Close Reading

More should be done to ensure that China stops taking advantage of Canada. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFZSkSBnFBY&t=196s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6MdgushuK4&t=235s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8o2DHovDgg stricter rules are needed and I wish the government would do more to stop the Chinese from exploitation our country ,people and resources.

Well done. BIG SKY country

Hes earning good money and has done nothing to become legal.. We have sucb lax laws in this country.!!

To me, it looks like Vice is really trying to pull the emotional card to get people to sympathize with this man because he really is in a rough situation. But, he is in a situation of his own making. It sounds like he had not done any prior research about Canada before deciding to claim refugess status. Yes, Trudeau was not giving the full truth when he made those public announcements to the media. Yes, people (educated or not) can be swayed by words of leaders they respect. But, to think you can just enter another country and claim refugee status without understanding what that actually entails is very naive. Canada has very transparent laws that are easily accessable in a multitude of different languages. The provinces also have legal assistance for those who can not afford lawyers. So, the fact that this man was able to spent $15,000 when he is being portrayed as a low income earner makes me question his income, or if he was even aware that he could apply for legal assistance. And since he has a lawyer who has been working his case, I would like to assume that the lawyer would have said something about assistance.\n\nI really want to be sympathetic for this man and his family, because security uncertainty makes life extra hard. But, as I have had to live in more than one country due to the Canadian immigration system refusing my husband due to a very old DUI (which has set our life on a completely different plan than anticipated), I have a very hard time being sympathetic when I feel as though they did not reach out to educated themselves on the laws of another country. I am a Canadian who currently can't live in Canada with my husband of 3 years and I still don't hate my country. I respect the hell out of it (this is not to get into our historic treatment of BIPOC, which deserves it's own seperate time and is a bloody stain on our land's history.)

Okay. A lot of people here have no clue how the immigration system works both in the US and in Canada. “He should just have come here legally”. Well, most of the time a legal path to emigrating to the US/Canada just does not exist, and its getting more and more impossible to be granted asylum. In the US you can’t just apply for a work visa, you can’t just apply for a green card. You got to be eligible to apply for it. For a work visa you need a job offer first, you need proof of income and most of the time the employer will have to prove they couldn’t find an American to take the position. To get a green card you either have to get married to an American, invest at least $500,000 or try applying for asylum (which is almost impossible to get nowadays). ALSO to apply for asylum you need to be either inside the US or at a US port of entry. Try to be less “patriotic” and more empathetic. People flee their countries because of war, violence, cartels, gangs, terrorism, etc. They are desperate and want to protect their families and have a better life. If you were in their shoes and staying in your home country put your family in great harm you would have done the same thing. People need to stop judging, stop being selfish and start leading with empathy.

Very well done movie. I live in Toronto,multicultural city. I was very suprised that in contemorary life of Canada the racism would be possible to be present in such tolerant country as Canada is in comparison with nationalism in USA. Especially the story of lady who owns the restaurant shocked me. . . Very sad.

hahaha....\n\n When a women went to islamic nation she had to be wear hijab or burkha.. because we have to respect your culture.. ok done... \n\nBut. . when a women of your country came to European country.. and govt stop them to wear hijab or burkha.. then again you guys will tell us that we should respect your culture... \n\nYou can't imagine how much time and effort has been taken to make a beautiful country.. you guys just know how to destroy peace nature country...\n\nThere is no limit of hypocrisy of this cult religion...

Wait...so can anyone explain am I getting this right? I am from a European country and to apply for a 12 month work permit/visa in Canada I had to get and translate all kinds of travel documents and documents that prove my identity and that I haven't been prosecuted in my country and drive 16 hours just to get biometrics done. And now all of that is going to waste because the borders are closed for me.\nAnd these people can just show up at this border crossing NOW without documents and just like that enter Canada illegally and that's ok? Am I getting this right? Can someone please clarify this to me?

what a disgrace. country running itself.leader and his government full of morons and burnouts...completely trashed the country ..Done deal...unicorns and rainbows and happy times..oh man.......

Islam done very bad condition in england . Hope canada stop comei them on there country.

They believe in 2 nation theory and jihad. There will be Pakistan formed in every country by partition as done in Indian subcontinent. Matter of time.

9 months have passed and the canadian government haven’t done anything good job Trudeau, your children will be happy for the mess you have done to their country

we are not a country go watch is canada a myth done by doug force it explains alot all backed up with investagative facts ,we tried many times meech lake accord was the last time ,look we can kick out the defacto gov.we have call our own election and set a dejour gov. for the people by the people go watch

Why concern? They are trying to establish Sharia Law in foreign countries and beating up people who don't convert to Islam. Canada is not Sharia Law. It has its own laws. People cannot come into a country and try to change its culture. People remember 9/11. That was not done by Eskimos.

Does criticism of Islam amount to racism? Why is it OK criticize communism, nazism and other supremacist ideologies, but as soon as you attach the word divine to the same ideas, then they're off limit? I am Iranian. I was born in a Muslim family. I have been educated in Islam and experienced Islamic, sharia based rule for most of my life. And I have the same concerns as this man. Islam is a brutal supremacist ideology that is incompatible with critical thought, personal freedoms, democracy, rule of law and pretty much everything else that we take for granted in the modern world, that came out of Western Enlightenment. Once muslims become the majority, they will do the same thing as they have done everywhere else where they've taken control. Look at what they're doing in England and France in Majority Muslim areas. Look around the world today and see what Islam leads to. You will put your head in the sand at your own peril. I left my home in my own beautiful and ancient country. I will not do it again in my new home...

Man as a Muslim i fucking hate see this kinda of acts that has nothing to do with Islam and still at the get portrayed as islam and here we are trying to convince people our own religion prohibits us of such acts, man this make me so angry ... they mix religion with tradition and do things that shouldn't be done ever ... There's no compulsion in religion, and uk is no Muslim country so you can't force people to follow your ideology, act upon it be kinda and leave them be ... if you really want to be a good Muslim show them the best yourself and the values that you are required to follow ...

I am a hotel management Grad In India. Brother, I have done internships 12 hours straight in 5 stars unpaid. after 3 years I am a restaurant manager now. Still, after all these years my job profile consists of standing 10 hours on foot and working. It's the same in India. Just that Indians usually don't take such jobs in the home country and when they go to a different country. They give up easily! best wishes to you motabhai.

So what that's life . It will always be there . Stop crying . Bunch off beady eye cunukes you have sh$tty beer . Your hockey teams haven't done sh$t in years. The only thing half way decent from your country is maple syrup. .... Haha see rascism will always be around. Stop whinnying. Terrence and Phillip.

Well done bro I can understand very well your struggle whatever you faced because i have also foreign country problem experienced.

This young man should go back to his country and fight for his land like Americans have done. They can grow food build their homes and fight instead of fighting cartels . Wake up send these people flyers to fight for freedom.

Muslim people are peacefull people in minority only. Once they come into the country, they destroy your country's peace, property and harmony. The same is done in India. They are make their population double and triple to become majority in India. Hope someone comes to rescue to guide islam people to leave in harmony.

Muslims do not assimilate, they want to conquer the world. These stone age culture and religion belief need to be ban in the 1st world countries. Europe is done if they don't start take control of their own countries. Wake up and do something about it before it's too late.

(1) Muslims Are not Immigrants!\n(2)Muslims Don't Assimilate Ever!\n(3) Muslims Bring there Own Law's!\n(4) Muslims Are a \nInvadeing Army! \n(5) Ignore these Fact's At Your own RISK !!! Brilliant You Idiot's Will Have no Country Left. When the Muslims Are Done

Should have done things the legal way this isnt pulling my heart strings! Two countries he tried to hide in and found out illegal is now wanted

This is done routinely by Chinese people. Similar situation in Australia. The vast majority of the Chinese 'businessmen' and officials registered barely spend a day in a year in the country they are supposedly ordinarily resident in. It's about preparing for the very real threat of when something goes awry back home or they fall out of favour with a honcho bigger than them they have an escape path and they can not be extorted with their families. For this, ultra-wealthy Chinese are more than willing to throw some money around by investing in unprofitable businesses, buying real estate or flat out handing some money to that country's government and go through the bureaucratic hurdles of committing fraud.

Well done CBSA, well done indeed. Ex-pat in Italia that let Gov. know I am here. These people are liars, take advantage of the system, contribute nothing to the country and deserve every measure of the law and then some. And the clients want compassion...1st plane out is the compassion they deserve.

7 years imprisonment for immigration fraud because he's Chinese. \n\nMillions of isis terrorists live in Canada on fraudulent documents and nothing is being done about it by Canadian authorities. \n\nCanada is the most racist country towards Chinese.

What's going on here? How is this man acting bossy after all he's done? I live in China and believe me, you can't do this in China. You will be deported and everything you have will be seized without a single reason. How is he still in Canada? Why would the Chinese respect the Canadian gov't if you won't take actions on people who commit such crimes in the country?

Well done Fifth Estate. The Chinese have completely taken over. I watch the border crossing show sometimes and when they come back from “vacationing “ in China and pretend that they haven’t brought anything with them and when their bags are inspected they have tons of stuff and have way exceeded the limits and they barely get a verbal reprimand. Let me see a Canadian whose family has been here for 9 generations get away with this. They are dishonest, money laundering scam artists. Yet, Canada still welcomes them with open arms. When will the Canadian government wake up? Having them take over this country is an insult to hard working Canadians and other honest immigrants. When they commit a crime of any type they should be deported. They’re always bragging about how rich their country is, then why do they want to come here? We haven’t invaded their country! Not that any sane person would want to.

Stupid sell outs\nInsulting your mother india saying you'd never go back\nAll we do is moan about india about the infrastructure, about the government. But we do nothing just escape abroad not our problem we say\n30 years ago india was on par with China. Bad governance and all our people going abroad has led to us being stuck in 1980 whilst china powered ahead and rules the world in most sectors \nThese idiot singh in Canada are the ones who say they'll never go to india but demand khalistan dopey cunts had a sikh pm for years what did he do for them\nAs for Canada what a joke country forever in Americas shadow. Gaylord pm and puts a indian in charge of defence. Not that their military has ever done anything\nJust to get the sikh votes \nNo asian should hold such a position in any other country look at our London mayor only there due to the left wing ideals of the labour party. Not their on merit nor is our home sec\n\nPay your taxes work hard for your own country\nIndia is the best\nModi is the best

Canada is a merit and point based country. Chain migration is about to end in USA. It was popular in florida, 1 family from cuba, and they bring. aunts, uncles, sisters,brothers, mothers, and father's. Do you see why chain migration has to stop because USA can no longer support welfare recipient's for life. We are done, we need to collect lost taxes from these welfare bleeders.

I cant BELEAVE the uk has come to this, that nothing is done, not that we can see. That the changes are so dramatic, that as an english person i feel like an out sider. Beleave you me if i went to there country Shouting out, HAY where are the bars, id like a drink after a hard day work to relax, for example, id be shot. Great eh. Unfortunately the UK is no longer THE UK.. sad really, what happened to the promised integration, and becoming a greater UK. ow nooo, uk is becoming fully muslim.. shame really

Let's help there countries \nDEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL \nUs this another way to depopulate population we all can benift by the land of each other countries as long as there is peace between each other DEMOCRATS LEFTIST SHADOW GOV BEHIND THIS MESS THEY HAVE DONE THIS TATIC TO OTHER COUNTRIES FOR YEARS NOW WE ALL CAN SEE IT UNFOLDING DEMOCRATS SHUT THEM DOWN NOW THEY HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC ON OUR COUNTRY'S WORLD WIDE..\nTRUST TRUMP \nDEMOCRATS HAVE DONE ENOUGH DAMAGE TO UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND OTHER COUNTRIES FOR YEARS MANIPULATE PUBLIC CHANGE THE BALANCE OF POWER PERIOD \nDEMOCRATS USE PPL AS PAWNS ENGAGE IN THERE SICK PLANS COLLAPSE USA DEPOPULATE BOMBINGS CLAIM TERRORIST ATTACKS THEY CREATED THEMSELVES NULLIFY YOUNG GENERATION EAISER TO BRAINWASH THE PUBLIC REALIZE THAT BEFORE YOU HAVE NO SAY ABOUT IT...\nWE HAVE TO STAND TOGETHER TO STOP THE CORRUPTION CHAOS CASTROHICHIC EVENTS DEMOCRATS LEFTIST SHADOW GOV HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC FOR YEARS NOW IT'S PERTAINING TO THE WORLD ORDER LEADERS GET MORE POWER TO DESTROY OTHER COUNTRIES REBUILT THEM LATER ON PUT IN DIFFERENT POSITION OF POWER POPULATION REBUILD FIX THE MESS OBAMA HILLARY SOROS WANT TO BRING DOWN MANY OTHER COUNTRIES BUILDING UP THERE EMPIRE DEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL HYPOCRITES LIERS WHO BETRAYED US ALL ..\nWE ALL HAVE TO HELP TO REBUILD COMMUNITIES CHILDREN FAMILIES WE ALL CAN BENEFIT BUT DEMOCRATIC PARTY'S DON'T CARE ABOUT HUMANITY FAIRNESS AND RESPECT FOR EACH OTHER COUNTRIES CLEARLY DEMOCRATS ARE BEHIND THE SCENES OF THE DESTRUCTION OF THERE OWN PERSONAL MILITARY MAKE NO MISTAKE ABOUT IT..\nWE HAVE TO DECIDE HOW MUCH SUFFERING WE ALL CAN ENDURE \nLAW'S THAT KEEP US ALL SAFE SECURE THE DEMOCRATS LEFTIST CORRUPT ONLY WANT TO GET CONTROL OVER POWER WHAT A MESS THEY HAVE CREATED WREAKING HAVOC ON OUR COUNTRY JUST AS DEMOCRATS HAVE DONE TO OTHER COUNTRIES 911 CREATED A WAR ON IRAQ UNNECESSARY WAR'S THAT SHOUDNT OF HAPPENED NOW IT'S A MESS BUT WE CAN CHANGE IT..\nWE HAVE TO TRUST TRUMP..\nHE'S NOT PART OF THE CORRUPT ONE'S HE'S FOR PEACEFUL PROCESS HEALING AND FAIR TRADES DEAL'S AS PROMISED WHERE WE CAN BEGIN WITH HEALING PROCESS TOGETHER WE CAN CHANGE IT DEMOCRATS HAVE DONE THIS TO MANY COUNTRIES WORLDWIDE SADLY IT ISN'T EASY TO WATCH INNOCENT CIVILIANS PPL FAMILIES CHILDREN SUFFERING FROM DEMOCRATS WITH GLOBALIST LEFTIST INVESTORS PROFITING OFF THE PEOPLE OR ELES..\nI PRAY FOR PEACE PROCESS HEALING AND FAIR TRADES DEAL'S AS PROMISED WE HAVE TO TRUST TRYING SOMETHING NEW DIFFERENT FROM THE HARDSHIPS OF DEMOCRATS CLICK CHAIN OF POWER GREED ACTIONS DEATH'S OF GOOD INNOCENT PEOPLE COUNTRIES WHO HAVE SUFFERED BECAUSE OF DEMOCRATS CLICK CHAIN OF POWER GREED ACTIONS OF GREED POWER TO BENEFIT THEMSELVES USING THE PPL AS PAWNS ENGAGE IN THERE SICK PLANS COLLAPSE COUNTRIES PROVIDE WEAPONS ANGER HATRED ENOUGH DAMAGE HAS BEEN DONE TO ALL OF US DEMOCRATS ARE REALLY EVIL TRYING TO COLLAPSE CHRISTIANITY PEOPLE WHO HELPED MANY COUNTRIES WORLDWIDE SADLY IT IS A WAY TO LOOSE HOPE BUILD UP ANGER SUCIDE MURDERS DEATH'S \nWE HAVE TO STOP DEMOCRATS LEFTIST HELP THE SUFFERING REBUILD THERE LAND HOMESTEAD FOR THOSE WHO WANT TO GO HOME ?

It angers me what this man has done to his family. How do you claim asylum in a country when fleeing from a country you came to illegally? Immigration laws are very important and protect citizens of a country in many ways. The US welcomes immigrants with open arms when they come here legally. These individuals want to challenge our rights to protect our people, our country. This family may be no threat to our country but if laws are not followed it opens the way for the wrong people to enter. I’m so tired of this manipulation. This man is responsible for the pain his children are going through.. not the countries standing by their laws to protect citizens and legal immigrants. If you know something is wrong and you do it anyway how do you then blame someone else for the consequence? Aside from this.. when do people start taking a stand and making positive change in their own Home Countries? So many of these people support corrupt leaders that promise to give them all their desires and then when things fall apart they want to flee. The problem in this world is people refuse to take responsibility. It’s always someone else’s fault. If we allow people from other countries to neglect our laws our country will fall as well. Wake up.

I’m shock that after all these years people are still fleeing Central America. The US and the United Nations haven’t done anything to fix these countries!

Britain is not muslim country go to muslims country and force charia law there .majority refuse it .prefere humans rigths laws wy you are too agressive no one like your charia laws its against humans rigths and here is the humans rigths laws country .no muslim country is leading the world of the justice none any scientist came from there last 500 years with discoveries to help the world they all struggles and follow the intelligent technologie medecine et so and so.. of christians and others nations so charia of islam didnt done much help

Even their own people from their own country will tell you it's all lies they are not in danger in their own country it's a big I'm poor help me game they are really are enemy it's all lies. They are trouble and Everytime you hear something horrible it's always them. Tell your leaders that illegal means punishment. That's what needs to be done.

The whole concept of Sanctuary Cities beginning 30 years ago was sold to bleeding heart Democrats in California as temporary sanctuary from violence in Central America,. It is just one of a long list of lies. Keep an eye on your churches Canada. Sanctuary Cities got started by the Catholic Church pandering their parishioners votes to city politicians. I cannot name one Sanctuary City that any voter ever had a say in. It was all done by politicians. 30 years later we have 20 million Illegals & Visa overstays, OUR wages & YOUR wages have suffered. If Central America can't solve their problems in 30 years that is the fault of the people who abandon the country. People who abandon their country do not deserve citizenship in another country. Canada needs to #DrainTheBeaverDam

What good has Islam ever done to Canada? On what grounds can Islamic Imams patronize Christian countries? Why does Canada have to adapt to Islam?

Have you ever done this in other countries not just America Canada profiling

As a Canadian screw Trudeau . I'm ashamed to call him my prime minister. At least his dad gave us the bill of rights and freedoms which is a historic document... His son aka Justin is literally ruining Canada .\n\nSo far he's put us in a tonne of debt , has no economic knowledge/political experience, is a hypocrite, went back on his promise for electoral reform (as the old system made him win lol) , is an Islamic extremist apologist , literally gave millions of tax $ to a terrorist because he was detained in Guantanamo aka Omar Khadar -_- etc ... The list goes on.\n\nWasting my tax dollars on people who not only are breaking the law but it's a joke - They just literally walk on over. Many have no skills or anything to actually bring to Canada either. They're not asylum seekers. They're economic migrants who broke the law by coming to the states illiegaly. Now because you actually have a president with balls to kick them out to where they came from they're coming to Canada where they know our PM can't even admit there's such a thing as an extremist Muslim. \nHe keeps using the excuse that Canada was built on immigrants. Yes. True. Legal ones. Or legitimate refugees fleeing war or persecution. Not bloody Donald Trump and a pretty developed / stable country aka the US. Smh. \n\nThe only good thing he's done is legalize weed and even then he's managed to screw it up by making it a government monopoly vs a free market the many US states have where entrepreneurs can thrive.

I feel bad for his innocent children to have to go through this. You want to live in another country, you need to follow the law like every else. You learn the language, get the same I.D. We all have to have , and be treated the same as if any American were to illegally cross boarders! What we have to go through just to have identification here should be no different for anyone else! You can’t just live off our tax dollars and government ins., food stamps etc.. While we pay for you to live here!! I don’t reap those benefits, yet I’m paying yours!! I can’t feel bad! When I go to a dr. Or dentist and an immigrant or a lazy able bodied parent gets everything done free and I’m struggling to pay with full ins.. I literally walk out so pissed off! These are straight facts!! He had fifteen years to make it right. Instead he took a shot doing it his way to reap the American benefits and the feel bad for me card!If they ever let him come back and he collected any kind of help in those last fifteen years, “if” , he should have to get proper I.D., citizenship, and pay back anything he was given! It’s only fair! He was able to save all that money tax free, hmmm must be nice! I don’t feel bad he had to spend it. That’s real life!I’m tired of watching my citizens no matter race or color, work hard paying taxes and giving their hard earned money away!!If we just let anyone walk right through our boarder than what’s the point of any American needing any I.D.??? Don’t people get why it’s so important to keep track for so many obvious different reasons!! I believe certain citizens with outrageous offenses should be chipped!In every race!I don’t care who the president is any president that doesn’t believe this is the right thing to do sucks! I didn’t vote for a Trump! I think he’s smart and a moron at the same time!

Canada is changing drastically and replacing its population with south Asian people.within a decade, Canada will be brown country because of uncontrolled immigrants and it’s done by all globalists including Justin Trudeau

If he had done just it legally in the begining he and his family wouldve been secured by now but he decided to do it illegally not just in one but two countries.

I did not know that these so-called educated people does not know that Canada is north America too,it only two different countries.But it is the same thing going on their with black people, only because it is not done on a large scale, like the united States.I have some relatives living in Canada over 45 years, friends over 38 years and.They talked about some form of racist against them, only it is not done on a large scale like the united States.Some of those Canada who they called snow birds, whenever they came to the united States.They are behaving like they own the country,or the complex where they are living.Nobody does not like them because of their racist behaviour against black people, so some people does not know about.The reason why it is done on a large scale as the united States, only because it does not populated like the united States as the world 2nd largest country.We have read where black people been turned away from entering certain building, only because it is not done on a regular scales like the united States.

This silliest part of this story is that if he could write a resume listing all that construction work that he has done he could easily find work that pays comparable wages to what he gets in Canada or the US in most Latin American countries. And he wouldn't even have to deal with documentation problems and culture shock. Construction businesses in those countries would be delighted to have workers capable of working to North American standards.

I don’t know whether to believe him or call him a liar because if he had $15,000. $15,000!!! in Mexico do you understand the life you could live not saying you would be in a mansion but you would live comfortably enough to do it correctly file paperwork the way it supposed to be done wait your time and then move into America everybody thinks Canada so great but they don’t realize that Justin Trudeau is a lying piece of shit he may say one thing but Canada as a country follow the law that they have set for immigrants #fail sorry you thought Canada was better than the U.S.A

Canada has done extremely well for Immigrants, and we spend a lot of money on making sure we get hard working decent citizens.. We've recently made it easier for people to immigrate here. We welcome it. But it does have to be done legally. And yes, I agree with everyone else here. 15 years in English countries, and doesn't speak it himself is disgusting. I bet he'd learn the word food fast if he was starving. Also, those kids need to be in school. I hope he's not hiding them too cause they'll never learn English then.

I feel for Jose, yet I wonder why he is not angry with his own government, with his own country for making him feel it was impossible for him to live and work in his own country. Why can he not go back there? How is that system lacking and what can be done to change it so that people don’t feel forced to leave. I find it odd that no one ever reports on these South American governments - what are they doing so wrong that their own citizens are refugees from their own country. Why can’t we stop blaming and find a solution to this problem? Why is it framed that it is the United States or Canada’s fault for upholding immigration laws, their own countries insist upon them. it’s odd.

Trudeu has done what Merkel did. Saying one thing for show, making people believe that they can go, then once the people get there, it's shown that thse words where just hot air. Merkel even backed everyone up in Hungary (see the Eastern Railway incident) and put the blame on the Eastern European countries for not being humane. ?\nCanada's darling dear did the same thing here and everyday people hoping for a new life get the sharp end of the deal. \nI don't see why this moma's boy is so idealised. He's just spouting popular rot, then backing out. A nation leader should take care what he/she says, otherwise you're just another style of Trump to me.