Close Reading

But they don't have the right to attack their neighbors.

I guess we’re just not going to even address the fact that the Palestinians overly attack their neighbors in the most barbaric ways, and refused to make peace over decades and decades? Oh, OK I guess I’ve wandered back into the anti-Semitic part of the Internet. I better get out of here.

Its not their land, every country that brings in Palestinians are met with turmoil (why no arab countries bring them in anymore), and a terrorist organization hords the money and resources from its own citizens while attacking its neighbor. Make it make sense

I would have liked his answer because this is the right way of doing things, only hiccup is Hamas attacked first and its been elected by Palestinians and protected in public areas, so there's no way the weight should be lifted to ensure Palestinian right by crossing Israel's boundaries and crushing its right to defend itself. If Arab world is so concerned about Palestinian rights then they should give them temporary refuge, help Israel eradicate Hamas and then let the Humanitarian aid to rebuild Palestine and safely send the Palestinians back to their land. \n\nIf you are not helping them in tough situations then your pushing for ceasefire is just a show off, because you are not helping with actual issue of Hamas terrorism.

So what hes saying is, they dont want the problems they bring, egpyt and Jordan already had terror attacks when they let gaza refugess in before and thats why they wont take them again

Meanwhile the whole entire situation was started by Hamas. It is Hamas hiding in the hospitals and schools and homes. Maybe the Palestinians need to kick Hamas out and the attacks will stop. You think there weren't any civilian casualties during WW1, WW2, Korea, Vietnam, the 100 year war in the Middle East?

By stopping terrorist attacks by Muslims

They want the Palestinians to be suffering so they can attack Israel that’s why they won’t help.

As from India we stand with the Israel??. The 1948 peel commission gave most of their land to arabs but they refused it they want whole of Israel and genocide of Israeli population no way any country will stand with this hamas terrorist attack.. We unite with ?? . Peel comission 1948, 1970 the 1993summit in every chance arab had they refused 2 state solution so it's their agenda don't fall for it

So the jews can't defend themselves? Who constantly attacks? Who has never accepted a peace deal? Thats right palestine

Really. In 47, 67, and 72 SA was supporting the attacks on Israel for its destruction. Biassed pro-Islamic because of he isn’t the Hanbali led public will attack the Kingdom.

It is best not to attack another country. This is a perfect example of f*** around and find out

SO DOES ISRAEL. STOP PRETENDING THEY WERE NOT THE ATTACKERS. THE LAND OF ISREAL BELONGED TO ABRAHAM, ISAAC, JACOB, THEN THEIR RETURN FROM EGYPT IN JOSHUA'S DAY. IT WAS PROMISED TO THEM. HAMAS JUST WANTS THEM GONE. STOP MASKING WHAT YOU REALLY WANT TO SAY!

So you don't want them there where you live. They shouldn't attack Israel.

Why did the Palestinians attack Israel to start the war ? The Palestinians teach their kids to hate Israel from the beginning! \nIsrael doesn’t teach their kids to hate Palestinians in school.

Ok so then how will this ever come to be if Palestine keeps sending bombs to Isreal? I know that Isreal is bombing them back to really badly but they brought it on to thier selfs just imagine a state in Iran that says it don't want to be a state in Iran so Iran gives them land to be in but then the people who are in that land want more they are not happy so they start bombing Iran and then Iran attacks the land you would all be ok with that right? Why because its the same religion killing each other all Palestine has to do is stopping fighting Isreal make peace work together stop spending all your money on weapons and armies that are just dying Palestine with the land it has can be great but they just want war! And the jews are not so innocent also they take land they mistreated people of other ethnicities but that being said war is not the way they both need to stop

But he failed to mention that, if Israel is not being attacked, there wouldn’t be any attack; what did Saudi Arabia do in Yemen? Exactly my point.

Palestinian should’ve never attacked Israel Israel tried to work with Palestinian but you fools think you know better

Too bad we tried that and we’re still attacked by terrorist…they act like Israel has been occupying Gaza since 1948, it’s a false narrative and yes if they did care, the Arab nations that initiated the war would help the people instead of turning their back on them in order to make Israel the oppressor.

THEN WHY DID YOUR PRECIOUS HAMAS ATTACK THE ISRAELITES FIRST KILLING INNOCENT WOMEN AND CHILDREN IF THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE WANTED TO STAY IN THEIR LAND PEACEFULLY AND SAFELY??

Well, they shouldn’t have attacked Israel. WTF?

BS its Yemen thats stopping aid getting through attacking ships

Question - let’s say Mexican Cartels attacked Texas and felt Texas was their land (it belonged to Mexico before, then Spain before that, then the American Indians before that) …. And Texas retaliated and counter attacked the Mexican Cartels causing Mexicans to flee south into Latin America… would yall blame Texas for causing all of this? Would it really be acceptable for Latin American not to take a single refugee?

Palestine has no right on land of they continue attacks

You forfeit your right to live when your reigning government (hamas) attacks sovereign nations

Haha, this doesn't answer the question—kind of an oblivious response. Hamas attacked Israel so they have a right to defend their land. We don't need to be rocket scientists to know that they are going to do it again. Further Hamas uses its people when it attacks Israelis. Where have any other Arab nations shown any type of involvement in condemning Hamas and intervening by stopping Hamas whether it's through negotiations or by force? it's because most of them back Hamas and know if they don't take any refugees it's only going to cause Israel more harm than if they were terrorists. People condemning Israel are stupid. Take your time to look into the entire matter before pointing a finger to entertain your life.

In simple words : No, we won't take a single refugee.\nWell when Ukraine was attacked western countries take a lot of there refugees these clearly shows ACTION SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS.

He deflected to the actual reason they don't take refugees. They want casualties and Palestinians to distract and attack Israel. They can't do that if the innocent and others are not present.

But if they attack others, how can they expect to be left alone in their land?

Missed out on the perfect follow up question: should Palestinians give Israel the same respect they are asking for? They cannot wrap their heads around it: they believe Israel does not have the right to live in their own land in safety and security, and not be forced out, nor will they stop the killing of Israelis by rockets and other attacks.

Israel has the right to live in peace and safety too, now if the Palestinians would stop attacking Israel then all would be peaceful

Cop out! They still are funneling money for them to attack Israel. Back in September there was no blockade no aid needed no issues until they messed with Israel.

I guess you shouldn't attack your neighbors, if you don't have the man power and fire power to back it up and then cry victim, when your neighbors begin demo'ing your land and buildings

Maybe they shouldn’t have attacked Israel then huh?

It’s not their land! He’s just covering for the Arab world turning their backs on Palestine. Is Palestine wanted to live peacefully, they wouldn’t be attacking Israel all the time.

So in other words, instead of taking the 2 million in Gaza to the vast unused space in the Arab world they want to keep them there to have a endless excuse to attack Israel - gotcha

Palestinians allow the HAMAS group in their land, allowing the HAMAS group to attack others.\n\nYou got to separate the Palestinians and HAMAS

Then WHY attack Izrel with 70.000 rockets? Why send paratroopers to a festival? WHY put babies in ovens?!

He basically said: they made their bed and now they can lie in it. \n\nThere’s quite a few Palestinians trying to leave and seek refuge in Egypt since they opened their borders to take a limited number of them in.. as long as they’re not associated with Hamas. \n\nHamas brought this war to the Palestinian’s doorstep in Gaza and if other Arab nations don’t want to open their borders to the Palestinians who would like to leave because of the war, then there will be an increased number of civilian casualties. Just because their fellow Arabs refuse to take them as refugees doesn’t mean Israel loses the right to defend itself from the barbaric terrorist attack Hamas launched against them. \nAny other country would have the right to defend itself from terrorists that live at their borders. If Hamas cared about their citizens, they’d have a plan for them and their safety once they initiated this war on Oct 7th. But it seems like Hamas’s only plan for them was to be disposable pawn martyrs caught in between them and Israeli forces. \n\nYou can’t torture, rape and kill 1,400 Israeli citizens/foreign nationals and take 200+ hostages back to Gaza during a depraved terrorist attack and then cry ceasefire when that country declares war and is winning. Especially when you’re still holding onto hostages and not honoring the terms of the first ceasefire by letting the Red Cross see the hostages. \n\nIf these other countries cared about the Palestinians, they’d take any refugees that wanted to leave. They clearly don’t want to do that for some reason. They’re watching from afar with their popcorn, saying “isn’t it terrible what the Israeli’s are doing.. but we won’t let them come here to escape, which would let the Israelis fight this war with Hamas, who initiated it, without civilians in between.” With no mention of how Hamas as put them in the middle and isn’t protecting them. Also no mention of any responsibility Hamas has for bring this war onto them by the large scale terrorist attack, that includes hundreds of civilian hostages of all ages.

? Israel gave Hamas led Palestine decades ago, so if Palestine wants to live in peace then they must tell their Hamas government to stop making terror attacks on Israel, because Israel has the sovereign right and will respond. It's an easy weight to remove, but it wont happen as long as Hamas is in government. Palestinians must not re-elect Hamas. Its that simple.

The weight= Stopping the rockets, stopping a terrorist organisation from attacking?‍♂️ Muslims please dont forget this part

Cardiologist takes care of heart attack patient orthopedic surgeon take care of bone fractured patient your analysis is not good please understand the medical specility

So does Israel. They have the right and left Gaza in 2025 Yet they still attacked Israel

The Arab countries such as his brought about the problem in 1947, by refusing to allow the Palestinians to have their own Sovereign country with the UN`s two state solution, Israel accepted it and became a sovereign country, whilst 5 Arab countries attacked them to inflict Genocide on the Jews ,and to wipe the newly fledged Israel off the Middle East map. It didn`t work and they were defeated. Even Mahmoud Abbas said it was the fault of the Arabs not to accept the solution, But it took him until 2011, Pathetic.

Doesn't Israel have the right to their land and safety and security also. This wouldn't be happening if they hadn't been attacked and their people taken hostage. If Israel doesnt defend themselves and make sure their people can be secure in their own homes this would continue to happen and would get worse. God bless Israel.

So jews have a rite to not get attacked or if attacked they have the rite to destroy their attacker.

They had a land for one day and they attack Israel, They don't want a land what they don't want is a non Muslim land in the area, they proved it in 1948, and they keep saying it, why don't we listen to them. Arabs want to conquer the world, soon or later the pro palestinians woke all over the western countries will understand, but will it be too late?.

Did Hamas care for wellbeing Palestinians when they attacked Israel civilians, or is it Palestine people that has some utopia human rights? Not to mention that Israel provides humanitarian aid, food, medicine and Hamas takes it.

So, tell them stop messing with the Jew people then.\nIt is not Israel attacking them.\nIsrael is defending them self from extermination.

Right! But he didn't care to explain how the attacks and genocide will end, when neither UN nor Arab world has done anything in this regard!