Close Reading

We don’t have a right to the land. There comes a point that after so many wars you must lose your land. This has happened since the dawn of time. Wars happen borders change. If China ever invaded my homeland of USA and we lost I’d just become chinese. It’s not really a big deal. My land used to be Spanish 200 years ago and British before that and Indian before that. Just live in peace and harmony with your neighbors and spend resources building a society instead of terrorists ❤

His answer is NO.\nAnd it sounds like he is fine letting everyone that wants out now too stay because it would be better if there was not war... But there is war.\nTruth is the southern border with egypt is full of people trying to flee gaza. I am sure they want to come back but right now this man's ideology doesn't help anyone living in reality

And the Jews have the right to their land. They have the righy to live in Isreal. The Palestinians must stop their nonsense. Its the Palestinians who doesn't want peace. Hamas doesnt care about their own peoples lives. And the world is starting to see that.

Who in their right mind would want to live in a country that our leader's have fill to the brim with terrorists from all over the world

You forfeit your right to live when your reigning government (hamas) attacks sovereign nations

The Palestinians have a RIGHT to live in their land. ? israel

The Palestinian people have no original authority/ties to the land in which they occupy. At best, they are squatters privileged by Israel to live in those designated zones, peacefully I might add. They have allowed Hamas, funded by Iran to control their lives, and bring havoc. Israel has every right to control, and defend its sovereignty. And people who support the Hamas, especially here in the US, should be ashamed of their ignorance….

Right of living is also for israel. Palestine should stop the killing of Israeli

Yes, of course the Palestinian people have the right to their land and the right to live on their land in dignity, peace and security but if nobody makes Israel stop butchering them, shouldn't someone at least offer them temporary refuge? I would want that if I were stuck there with my loved ones.

None of country need to take Palestinian That is their own land right to live there.

That is very well answered. Palestinians do have the right to live in their land. The killing has to stop.

I hope this guy realizes Israel has a right to exist and a right to live on their land.

An analogy would be jews from new york city moving to miami….settling their and then killing the cuban americans who have lived there for generations. The property that cuban americans own in miami, florida belongs to them! \n\nBut the jews from nyc who just moved to miami start forcing out the cubans and demand that georgia and alabama take the cuban americans. \n\nThat doesnt make any sense.\n\nThat’s not right.

Excellent answer. Palestinians have the right to live there period. It seems to me that someone wants them out so badly and is using media to spread propaganda and misinformation.

The UN is crap. The Gazans could have lived in peace for the last 75 years if they accepted Israel's right to exist. The Gaza is apartheid. No Jews allowed. Israel is not apartheid. There are millions of Muslims in Israel.

Palestine is not a country. It's never been a country. Palestinians are a combination of Egyptians, Jordanians, Syrians, and Lebanese arabs that were expelled from their countries and the British Mandate. The area of land you're referring to is not Palestine. It's Israel or, if you want to go back further, Judea and Sumaria. The people who rightfully live there, and have lived there for thousands of years, are happy to let others live there as well; as long as they're peaceful. Seems to be hard for some.

Missed out on the perfect follow up question: should Palestinians give Israel the same respect they are asking for? They cannot wrap their heads around it: they believe Israel does not have the right to live in their own land in safety and security, and not be forced out, nor will they stop the killing of Israelis by rockets and other attacks.

This reporter has no shame! She doesn’t care that Palestinians are being ethnically cleaned out of their own land, yet has the audacity to question those who support their right to live on their land.

Israel has the right to live in peace and safety too, now if the Palestinians would stop attacking Israel then all would be peaceful

He is 100% correct. The Palestinians have every right to live in their land and no one has a right to force them to leave their land?

Why are they asking other countries to take the refugees? Why did they become refugees in the first place because of greed and power? People have a right to stay on their land to be driven out because of hate and racism. Let people live like you're letting your people live.

Do the Israelites not have the same rights? They have a historical right to thier land, they just want to live in peace but to begin try to achieve this hamas has to go.

All the Arabs keep saying the Palestinians have the right to live on their land but never mention the Jews have the right to live in their ancestral land as well.

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.

Israel have right to live in their land.

? Israel gave Hamas led Palestine decades ago, so if Palestine wants to live in peace then they must tell their Hamas government to stop making terror attacks on Israel, because Israel has the sovereign right and will respond. It's an easy weight to remove, but it wont happen as long as Hamas is in government. Palestinians must not re-elect Hamas. Its that simple.

The Muslim-Arabs in Judea-Samaria have the right to live in safety and security... but not the innocent Jewish people that they massacred? Now tell me, what's wrong with that picture?

And yet when asked about a 2 state solution they don't want that at all. As though Isrealis don't have that right or cannot have the dignity to live in the land that was their since biblical times. \nAlthough well spoken truth is no one wants to help a lending hand to Palestinians since they think of them to be untrustworthy.

The Israelis have the right to live in their land in safety and security also and if the palestinians aren't going to allow that by slaughtering their civilian babies, children, women and elderly then they lose their right to peace and security. \nFor this guy to say they (Arabs world) won't take the Palestinians because they deserve to stay in Gaza is just gas lighting. I bet his country supplies humanitarian aid to his enemies during war also. Hippocrits.

Yes, but note he didn't state they have a right to a separate nation. He's basically saying what most sane people are saying. Get rid of Hamas, reunification of the Palestinian people with the rest of the nation, right to education, work, and representation in the Israeli government. Gotta get rid of the indoctrination of a false Palestinian state when there has never been one. We live in a world of misinformation clearly & deluded people who think men can be women, women can be men, and numerous false identities despite not facts to back it up.

Same goes for Jews. They have the right to the land, to exist and live safely, secured, not threatened by the neighbour.

Excellent video. I am a 29 years old Canadian with high education. I make 125K/year and yet after 2-3 years of looking actively I still can't manage to buy a house near the city as a first time buyer. I made many offers but lost every time. The demand is so high and the offer so low that many people bid way above the asking price even though the prices are sky high. Most of those people sold their previous house for a lot more than they bought it many years ago and therefore, are able to do so. First time buyers like myself don't have this advantage and the ones with lower salaries might never have the chance to have a house except if they move far from the city. Our government does not slow down on immigration because there is a labor shortage due to the older generation retiring but they don't build enough houses and allowed foreign investors for too long which results in the housing crisis we are currently in. My father bought a decent house near the city for the equivalent of 2 years of his gross salary at the time... Now the equivalent is more than 4-5 times my gross salary even though I make more than him at the time (taking inflation into account). Our healthcare and education systems are falling apart as well. Both are currently on strike in the province I live in due to terrible work conditions and salaries from our government. The cost of living has increased considerably in the last few years as well, especially the food even though the companies are making record net profits this year. Yeah... Canada is not doing well right now.

palestinians has all the right to live in their own country with peace if they dont allow hamas terorist in their community and put legitimate democratic goverment to govern them. im sure aid from different country did not go to waste.

I was about to move to Toronto right before covid hit and live with my girlfriend at the time. Moving from Florida. then i tried moving after covid on my own we broke up and man being disabled and trying to get to toronto or ca in general they really make it hard af. im on a waiting list for buffalo ny. It's alot easier to move their and i can easily travel to toronto whenever i want.

You nailed it Sonia, me and my family of as been living here for about 17 years and yes we have been through it all, so I could actually feel the clock turning as you spoke. I would like to add one thing though which you are right about that, if you are planning to come and start now, it definitely is not the time to come, 17 years ago was a different time and I can also tell you that we feel the pain yet even now to make ends meet. Honestly, life was good until a few years ago but now the value is declining to a great extent, again as a disclaimer this is my personal experience and would probably apply differently to different individuals. In short, as you said, if you are doing well somewhere else, don't hit the axe on your own feet by coming here.

So he just said - we will send aid, but we won’t (even temporarily) take in any Palestinians or send any military to protect them so they can keep their land… right so Land is more important than human LIVES. Tell that to a 5 year old getting blown up right now - I’m pretty sure they would prefer safety.

As someone who came to Canada, the huge problem for me right now is rent prices compared to the wages, and the taxes don't make it easier, everyone is living off their credit card, they can't keep up with the rent with their wages.

Do the jews have the right to live on their land without having rockets shot at them?

NO WHERE in this piece of propoganda, did the author mention human rights. Some of the alternative countries have even more bigotry than Canada and restrictions on letting people choose their own lives. \nAsk a BLM person, a Muslim person, or LGBTQ person in America how confident they are about their entire country.

I agree ❤with him. Everyone has a right to their dignity, to live free on the land of their birth, raising their children like any other citizens.. peace ✌️ ☮️ to all mankind ❤❤❤❤❤stop the ki....g

Disgusting get them and their families out of the country. They come to the west Christian countries and they dictate what we should do. Follow the rules and cultures of the countries you go to . Can you imagine a Christian doing this in a Muslim country. They’d be beheaded in the street in front of baying crowds. No such thing as Shari law in Britain. Go to a Muslim country if you want Shari law or learn to live and respect other people’s rights and choices.

Many of the issues you bring up are the same here, but I am willing to deal with those over the impending chaos we are seeing down here. I am an American living close to the border in Buffalo, but I am considering a move to Canada due to the political climate down here. I would rather pay a little more in taxes & gas than deal with the Christian Taliban we are heading for. The Canadian housing market can be fixed, food prices can come down, but once you start losing rights, it's time to consider your options. When I (a straight white guy in his 50's) can see the writing on the wall, it's getting close to time. That being said, living in a state (New York) that will fight the incoming stripping of our rights, will buy us a few years. I can deal with all the other things (high housing costs, soul crushing medical debt, overpriced college, & out of control gun violence), but we are way too close to a civil war for my comfort. I travel up and down the east coast and don't believe what they are saying, we are way too close to a pre-WW2 Germany situation for anyone to feel safe. The amount of gun owners threatening violence is very concerning.

❤❤❤Maashallah, ?% You are right everything. Palestinian want to live their land safe and sound. Thank you very my young gentleman.

It's astonishing to see so many Canadians voicing serious complaints about their country. More to hear complaints coming from immigrants who then left Canada in disgust and found better lives elsewhere is even more astonishing.\n Yet I warn everyone else. It's okay for Canadians to complain about their own country. They have every right. As for immigrants or immigrants who left Canada, well, they were there and experienced the downside, so they have legitimacy.\n But for any other non-Canadian, including me, keep our mouths shut and say nothing. Let only the Canadians speak here. If you non-Canadians are foolish enough to open your mouth, a hundred angry Canadians will come here to loudly denounce you and maybe swear profanities for demeaning their perfect nation, Canada, and that all these complaints really don't exist and are made up.

Ask him about Israelis \n.do they have right to live?

Because Canada’s human rights record is now very poor and many of the immigrants have left tyrannical regimes and don’t want to live in another. Sad really but when they discard Justin and his “Illiberals” things may change.

Its not their land, it was once Jordanian land but Jordan lost. The only reason Gaza and the West Bank exist in its present form is because Israel wants to live in peace with the people in THEIR land. Personally I think Israel should invade Lebanon and forceably move all Palestinians to that area. They could do the same thing in Syria. At that point, all the Arabs can give all the Palestinians all the aid they want because they will no longert be in Israel. \nIran should be being blockaded and Tehran should look just like Gaza. I do appreciate that these Islamic countries have the arrogance they do, doesnt make them right though, at all.

What sick notion is that. Every Palestinian has the right To live on that land with dignity and respect. Did we forget Nabi Esa (AS) (Prophet Jesus) is Palestine born in Jerusalem.

I lived and worked in TO in a few areas for several years. I left in 2016. I am glad I left before it got bad. I started witnessing more racist comments on subway and platforms were becoming too crowded. After 30 plus years I moved to live in a rural area before moving to live in a similar setting to where I grew up in Oakville. I do love TO and it has so much to offer. I worked downtown and just could not keep up. I spent my spare time walking along the beaches especially Scarborough Bluffs and skating at Harbourfront on a weekday. These are fond memories that I will cherish.\n\n I heard that the shelters were over crowded and unhealthy places. I met a nice man in my building who was successful, lived on street for 13 years before successfully integrating into low-income housing. I learned the most from his stories and met some of the most fabulous people in the worst buildings. I had to leave for safety and mental health reasons. I could not see myself remaining in TO without support. \n\n I made the right move in the right time. Not everyone can afford city living. My quality of life and mental health are better but I cherish the friendships I made in TO. My Grandfather was a Mcleod and I am amazed how much you look like my mother when she was younger. She modeled for Ford and volunteered for a local Vet and hospital. I wish you well. I appreciate your honesty. Since I left, I have driven by TO on 407 a few times. I just didn't have the right mix of education and work to survive in the city any more.

This isn't meant to be racist or anti immigrant, but i must point out that this entire situation you're describing is worse for Canadian born Canadians that don't have roots anywhere else. About 50 years ago, the recently deceased Henry Kissinger went to China at the behest of David Rockefeller to open up manufacturing in the country and to use US construction firms to build China into a modern society with modern infrastructure. They also took all of the manufacturing sectors that were created, perfected and relied upon by the North Americans and handed them over to foreign countries they were developing into the modern economic powerhouses they are now. \nNow that we're poor and have no manufacturing sectors to sustain a healthy middle class anymore, we welcome people from the countries who received our manufacturing sectors and have prospered greatly from it to our countries where they continue to make things here economically worse by making us compete with nouveau rich foreigners for our limited housing and infrastructure. Again, im not blaming the average citizen, North American or not. I am strictly blaming billionaires who think they have the right to control the world for their own benefit. But at least you have an economically rising country that is affordable to live in that you can retreat to at anytime. People with only a Canadian passport do not have that option.