Close Reading

They had a right to live on that land until they conducted the most barbaric attack on Israel on 7th October. Now Israel has a right to rid themselves of that evil and barbaric threat next door. The Palestinians can never again be trusted.

As a European who lived for 3 years in Canada, I have to say that Canadians - as much as I love them - are very entitled. They live in a bubble and don't realise how good they have it. \n\nTheir country is beautiful, the lifestyle is phenomenal even if you aren't rich. A lot of things they complain about like rising house prices, food costs, and political divide is literally happening everywhere - I'm really not sure why they think only Canada is struggling with this right now. Perhaps because on their strong currency they can go and live like Kings in somewhere like Portugal or Bali, but then they don't realise that they are bringing over the cost of living crisis and making things harder for locals when they do that. \n\nThey want things to be perfect, which isn't something to discourage but they don't realise how much harder life is like in most other countries on the planet. The only ones who appreciated it were the people who had lived for a few years in the UK or Paris or Australia, or somewhere else they imagined that life was easier and then ended up actually miserable and actually struggling - and then soon fly back to Canada. I have to say though I do love the sense of always wanting things to be better, whilst in Europe we tend to accept having less, less options and struggle to the extent that we don't even see it as struggle.

They have the right to live in Palestine but without supporting terrorism. Live peacefully n allow others to live peacefully. Dont take the lives of innocent n unarmed citizens n children. Thats not the act of bravery. Nobody is going to live forever as we r mortal. Right education is a must.

And Jews have the right to live on their land. If your religion have a group of fanatics who is trying to destroy your people or anyone who is not Muslim that’s your problem not Europe not Israel not the West.

The solution to all these problems is not to make the Palestinians a Muslim or Arab country. The solution to all these problems is the establishment of an independent Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital. There is no other solution to this problem. There is another question that people ask why an Arab country or a Muslim country is not giving shelter to the Palestinians, so the answer is that the Palestinians have their own country, the Palestinian country is Palestine and they have the right to live on their land. Is. . I am sure that they will never agree to leave their land and Al-Aqsa Mosque, it is not possible, or the Muslim Ummah will never accept it, and if so, if some people say so. If the Palestinians are made a Muslim country, we can also say that if someone from Europe or the United States gives some of their land to the Israelis to the Jews, this problem will end, but no one will do that because no country They will not agree to give even a piece of their land to any other country and all these problems are only because of Europe and America. We want peace, but if the time comes and our governments allow us, we will support our Palestinian brothers in the jihad against Israel, but we don't want war, we want a peaceful world, but that's all they want. . It will be possible to establish an independent Palestinian state by ending the Israeli occupation. When the Palestinians have their own country, why should an Arab or Muslim country keep the Palestinians as refugees in their country? No European country or America should keep Jews as a shelter, it is not possible and if this cruelty, brutality, terrorism does not end, then know that Israel will have to suffer the most dangerous consequences. Time will not stop if the Muslim governments do not declare war against Israel, then the Muslim people will declare war, and if the Muslims rise up, America and Europe will be in no position to stop the Muslims, but we are not. War, we want peace and this is only possible when this occupation ends, this oppression ends and an independent Palestinian state is established.

Food prices are a hot topic right now. Interestingly, I was in Fort Myers Florida recently shopping at Publix and I was astonished by the high food prices versus stores around Toronto. 1.5L of Tropicana orange juice was $7.99 USD compared to $5.99 CAD, green/red peppers were much more expensive. Cereals, bread, potatoes, meats…. everything I found was consistently more expensive in USD versus CAD. Once you factor in the exchange rate it was just that much more painful. Perhaps Fort Myers is unique in this respect, or maybe it was a Publix issue, but I was happy to come home to much more reasonable food prices. \n\nWe definitely have our issues in Canada, but I love Canada. Our lakes, wilderness, and wildlife are truly majestic. We have virtually unlimited freedom to explore and roam this beautiful land. As one comment stated wisely, too many people live beyond their means and make unwise purchase decisions that create stress. Having said that, I realize that wealth and income inequality have never been worse, and many people face very difficult daily struggles. I do think Canada offers a better social safety net structure vs US to help people through those struggles, but we are definitely heading in the wrong direction in that respect. These are complex issues that are difficult to solve.

I think that as a Muslim, my view is that he has said the absolute truth that the Palestinians have every right to live in their land and why should the Palestinians leave their land and live in another land if he said that. If Palestine goes to another Arab state or another Arab country, it may also happen that the Jews of Israel leave Palestine and go to America or go to Europe, who are standing behind them. Why should Palestinians leave their land? Explain the reason

Basically he said - they have the right to die, because we don't want them... Palestinian refugees who has been taken by Egypt and other arab nation in the past made a mess in those countries.They could take refugees till the war is over to save lives, like Poland,Moldova and other countries did to save lives of Ukrainians ! Arab world can save lives, but they don't care.......

Israelis also have the right to live in their land too....Why are Arab muslims refuse to recognize Israel's rights since 1948...

One has to listen to arguments to and fro and Allah or God right now calls upon you to leave\nTongues behind and immediately help your people who are obviously of the same seed as you are. Take in all people in Gaza as refugees to save their lives. It is also obvious from 75 years of occupation the Jew can not remain in Israel. This ideology can be dealt with after the people are saved. You do not tell a drowning person you have a life ring but first you must be able to swim. ?

A.k.a. Muslims won’t help “Palestinians” \nThey deserve to live on their land and I guess the right to continuously attack Israel???

He is right but war is war, and when you start a war you have to live with the consequences.\nAnd that is the truth for every war

Palestinians have a right to live on their land with dignity

What an outrageous question ! She is not concerned by the horrific atrocities taking place in Gaza and in the Westbank against the Palestinians ! They are being slaughtered, arrested and humiliated, deprived of food and water ! Iz Not Real is besieging and slaughtering the Palestinians. They need to live in peace, they don't want to leave their land ! They have the right to defend themselves from the occupation, from the oppression and from the continuous humiliations they have been subjected to for 75 years !

NO, the cost of living in Canada has not *always* been high. For someone as young as this woman that may be true, since people usually say *always* to refer to their own lifespan. When I went to Canada (Toronto) in 1967, it was quite easy to find a one-bedroom apartment for $100-130 . Nothing luxurious of course, but acceptable. Public transport cost 25 cents (!), 5 tickets for $1.00. Working-class salaries were in the range of $100-150 per week. The value of the Canadian dollar was 7% less than that of the US dollar. My wife and I were actors who worked in a children's theatre for $45/week. Slim pickings, but with our approx. $370/month we got along all right, went to the movies, bought records and books,, ate in restaurants from time to time, bought food cheap in the Kensingto Market and got a complete tax refund at the end of the year. There was an air of general prosperity Things have changed drastically over the years, obviously.

First of all, people needs to learn how to stop pointing fingers. The Palestinians said it's their land, the Israelis proved it's their land through history. So there is no end for this finger pointing , only endless suffering when there is war. We should educate the people to advocate peaceful living for both sides not just continuously condemning one side, by doing that you are actually depriving their rights to defend themselves.

So the Jews have the right to live in their God given land, the right to defend themselves and the right to stop Hamas from repeating the Oct 7 experience. Palestinians do not want to leave their land but they will suffer the consequences of not respecting the rights of Israel.

The Palestinians have the right to live free of Hamas

That shows u whos coming when they are tearing that fence up. Come the right way like many of us did. It took years. Stop having 2 3 4 kids and we have to pay for it. People thi k this is funny? Do u k ow where they dtay? I live in s place where they a mile sesy turned s ice Hotel into a hiding place for them they have big gates they put up. Theyive in the hotel rooms and start the process snd they ha e kids lots of them.. free rent free pbones free money our government hiding this and we are sll paying for it. They say they want a betterife. Well hire one cause o i.d u dont know who they are and starting wage 30 hour. Yep thats right 30.

What does the person presenting the video and probably ninety percent of responding to it have in common and really do not want to tell you this. There political ideology lines up closer to the far right in the USA. So it’s no surprise they would be sad and angry living in Canada and am glad they live by their convictions and move out.

Stay in your own country fight for your own country make a country of your own. You came from a country go back there and live make it right

Israel has the right to live in safety also . However praying for peace in that area ??

To the people who say to the Arabs, why don't you take the Palestinians to your countries? We, the Arabs, each of us consider Palestine as our inevitable country, so it is impossible for us to give up our property and rights. Do not ask this question again because I will ask you, what if a criminal occupied your home? Would you live with one of your members like a coward or would you defend your right?!

Why would you want to ask that kind of question basically you telling the Arab world to leave their land. I live in US with my AK if someone told me to leave my land, you better think twice. Free Palestinian Palestinian has the right to defend itself.

Anyone has taken one or two steps back to look at the big picture and noticed similar economic turns in most Western countries combined with increasing taxes and laws making renting out flats and houses if you are an owner very difficult? Are we looking at the WEF grand work here? Will private property be first challenged as a moral right then debated in parliaments and senates around the world then scrapped and the by then unemployed population moved to 'centers' or 'concentrated living units'?

And “THAT” is even MORE TRUE for\nISRAEL ??!!! Their Right to live in\ntheir Land in Peace and Safety !!! ?\n ??❤️??

Palestinians have the right to live on their land, in their homeland. If u luv israel give them ure home.

What about Israels right to live savely on their land an not to be attacked by hammas

Israel also have the right to live in their land safely without terror

Respected Minister provided true facts to the uninformed reporter with the rightv wing narrative. Palestinians have land and the right to live there peacefully. .

When they speak Arabic, u sometimes think they don't understand English but his response moved me. His government has the right people in right positions. I loved that response. Why would Palestinians live their land????

so the reporter does not support they have right to live in their land and right to live in peace.

He failed to mention that Hamas must stop terrorizing Israel! The Arab world must accept Israel as a Jewish State and that all Jews have the right to be in Israel! The Palestinians must reject Hamas as their leader! Live and let live! Look at what Hamas has done to the Palestinians with the support of Iran! Get rid of the hate and there will be peace!

He is right that Palestinians don’t want to leave their home they want to live as any other citizen in their country does in peace ?

I'm an expat Brit living in Alberta with my wife, we've seen a significant downturn in quality of life due to the shocking cost of living, which in turn has driven up homelessness and that's has driven crime and drug abuse through the roof. I fear the far right are going to take hold of the narrative and start to rise here as they are in Europe.

Salam, Thanks for getting it RIGHT. Palestinians have the Inalienable Right to live in Peace and Dignity in their own LAND and the Right to Defend itself from Apartheid Israel the Colonialist and Settlers. Caged Bird Will Sing. You’ll act as if you’ll don’t KNOW.

OK so from now on prevent muslim migrants to enter Europe! They have the right to live in their own country too ?

The media and several right wing groups are so determined to get Arab nations to take more refugees. This is horrible because that land will be lost to Zionist aggression forever and they will never return home like the 3 million Palestinian refugees that live in Jordan for example.

What about Israel having a right to live in peace without the bombing’s that have been going on for years now? I stand with Gods chosen people ??

Also Israelis have their right to live

Even Israel has the right to live. Live let live will help both to survive. Use aids from other nations for development, not for weapons and tunnel building.

Ya Allah truth spoken Saudi's Prince , reporter one Question to you ,should you leave your place and land where you live , with out any rishen , why must Palestinians leave Palestina and for who , what Saudi's Prince says is true,stop the wars , murdered, attacking, annexatie, innocent Palestinians, Gaza Muslims and little children, no any fors to leave Palestina, and Gaza , is Your land , absulutely Palestinians, Gaza Muslims have right on their land with own statement , and big issue for Israëliërs ,the road what Israëliërs have make is in Palestinians territory , think about no any dominantion to Palestinians more from Israëliërs Allah hu Akbar, Allah is Great, Sukria Prince of Saudi Arabië so soft ,clear openly spoken message Masha Allah Subhan Allah Ameen

Notice that all western media always ask why Arab countries won't take the Palestinians but nobody ask who gave the Zionist Jews the right to harrass, exterminate or otherwise get rid of the Palestinians off the land that Ancestraly both Jews and Arabs lived in peace on?

But Israelis don’t have the right to live in their land with out fear of rockets stabbings shootings etc etc ???\nעם ישאל חי לעולם ??❤️

GREAT ANSWER FOR THE QUESTION!! PALESTINIANS HAVE RIGHT TO LIVE PEACEFULLY AND WITH SAFETY IN THEIR OWN LAND.

Palestinians have the right to live in their land !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

***National Post***\nMuslim leaders should've condemned Hamas instead of fomenting hate\nIf they had spoken out against terrorism, their advocacy of the Palestinian cause would carry much more weight. \n\nPart of the reason we are seeing division, hatred and unrest in the streets of Montreal, Toronto and other communities across Canada is due to the collective failure of Muslim leaders, in Canada and around the world, to condemn the despicable Oct. 7 terror attack by Hamas on Israeli civilians. \n\nIt was a horrific and cowardly attack by a terrorist group — not by all Palestinians, Arabs or the wider Muslim community. It should have been condemned and contained immediately. Muslims who pride themselves as followers of a peaceful religion should have empathized and consoled the grieving Jews. \n\nThere was a lot of time to do this. There was a lengthy delay between the attack and Israel’s ground offensive in Gaza. Instead of taking this time to condemn Hamas’s slaughter, Arab and Muslim politicians and government leaders promoted anti-Jewish hate to shore up their political support. This is nothing less than encouraging antisemitism. \n\nMuslim political and religious leaders, barring rare exceptions, chose to contextualize, equivocate and, in most cases, justify Hamas’s barbarity. What we have, as a result, is widespread hate bordering on violence in Canada — a country where communities have historically lived side-by-side in peace. \n\nThe situation got worse due to the statements made by community leaders like Amira Elghawaby, Canada’s special representative on combating Islamophobia, who did not hide her partisan and divisive outlook by clearly siding with the protesters on Canadian streets, characterizing them as “peaceful demonstrations,” even though we have seen people supporting Hamas, calling for genocide against Israeli Jews and harassing and intimidating Jewish-owned businesses. \n\nOn Twitter, Elghawaby approvingly cited a quote from a Toronto Star column reading, “The stories I have heard are both fantastical and true. Muslims (and others who silently sympathize with the loss of Palestinians lives) are being disciplined, maligned, isolated and targeted at work.” \n\nInstead of reaching across the aisle and consoling the Jewish community, she has instead chosen to focus her public comments on rising Islamophobia. \n\nSeriously? Remember the Muslim family who were killed in a hate-related attack in London, Ont., a couple years ago? All communities, including the Jewish community, across the political and religious spectrum unambiguously condemned that hate crime. And it brought a sense of relief and security to Muslims in Ontario. \n\nRemember how, after more that 50 people were gunned down while worshipping at mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, in 2019, political and religious leaders from all faiths stood behind Muslims and consoled them? \n\nAlso, after the Quebec mosque attack, almost all communities in Canada chose to stand with Muslims. There were images of people in Alberta who formed a human chain to protect Muslims. Similar scenes were witnessed elsewhere in the country. Jewish community leaders spoke out, loud and clear, in support of Muslims and against hate and bigotry. \n\nBut that is not what Elghawaby did. Instead, she makes it sounds as though it is Muslims who are the victims, while failing to mention the barbarity unleashed on Oct. 7. This is not leadership. This is not her mandate. Her job is to promote tolerance as enshrined in Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. \n\nNow imagine a scenario in which Muslims did what they ought to have done in the first place: condemned the Hamas attack, sided with the Jewish victims and dissociated themselves from terrorism. Their voices for the Palestinian cause would have carried much more weight. \n\nWhat we are seeing instead is a rising tide of anti-Jewish hate on our streets, promoted and peddled by Muslim leaders themselves, either by gaslighting the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, or wallpapering it with the political colours of the Palestinian cause. \n\nLet us all come together, not to let hate be poured onto the streets of Canada, but to stand united for a secure and prosperous country. \n\nNational Post \n\nRaheel Raza and Mohammad Rizwan are members of the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism.

Palestinians have right to live on there land . Palestinians have right to defend itself from occupation extremist. \nFree Palestine.

Very well said. Palestinians have a right to live on their own land.

Palestinian have a land and they have right to live their witg dignity and security❤❤❤