you Marco Mendicino and Ahmed Hussen for your outstanding response to International Immigration and Asylum in our Country!\n\n Now start Deporting back to their own Countries

Right,no immigrants to US and Canada please,closed immediately,economic crisis continued.Thanks. ( légionnaires vétérans Français)??????????????

Yes!! Good job ? we Canadians cannot afford all these immigrants coming by the hundreds!! We have Canadians who need housing and cannot afford to pay their rent. They must go to the immigration office in the right and proper way. Roxanne road should have closed a long time

Developed countries around the world are suffering from low birth rates and the non-specialized job labor force is also suffering so we do need immigrants.\nBut this is not the right way to do so.

I see the harm in that border crossing when Roxham road was open it was dangerous and illegal, I don't see why Migrant reports and Human rights groups are upset about the closure it's keeping the migrants safe and that law will not break in Canada, and I Immigrated here legally 41 years ago from Persecution in Somalia. Those who sneak through the borders will break the law and those who come through the border will obey the laws in Canada. The new migrants have entitlements, thinking that the law doesn't apply to them because they are migrants.

Enter LEGALLY. Majority of us Americans Are SOME kind of immigrant but we came here the right way. Now we got even Asians going through mexico to get here. Feels like Armageddon. And they dont even bother learning English. Some places i call or go to are only spanish speaking. Like wtf. Start ur business back home dude. Atleast learn the language

I really feel for these folks but you need to do it the right way like all the other immigrants that came to America Land of the Free but you're not allowed to break in

Personally, I have zero issue with immigrants..but you must do it legally, PERIOD! Once you cross a border illegally YOU are now a criminal by law and SHOULD be treated as such & immediately deported. We all have suspicions as to why a certain political group allows this to happen though & it’s to the detriment of actual Americans. With everything there is a right & wrong way of doing something…and the wrong way should always come with consequences.

The only thing you can do right now is completely close the border. NO further immigration or asylum seekers until further notice. Notice how Trudau is saying he is trying to work with US and, as always, nothing gets accomplished with this administration. Now Canada is mad at US too!

Immigration issues??? Lol I thought y’all said people have the right to to fight for a better life or some shit, so why is it an issue???

They will arrest you if you misgender someone in Canada..But if your a illegals..police will help you enter the country ..wtf? How low respect you have for a country.. Dont let these kind of ppl in..we dont want them..They dont care about Canada or any country..Insulting..after that they will cry if you dont give them everything..This country is a joke.. immigrants mostly illegals have more right than any canadian

i am by no means against immigration but it needs to be done legally. im an immigrant myself and it took me years to get thru work permit, landing and PR. yet those\nppl can just cross the border illegally and claim asylum right away skipping the queue. that aint right...

Immigrated to Canada many years ago as skill worker in the engineering field, and there were no opportunities in that country, Canada just needed laborers to fill out factories and people to do the jobs that the Canadian born did not want to do. I ended up working in my field in the USA, and salaries and opportunities are much better in this country. Americans are very practical, they just want someone with the right knowledge. When applying for jobs in Canada, employers were very obsessed with Canadian education and experience, but in my opinion, that was an intentional way to block immigrants. In the USA I was never asked for American education or experience, the interviews were very straightforward, very technical, they just wanted to verify technical knowledge. In conclusion, if looking for professional opportunities, the USA is much better than Canada, but legal immigration as a professional to the USA is extremely difficult.

I know exactly what some of these people plan.Get the canadian passport then bounce right back to the states...The states is a more complicated immigration process so Canada is there next option.

This is how you destroy a country by allowing aliens to invade it United States is watered down with immigrants right now that we're not strong as we used to be it's a whole nother World here. It's so much of a mess that we have to rely on the police to do work is this the country that we really want then the wait in the hospital for emergencies I don't see how this is going to work not to mention the West isn't the drought last time I checked the water in Mexico is worth more than gold they're running out of it that's why they're invading us it's about time we take our country back to start kicking them out.

There is supposedly an agreement between Canada and the US called the Safe Third Country Agreement which means illegal immigrants are supposed to apply for asylum in the first country they come to. Unfortunately, because of Trump, the Canadian government doesn't trust any US government to give these asylum seekers a fair hearing. Second, this agreement only applies to official border crossings, not unofficial ones like Roxham Road. Trudeau is absolutely right in wanting to renegotiate the Safe Third Country Agreement.

Enough is enough. Stop these illegal immigrants. Let them enter Canada the legal and the right way. I entered Canada and got my PR and citizenship the legal way. I expect them to do the same thing too!

What a joke this Country has become. Trudeau will let anyone in as long as they vote Liberal. \nWhy do we let this happen?\nWe should be looking after the people who come to Canada the right way.\nNow we pay immigrants to sit around and get houses while hard working migrants live sub standard.

The United States has become an unsafe country for immigrants and refugees as Republican politicians pander to racists, anti-semites, and homophobes for personal profit and political power. Under international law Refugees/Asylum seekers have the right to present themselves at the border to ask for asylum in Canada. We should welcome them as our grandparents were welcomed.

All Joe Biden’s doing! At the end of the day, you cannot enter into this country illegally! That’s the law! I agree with Trump, we don’t mind immigrants coming to the country ,, we just want you all to do it legally, otherwise you shouldn’t be over here ,,, period! You all have to abide by the laws just like everyone else! Look at how you all are trying to Bogard your way in , and you all have no regards for the laws of the land we live in! Maybe we should get Trump back in office because he had complete control of this border like this country has ever seen ! In addition, it is not the fault of the United States that there is so much poverty in your country, nor is it our responsibility to reduce the level of poverty in your country! That’s why you all have politicians in your country! Its not our fault that corruption in your country has led to the impoverished situation that exists in your country! This is down right disrespectful to the United States!\nI personally would send all of you all back and require that you go back to your country and do this the legal way!

TRUDEAU IS RIGHT TO WANT TO REMOVE THAT BORDER CROSSING. HE SHOULD ALSO TELL HIS BORDER AGENTS TO SEND THESE IMMIGRANTS BACK TO THEIR HOME COUNTRIES.

HA... sorry to burst your expectations but you will find many of the same things that you don't like in Australia here in Canada, except it is colder in Canada. Read why people leave Canada. At least you can escape to the USA but right now they have massive illegal immigration problems where the US is shipping them to Canada.