Close Reading

Why none of the temporary workers of India, Pakistan, Singhs, Bangladesh etc ever protested in Middle east countries like Suadia Arab, Qatar, Dubai etc to extend their work permits or grant them citizenships ?? Because they know their laws how strict they are .. but they want extensions here in Canada ?

Not too different we couldn't go anywhere on a tourist, work or student visa and expect citizenship

They were promised education, they got it. It's time to leave. The canadian government doesn't owe you anything aside from education. You have no right whatsoever to demand WP extensions or even canadian citizenship. Go home and prosper your land. Canada has its own problems to fix.

they will get citizenship you just follow thru ?

Ask about the Bangladeshis who want citizenship in India and keep moving into India illegally. They don't automatically get citizenship either.

Why do indians from india push their way in illegally in western countries. And demand that they have rights in our countries. Why do they think that a student visa's are a stepping stone to citizenship. India should take care of their own people. Like china. Your population is too big.

Go home guys, your parents are waiting! They will make sure you're fed and have a home on land they have rented or owned.\n\nThe answer is NO India will not allow a foreign to come and even buy land, getting a citizenship is a process and must be followed correctly.\n\nThis is disgusting what is happening. Surely sending them back is a great first step, but more must be done and laws must be corrected.

Who give them a permit to rally? What is the difference of aspiring citizenship in their country , and for them demanding citizenship in our country ?

Students are scamming their way here. Canadian citizenship is not their right. They need to leave and so does Trudeau.

What’s going on in Canada? Foreigners come here to demand citizenship and financial help. Enough of the leeches! Pro Hamas supporters demand financial assistance for Palestinians, demand to stop businesses with Israel. Why are these criminals in Canada?

The former immigrants who have been here for several years are here and paid a lot of taxes... ESPECIALLY AS CANADA IS OVER TAXED! I understand that... but that they don't want Canadian citizenship, that's not understood . However, this does not make them traitors to their Nationality and does not prevent them from returning to their country one day..these are those who have just arrived or do not work and or cause problems. Who deserves to leave... the pro-W students... Who shouts racist and thief... it's obvious that they have only thought about their slogans or there are only a few of them who are trying to harm Our country

END BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP ‼️‼️

Will canda revoke the citizenship of students who cane to study and end up becoming cutizen of the country?

They are here for permanent citizenship not for study

NOT STUDENTS BUT THOSE WHO ARE LOOKING FOR CITIZENSHIP AND ESCAPING CORRUPTION AND POVERTY

Question remains unanswered why Canada (Trudeu ie) is keen to give citizenship to terrorists?. What would have happened if the FBI was not so lucky enough?....

Savage mentality and gutts to demand citizenship in foreign country on a temporary visa crazzzzzzzy?

Consequences of Trudeau Liberals broken Immigration. Some of them barely speak English and they want Citizenship

Legal and if arrested needs to be -deported, why not duel citizenship so rather then revoke citizenship, they can be sent back to their country if committing crime, For those entering and becoming citizens and need help there is plenty. Housing is an issue, Trudeau plans on 500 000 more immigrates, due to Unemployment being at 7 percent, Foreign Workers are less needed esp winter as most used are farmers, fishers, seasonal, The Health Care programs and refer a relatives or apply from a different country as a Health Care Worker are the current programs, Nurses, Doctors, Home Care workers, Nursing Home etc hosing will be what governmental lands bought and preference for 1st time owner including immigrants, no down payment, ability to enter USA legally later.

They should get full citizenship, free housing, free groceries, free everything. Ya right.

They can go to Afghanistan and Palestine for citizenships

Wow didn't know it was this easy to get Citizenship in Canada hummm don't my parents feel stupid they been in Canada 42yrs and follow A process ?

david nobody would want citizenship in india!!

How entitled can you be to protest and demand for citizenship stop draining our resources

CARGO SHIPS AND MASS DEPORTATIONS ARE NEEDED TO SAVE CANADA ALONG with REVOKING CITIZENSHIPS for all IMMIGRANTS THAT came to CANADA DURING TRUDEAU DICTATORSHIP years

In Europe , students may work only 20hrs and there is no chance to get citizenship over there, so students leave the country after completing their study.. which makes sense

You can't stay. It is quite simple. Go back home to your families. Apply for citizenship in a few or ten years

You SHOULD pay taxes while you are living here, that does not entitle you to citizenship.

It should be renamed to Indian students demanding free citizenship, I don’t see any other students other Indians. Why do they feel entitled?

C'mon David, you can't compare this encampment to freedom convoy thugs who honked all night in Ottawa, blocked roads, businesses closed down and couldn't operate, they blocked borders. US/Canada both suffered due to the blockade at Ambassador Bridge. As a long haul Trucker, I couldn't work and I was forced to stay home because of those Convoy thugs. Trudeau did the right thing about Convoy thugs. Yes, I agree, these low-class immigrants and international students shouldn't have been brought here in the first place. They shouldn't be allowed to get jobs here. They shouldn't be allowed to apply for citizenship. Canada needs to cut down on it's immigration. I don't think Poilievre will bring any revolutionary changes. I don't find Poilievre to be smart or intelligent. Poilievre is only good at whining and criticizing. Trudeau must go for all the bad policies and bad decisions he's made. I just wish we had someone like Trump here in Canada.

Are they protesting for education purposes, work purposes, or citizenship purposes?

That guy being interviewed does not understand the question, Such type of Inappropriate behavior should not be entertained, they should go and protest on the streets from where they have come. No one promised them Permanent Residency or Canadian Citizenship, they were here to study and if done with it go back home.

How is it different if a foreigner demands citizenship in India , obviously India would say get the f**k out.

IF THEY GIVE THEM CITIZENSHIP ! WE WILL VOTE THEM OUT & SEND THEM PACKING ALONG WITH THEIR CHERISHED MIGRANTS & LET THE MIGRANTS PAY THEIR SALARIES !!!!

Citizenship is a privilege, not a right. No one wants or needs entitled narcissists in their country.\n\nThese people are calling Canadians racist land stealers and then expect them to fight for their non existent right to stay in the country. \n\nBye bye?\nCanada won’t miss you!\n\nMaybe be thankful you were even allowed in the country for your studies. No, they aren’t thankful.

didn't anyone tell these students they need to pass the citizenship test from a 500-questionaire booklet in order to become a canadian? You gotta speak the language, understand the country's culture, history, geography etc, and while making and oath, swear that you respect the laws, the ppl. You have none of those. Go home!! The audacity to demand permanent resident or citizenship as an international student!

?????????Look, there are people 'gaming' the system, here in B.C. there are a bunch of Schools that nobody ever really attends, they are old storefronts downtown... the windows are covered with paper so you can't see inside. Conviently there are 'immigration lawyers' offices right next door. There are reports that 'students' are recruited in certain South Asian countries, put into debt to the tune of $180,000 with the promise of being able to get residency and eventually citizenship. They are then put to work, in local businesses to work off this debt. There is a reason every single small business in my town is owned by a certain Southern Asian position group..\n Every single one, every gas station (even the one on the native reserve) every single fast food restaurant and they only seem to employ people of a certain population group... in my day that was called racism, but today it is just motivated by greed and exploiting their own people, which they have a long history of in their own country?????????

Consider going to the US or Europe if you have Canadian Citizenship.

Not only immigration is high. There is no screening at all. Leads to literal ISIS getting PR and eventually citizenship.

I don't even need to watch the video to explain why Canadians hate Indians. Indians flooded our country with mostly unskilled people who don't integrate. People who don't understand deodorant and shit on beaches. People who rape women and beat each other up in the streets. People who don't know how to drive a car safely. People who will live 10 people in a bedroom so landlords can jack up rent prices. People who scam the immigration system and bribe their way into the country using LMIA. These people are essentially buying citizenship through a loophole while massively suppressing wages and taking jobs that Canadians should have.\n\nIf you're an Indian that came to Canada recently, I'm sorry but we don't like you. GO HOME.

No more dual citizenship.

What I find interesting is that one of isis's leader was caught having an Israeli citizenship and I wonder why Isis never attacked Israel?

He still qualifies for citizenship though don't worry

Why indians are desperate to leave indian citizenship and migrate to another country although there is no war no persecution but still they want to leave India its a very serious matter and india must think about it. It's spoiling the name of india

It's hard to believe that Canadian visas for seasonal crop pickers provide an expectation of permanent residence or citizenship? Provided the Government is not revoking or reneging on already granted granted visas for individuals then the proposed policy seems reasonable.

I got in Canada when I was 8 years old and obtained my citizenship. Trudeau is the Worst thing to ever happen to Canada and I say this as an Immigrant. Justin Trudeau needs to get the fuck out. I work in the Health System and immigrants are overcrowding the system and carrying medical debts for medical conditions that lied dormant for years and expecting free services.

Our generosity is being taken advantage of. The ones on a temporary visa need to go back home no extentions or promises of citizenship! If they come here to learn then once tgey graduate time to go home. If they fail the at anytime go home.

there is only so many students per school for other countries so our own get a chance to go to school. but trulip has fixed this to buy votes by allowing foreigner to vote when they get here and not by the rules of citizenship. but that has ended now and so has trulip. cant house our own people time to close the boarder on immigration. I think 10 years of this in only a few years was a bit much.

When I was on a student visa to study nursing in the usa, I returned my student visa when I was done my studies and graduated. I didn't demand a job or an extension. I didnt do a path of citizenship on my student visa. Do it the correct way.

I came to Germany from the UK in 1991, and was already fluent in German. In those days the Ausländerbehörde was incredibly unfriendly and demanding. They have got better over the years but there is definitely different treatment of UK citizens people from other countries. When I applied for citizenship before Brexit, it only took a few months. Now although it is supposed to be a faster process, it takes more than a year to even get an appointment, which is completely ridiculous. The reason is the lack of personnel. I accompany foreigners to the Ausländerbehörde and there is definitely different treatment of non-eu foreigners although it depends on the individual person in charge there. Even the period of residency given can vary between applicants by 1 to 5 years, depending on who they see or which Ausländerbehörde. This seems very strange and unfair considering that an annual fee for a residency permit is around 100 euros and involves 2 visits (the foreigner has to take at least a 1/2 day off to attend the appointment).