Close Reading

A lot of Mexicans are in Canada applying for asylum, Brazil is another million doing the same. There is no war in Mexico or Brazil.

What people don't understand is that you can't just start a process in any country unless you have and meet the grounds for starting a process. Each process has its own regulations. Example: For asylum to take place, you have to prove you have a well founded fear of persecution from your home country due to your race, religion, or political opinion. Most of the illegals claiming asylum base on economic hardship, or violence from local gangs, will not win an asylum case. Wanting a better life for your family is not considered valid grounds. The same with legal status: You have to first become a resident which means you have to be petitioned by an immediate family member ( A Parent or sibling with a legal status in the US). Depending who petitioned you, it can be a very lengthy process, up to 26 yrs if your sibling submitted the application! Process is much faster for spouses and kids of US Citizens. Only after several years as a legal resident can you apply for Citizenship. Spouses married to US Citizens is 3 yrs, IF you know english. If you don't you might have to wait till you are 65, when you qualify for the test to be in your native language, but only if you have been a resident more than 20 yrs and so forth. As you can see doing it legally, is a lengthy process, but all these caravans think they can just march in and let the countries accept them without going thru the process and it has caused major problems all the way around. That's why the laws must be enforced to eliminate these invasions!

Something trump supporters and everyone needs to understand is that there is NO application to just apply and come here legally! That’s why her family has been here for 20 something years. Only people that can “apply” are asylum seekers. Anyone from any other country there is no such application. There would only be an “application” is there was an immigration reform that would allow people that want to come or have been here to apply. There has not been immigration reform/amnesty in decades. \n\nI urge everyone to YouTube or go on the uscis website and find this so called application. The only way is either 1. You were born somewhere else and your parents are citizens 2. Enlist in US military 4. Marriage with a us citizen. So it’s not as easy as just applying, if it was there wouldn’t be so much illegal immigration. \n\nNo excusing or saying it’s okay to come illegally, just saying the reason people do it that way is because there hasn’t been and there currently is no process to do it legally.

So its a good thing Melania and her father got their papers due to her marriage to Trump already or they would be deported...such luck! How lucky she was to get in with an Einstein VISA even though she's dumb as a rock, allegedly, while undocumented workers and those who have filed for asylum or applied for a visa have to wait 20 or 30 years to get it, if they get residency at all after paying the last dime to the immigration lawyers who scam them.

Wait until Trump starts Mass Deportations applied for asylum in Canada it's going to grow and once you get them in You will not be able to remove them mark my words!

Remain in Mexico applies to arriving aliens applying for asylum, not asylum seekers who have already been admitted. The latter contravenes federal immigration law, and that's something that a President can't do via executive order. As well, if we deport asylum seekers to a different country, or make asylum seekers wait in another country as their asylum cases are adjudicated, the US government is STILL responsible for providing essential resources and ensuring their safety (this includes providing migrant centers) and the US cannot impede on their right to counsel - and by virtue of making them stay in another country that doesn't HAVE US immigration attorneys, this DOES impede their access to legal council, which is an immediate infringement on civil rights and a key reason why Remain in Mexico was challenged up to the Supreme Court and was kept from fully going into effect.

Here's a crazy idea say no vacancy we don't owe them anything especially screwing canada worse than Trudeau already screwed it up the rules of immigration is they have to apply for asylum in the first country they stepped foot in, turn them away or watch the end of canada entirely!

all those future democrat voters will have to go home and apply for asylum the old fashioned way. good luck with that

Well the best thing to do for those illegal immigrant to come to Canada would be they go to India, apply for a student visa, come to Canada, join the Khalistani gang, apply for ASYLUM ,get a citizenship of Canada and join one of the gangster either Lawrence Bisnoi or Goldie Bhel gang and become a local king pin.\n\nThis is a hand made strategy by Trudeau and Singh.

Even she came illegally, later applied for green card, possibly after got one asylum

when they apply for asylum we pay benefits from our tax dollars...enough

Among indians you will find most from Punjab.People with criminal backgrounds applying for asylum and sponsored by Khalistani polliticians in Canada and the Canadian embassy is involved in this scam of giving Visas to such people

2-3 may be in Danger. Maybe even a 50-100. But when 13K apply for asylum....your country has become a damn joke, and is run by a joker.

What’s messed up is that she’s right, but wrong at the same time. She got lucky to only have to wait in line for days. What reason does she thinks her cousins, nieces, and nephews came here illegally for? It’s easier to seek asylum and work from there than to get a travel visa and apply and then just hope you don’t get deported or rejected. \n\nIt’s very telling when a yankee is interviewed and holds these sentiments- what kind of life they have lived. It isn’t out of the realm of imagination what situations many immigrants are coming from. Best case scenario they just lived paycheck to paycheck in an impoverished area. At least now they can live in an impoverished area where the government is only like 70% corrupt instead of 95% corrupt.

Dear Hind Hassan why I never seen any of your videos on topics like criminality in Europe caused by immigrants? Drugs, rapes, religion based assaults, homophobic or xenophobic attacks, violence and sexism against females?! Hm ? You always just advocates for this poor immigrants who try to flee war zones!! Where in the heck is war in Afghanistan now? Isn’t status of war refugee obtained by the law that they can apply for asylum in first safe country? If they doesn’t do ir then they are not refugees, they are economic migrants and therefore without right to demand the entry to Europe!! Me as well as European citizen if I want to go out of EU and we have no free visa policy with that country I need to apply for Visa, I do not go simply to the border with that country and requesting the entry out of nowhere!! There are certain legal procedures what applies even to us westerners and we need to follow them as well!!!

If you have applied to be a student then how can you be an asylum seeker? Someone claiming asylum would have normally come here right away and claimed asylum as their life is at risk, not try to be a student first. Any international students trying to claim asylum should have their application immediately rejected, Canada does not have the resources to deal with this scam behavior.

I feeo like these students are copying what ukrainians did... free PR card after applying for asylum

What is actual process of getting asylum?once you apply you are in ?no revoke or rejection?

If you can come here as a student, you don't need asylum. It means you have the financial capability in your home country to properly apply for the immigration process, not try to cut the lines.

Why can't they just do online studies? Either that, or make it known and agreed to that they cannot apply for citizenship or asylum as a student.

If you apply asylum, then you should be banned from ever being allowed to visit the country you apply your asylum from. I’m sure more ppl will think twice to apply….. and if you apply and your case is found to be fraudulent then that’s automatically denied and you are deported back and barred from ever entering the country again. Problem solved

Say it how it is, don’t label it as international since 100% of these students who applied for asylum are from India. Label it as Indians. You don’t students from Korea or japan applying for asylum

Students should not be allowed to apply for asylum.

Applying asylum on a student visa after entering canada is first huge violation of study permit.

Recieved asylum, not applied for.

Due to the stress of post secondary education, they had no choice but to apply for asylum… because their big bad parents make them go to school ! That’s not nice - bad parents… grant them asylum from their mommy and daddy quickly and welcome them into this rapidly failing country.

13 K international students should NEVER be allowed to apply for asylum. Canada does not need any of them. GO HOME Canada has no moral responsibility to welcome anyone into the country. I believe Justin Trudeau has a moral responsibility to take care and make sure Canadians come first.

A watch a video an Indian tourist he said the only wu to enter is by applying for asylum. Or we refuse to enter . The immigration agent told him. He has no choice. Meaning the immigration are the ones are pushing all immigrant to claim asylum.

Came here as a student, why would you need asylum?\nSurely if you need asylum now it's not Canada you should be applying for it with, no? Presumably whatever your problem is, is here?\nOr are you prepared to tell me you entered the country on false pretenses?\nAuto-reject them all.

Doesn't make sense that they could apply as asylum. They're obviously looking for a way to stay.

Simple fact is you apply as a student visa you automatically get deny as asylum seekers.

They applied as international students so obviously they were not in any danger to justify seeking asylum later on in Canada.

The rules of asylum applications are clear. You can NOT apply for asylum of your here on a student visa. Deport!

I once came across colleague who arrived on study permit, went to construction jobs while on the permit, took advantage of favouring exchange rate in his home country, send all his savings there, bought a 4 acre land and gets healthy crops there enough for his family to live a lavish life making enough to retire at 30. When his study permit and associated work permit expired and he didn't qualify for PR in Canada as per point system, applied for asylum stating political unrest back home. His asylum was accepted. We who think they are poor are fools. He was only 27 and said he will retire at 30. But I doubt he will ever go back to his home country.? Canada is his gold mine. He was from Bangladesh. Trust me Indians dont go that far. There is no political instability in India and if to the contrary Indians are claiming asylum the system is truly broken.

They are not ‘international students’ they are illegal immigrants. When they applied for students visa in India or Bangladesh they did not have any reason for asylum.

It seems like a good number of them are coming from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and the Middle East. We should definitely think about stopping student admissions, especially since tourist visas are being used to rush into Canada and apply for asylum. We need to put a stop to this kind of system abuse.

Applying for asylum under initial false pretenses is a dealbreaker and grounds for deportation.

1:28 the immigration lawyer, Max Chaudhary, said the scrutiny did not take place. That's bull and extremely naive. The foreign students lied on their applications when they agreed to return home after studying, and now are applying for asylum to extend their stay at our expense. \nThey knew full well that the student visa was not an asylum claim. It was for study only. Period. \nThe students might even be coached by professional immigration consultants, who are being well paid, to scam the Canadian system.

Students are smarter than the government lol.. they were refused extended work permits, and now they’re applying for asylum

They are applying for asylum due to protection from Canada because they ran out of money or permit and need social services welfare money to survive here in the shelters for free food and the welfare pocket money.

RELEASE THE COUNTRY DATA. I am so certain we will see just 2 countries taking the majority of these claims. Why punish all international students if thr problem seems to have 1 or 2 sources? Im sorry, but not every country is in a condition to where we can trust that the students aren't merely using study as a way to get to Canada. Until this issues are addressed back home or can be screened harder here, people from those countries should be banned from applying. Its so ridiculous. If the data shows its like a relatively even asylum application rate from like 10+ countries ok Ill shut up. If its like 1 or 2 countries. ban Ban Ban ffs.

International students applying for asylum? THAT'S MANIPULATION!!

Ofcourse if Canadian Govt. break many promises for international students, now they will apply for asylum seeker, this is the dark reality of this nation.

NDP liberal govt need to resign \nUnlimited students , unlimited refugees \nChinese , Pakistan,Bangladesh, Brazil , Indian and Nepal students applying asylum\nSad news

Former Liberals Immigration minister Sean Fraser broke our immigration. Now 13k international students , ( probably 95 percent from India ) applied asylum status. These fake asylum applicants know our current immigration is a JOKE and they are taking advantage of the system. “Welcome to Trudeau Liberals broken Immigration”

Wishful ? Ng - came across a Pakistani family with 6K per month govt payout because they got approval for asylum. Another young man is getting 2K every month though he says he has no issue in his home country and now trying to get rest of family here too from Pakistan so that they all can apply for asylum. Canada is getting cash workers for low wages jobs - Uber drivers, servers , grocery store cashiers. for life long just like Europe has been for so many years.

What about asylum seekers also entering no one is talking about! Tax rebate for asylum seekers! College made money and government made money! People travelling on tourist visa and applying for jobs ! This government is working for outsiders not for Canadian people. Kids of hardworking Canadian not getting jobs.LMIA scam also big issue employers making money in cash. Tim Hortons issuing 2000 plus lmia no one is talking about! Immigration consultant also responsible for this mess.

thwy even have the gutts to apply for asylum, based on what. no respect and unskilled

I know someone who has got a visit visa and is coming to Canada in September with 100% intention to apply for asylum. I know that he is bringing with him fake documents that will show he has a genuine case. But I know for sure that everything is fake. I have reported it to boarder security but I don’t trust that if they will check and even if they care. Because we all know these visit visa were issued to bring people and claim asylum. That’s like government is bring on purpose cheap labor and want to put the burden on existing tax payer.

All these people (Desperate Punjabis and Gujaratis ) who are crossing from Canada to US via the US Canada border and seeking Asylum will be deported as soon as possible back to canada under the safe country agreement between US and Canada. They will never be able to apply asylum in US once they are deported from US to canada. Least they will have an option to file asylum in canada will obviously wont give them any fruits given the houseful condition. ?‍??