Close Reading

Anyone actually ASKED Palestinians if they want to leave?

They want Arabs to take them as refugees but Palestine belongs to Palestinians why should they leave why the genocide is not stopping Permanent ceasefire now Free Palestine ?????

Big decision, but so is the world. Have you considered what you would do for a living? I'm sorry I don't know much about your family. \nIf you can work from anywhere in the world, then you have a few choices. Someone suggested Malaysia. I think that is very good option. Its technically advanced, people are kind and warm, living expenses are very reasonable. I have only visited once, but I loved it. Felt completely comfortable (I don't wear the hijab). This was my experience from over 25years ago. \nIf you want to consider an Arab country, I would highly recommend checking out Oman, that is where I am from. I lived in the US for over 25 years, and now I love living in Oman. Its very calm, people are kind and welcoming. Winters are great here, but summers are very hot. Most foreigners who come here, never want to leave. The sense of serenity here is addictive. \nGood luck in your search.

Palestinians: Lets us leave!!!\n\nIslamic Colonialists Hamas and Arabs: No. You don't want to.

I completely understand why you are leaving. Part of me wants to follow you, knowing nothing about where to go. It’s not welcome here for Christian’s or Muslims. How is THAT our current times. No? Shocking.

I had the same idea of leaving because I found my self not represented by my PM (both of them). But at the same time, by doing so it’s just like giving them the right to do what ever they want.

The Gazans are being kept in prison by the world and Islamic ideology. A large percentage of them WANT TO LEAVE. The are probably hating the whole world for keeping them in this prison. Using them as pawns. Shame on him.

Actually, polls of Gazans say that a very large percentage of them want to leave, over half

Really then I do not like to hear or see you applying as Canadian citizen ! Also wanted to see you leaving the country anytime !unless you are here because you like to make Money using YouTube and Canada !!!!!?????

The Palestinians DO NOT want to leave their land!

Please leave we are a secular society and Sharia is not wanted by most people here.

Gotta say, you're lucky to have lived in Japan and are now able to work remotely. I've wanted to live in Japan for 15 years now, but have been unable to get a work visa, while each year I meet dozens of people now living in Canada, by simply taking ESL or Makeup courses, and that leads to a PR card.. what I wouldn't give to be able to pack up and leave to Japan..

I dont think even Isreal wants to take the land from the palestinians. They're afraid if they leave, they won't return. They're just as culpable for the children dying in this conflict. They could take women with children. People over 50.

I agree 100% as an Australian your doing the right thing because even here I am seeing these things which are morally wrong and you cant speak out because your made as the bad person. So I hope you find your paradise on Earth that is what you want..My parents after second world war came to Australia now gone and I am old I wish I could leave here and go somewhere else but its safe where we are and in Tasmania so its cold we have a good state its small but very cold hehe so good luck..

I was born here and im 72 yrs old. I love my country but i dont even recognize it from 25 yrs ago. Its like waking up in a night mare that just keeps getting worse. It breaks my heart to see this country turn into a 3rd world sh t hole. I fully understand why you would want to leave. If i had kids although im not Muslim i wouldn't want them growing up in this dysfunctional nightmare supoosed utopia . Its getting crazier by the day. May God bless and keep you in your new life and bring blessings on you.

canada IS NOT a Muslim country. You want all that, go to a Muslim country, you don't support one of Canada's allies. Leave. Go to gaza if that's where you feel you will belong there.

I just stumbled upon you guy's channel by accident, because we are looking to move out of our country as well and Canada was actually a possible option. (not likely now) \n\nI am not muslim, I am just a regular western white girl, with priveleges I never knew I had until a few years ago, and looking at the world with increasing disgust and sadness. \nI completely understand why you'd want to move away from there, and even though I am not muslim, some of the points mentioned here are also reasons we want to leave where we are now (Netherlands). \nSociety is falling apart, people pointing fingers, our government is a ****show and puts the entire world's needs before taking care of our own problems. I don't feel safe and welcome anymore in the country that I once called home. I can't imagine how hard it must be for you two, raising kids, in the world how it is today, where people are using Islam in ways it was not intended and how it has played out to put the western population to turn against an entire group of people that also ultimately like everyone else, want to live their life in peace and safety. \n\nI wish you both the very best, stick to what you think is right! Your children couldn't have asked for better parents :)

This saddens me - Fellow Canadians are wanting to leave their home land because politicians have made it impossible for us to live here. \n\nI very much agree with you and with most of the reasons why you're leaving. I wish you the best in finding your new home and hope you know you will always be welcomed back to Canada with open arms.

Good if you want to leave Canada, just do it, stop complaining.

Well said, they only want the Palestinians to leave so Israel can take their land. Give the people back their land simple simone.

I'm Canadian and also want to leave this country, it's extremely unaffordable. Taxes are insane, home prices are out of reach, hospital care is non existent, the drug issue that's growing in every city.. etc etc. \nCanada is not what it used to be.

You keep hearing this question that originates from Israeli plans. Israel wants to force out all Palestinians from Gaza and the West Bank. They want the Palestinians to go to Sinai or Jordan. Insidiously they tell their propagandists to say the Arab countries don’t really care for the Palestinians because they’re not welcoming them as refugees into their countries. Why should the Arab nations fall for this devious Israeli trick? Palestine is the home of the Palestinians. Why should they leave it?

Little off topic observation but its strange that you say you are an extreme introvert yet on video you seem super confident and outgoing. Whereas I would describe myself as the opposite, extremely social and extroverted yet too shy to film myself talking...I would stutter and be really uncomfortable.\n\nOn topic, yes we have become cold to outsiders and I think you are correct in that the climate of political correctness has essentially choked any kind of openness as we have been taught since multiculturalism was made state policy to never ask certain questions or we are racist so to er on the side of safety we just don't say anything to newcomers anymore. That would be for the young demographic of Canadians but for older Canadians it is more due to resentment and anger, the reasons you list for wanting to leave Canada have all been caused BY immigration into Canada at such high rates and so older Canadians whom never voted for these changes to our immigration policies and whose voices never get heard are mad, mad their parents were able to buy a home in Vancouver for $50k with a basic blue collar job 2 generations ago now the same house is $3 million dollars. Or that we can no longer communicate with our neighbours because non of them speak english well or that we are constantly being called racist either by implication or outright by our media, academia and government. Or that our parents were able to afford university with zero debt afterwards now you leave with $100k+ in debt and the classrooms are 80% foreigner. Our the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who have been pushed into living in tents because sky high immigration has made their home town unaffordable etc Their anger is misdirected I know that, but it is understandable and will get worse. The future for Canada now is probably breaking into small countries because diversity has no future.

Im catholic. Here in california. Its complete craziness. Crime os much higher than b4. Many homeless. Over 200000 homes in California. People sleeping in rvs. I want to leave

I def. think you should leave . if you don't feel the values align with your family then you should leave. I am always confused when people want to stay in a country that they disagree with the values and culture and try to FORCE their culture and values on the that country. Go to where you feel loved and valued

They want to leave, all to Europe.\nAs usual.

I agree with him, the Palestinians don't want to leave, and why should they?

Some of them may want you to leave. Why not give them the choice?

Create problems and destabilize other countries expect refugees to surge into yours! \n\nNo immigrant wants to leave their land if theres safety and any level of opportunity in their own homeland to be a second class citizen somewhwre else... unless they have to. The American public doesnt lnow or understand the level of American politics agitating other parts of the world ...starting from Latin America and Palestine.

Anyone who crosses the border illegally for any amount of time be it five minutes or 5 years , it’s a life time ban from ever entering this country again . They have to pass a law like this and have include the ones already here , if you get caught you are deported and never allowed to enter the country legally again period never again. I would have the president give a speech encouraging all illegal immigrates that from this moment until 30 days from now you will have to go back to your home country, if you can’t afford it we will put you on a flight to the airport of our choice in your homeland.So for the next 30 days you will not be stopped or detained if you are leaving the country but anyone who’s still here after that deadline and caught there’s no immigration court with free lawyers you are gone with a life time ban . If you want to come legally than all the regular procedures are still in place . First find a sponsor, than get a visa so you can go to the immigration office and get a background check , if you don’t qualify than too bad it’s not our fault you don’t meet our requirements to be eligible to become a U.S. citizen. If you pass the background check and can prove you can support yourself and have a place to live then you get a green card and you get in line while you are in this country and wait your turn to become a U.S. citizen .

Whether or not Palestinians want to leave Gaza is not up to this man to decide. They should offer help and asylum as any decent nation would do, but let me tell you ….there are other reasons for this refusal.

I think netither he nor any of you understand the concept of refugees. Refugees don’t want to leave, they are forced. It is about providing them with a temporary safe haven from the consequences of Hamas’ actions

Why should other countries be responsible for citizens who voted for Hamas. There was celebrations around the world by Palestinians, for the disgraceful attacks on the Jewish population in Israel. They want sympathy and understanding from the world, but I shall never forget their chants and behaviours, even before Israel retaliated. Countries who have taken these people in, have altered the fabric of their societies. You can try all you want in the UK, but our citizens will vote out Sunak the spineless fingers crossed they get rid of Sadiq Khan who is the racist major of London. It’s called a democracy. We may have to wait for Labour to run its election course, but Reform UK is the party who puts its citizens before those who abuse the migration process and those who chant against countries that have been good enough and have taken them in. There will be a time, in the future when racism gets called out, tougher legislation comes into effect. You have no value, then you will have to leave, by law of the land, not the law of your religion.

what a nice thing. Why did they not tell that to europe?\nso we should not take any refugees in!\nbecause they obviously dont actually want to leave. they want to stay actually!

He says the Palestinians don't want to leave their land but the people clamoring at the Rafah border crossing would say otherwise. The tanks and troops that Egypt has mobilized at the border is evidence that Palestinians do at least temporarily want to leave their land for the safety of the Sinai desert. But Egypt is scared of the terrorists among just like the rest of the Arab world is.

Thousand of people WANT to leave, but they cant since the surrounding arab countries refuse them. What he is saying is simply not answering the question, there are people who want to stay, and people who DO NOT. He is intentionally and maliciously dodging the question.

I want to leave the US. I was thinking Pakistan, but my parents taunt me and say that people would die to come to the US, and you’re trying to leave??

Really good answer indeed, because the whole whole should be responsible for peace in every corner of the world. However, he smartly ignored the fact that Palestine claims are based on muslim ideology, and hence muslim nations do need to take a larger part of the share in this burden. Obviously, no one wants to leave their land, but no one wants terrorists to win as well.

Israel wants the Palestinian to leave so that they(palestinian) can be a minority.

So israelis dont have right to live there either?? There were many tries for peace by israel. Encouraging palestine to create their own leaders. And what they did was get hamas up to power. Which lead to thousands of israelis killed. Nice that they dont want to leave their home. I understand. But dont blame israel. And act as if they have somwhere else to go. Arabs have like 40+ countries. Jews only have 1. Make some sense outta that

That’s what I often say… Do you want to live according to your religion? Go to a country that allows you to do so. Non-Muslim countries will not change. There is definitely only one solution: adapt or leave. Muslim countries are the same, you respect them, you leave them.

Why don't you give them opportunity to leave if they so choose. Start making available refugee visas. I bet many would appreciate that opportunity and accept it. The truth is either the Arab nations don't want palestinian refugees or they don't want the palestinan cause to die.

Douglass Murray and his kimd are always asking this same question; why don't the Muslims take them in, as if they havent taken on milliins of Palestinian refugees in already, in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt, but not all Palestinians want to leave, like he said. Israel needs to stop producing homelessness by bombing homes it does not.intend to.rebuild.

I am not Muslim and I therefore do not have the same experiences as you but I am a second generation U.S. immigrant and I wanted to say I am considering leaving as well for many of the same reasons you gave. And I think you are very brave to stand up for your beliefs regardless of what happens.

Listen Febby, this B.S. has been going on for decades now. I'm almost seventy and it existed when I was a young man. The joke was you want a job get experience, you want experience get a job. It's a catch 22 or the cat chasing his tale. Canada is a country made up of the old ruling elite and there idiot off-spring. So, the only way to keep their kids in the money since most, like American's a dumber than skunks is with this B.S. I spent 10 years working and living in China and although I don't want to go back I too, I Canadian born and breed want to get the hell out of Canada as well. I've worked and waited until I was 70 so as to get a larger pension and if I can afford it, the next time I leave Canada will be the last time and if that happens, I'LL NEVER RETURN. That should give you some idea what I think of my own country. The End. Good-Luck and Good-Bye. AD.

If Palestinians don't want to leave their land why there are millions of Palestinians in USA, Canada, Australia, Europe, etc?

Taking in refugees is not the answer, the Palestinians are proud people and don’t want to leave their native homeland!

He said Palestinians don't want to leave their land, how many Palestinians took Europe citizenship US citizenship \nIsrael is doing the right thing

Palestinians who don't want to leave their land should not allow Hamas to control their land either then. If their land is so sacred, why does Hamas get to launch terror attacks from their land?

That was a bs answer, What's the difference between the Ukraine war and Israeli and the palestine war? Did the ukrainian not have a claim to there land ?\nDid the the Ukrainian want to leave no, but it doesn't stop the European country to help a little bit, just by taking some of there people in.