Close Reading

I think it was on NBC where they interviewed an immigrant family who came here illegally, but were given citizenship under Reagans amnesty program. The whole family, parents and kids voted Trump and support his deportation policy. When ask they admitted they had several relatives in the states who are here illegally, but they dont think Trump will deport them because they work and are productive. ?

This is cruel and beyond that it's economically idiotic. Just wait until your grocery prices go through the roof. Farmers CANNOT find Americans to pick tomatoes, watermelons, etc. etc. American citizens just simply won't do the work.There are countless other industries that use undocumented workers. We are headed for a higher inflation again if this is implemented. How about immigration reform instead? How about work permits? How about paths to citizenship? We need the workers. Our legislators should do their job and come up with immigration reform rather than spend billions rounding up people and hamstringing our economy in the process. Maybe this move along with tariffs will help Americans realize that electing Trump was a mistake.

I am not democrat or republican I am an independent so I don’t have any loyalty to any party just the constitution. With that being said deporting citizens spouses is insane the people voted to secure the boarder and to stop incentivizing illegals to come in and giving them the people’s money with no contribution. What people didn’t vote for is denationalization and ending birthright citizenship. How you pro life and say you have to protect the unborn but also taking there constitutional birthrights away. Make it make sense??‍♂️??‍♂️

Remember, the stated plan is to ignore any birthright citizenship. So if you voted for the GOP and Trump and think because you were born in the US you aren’t getting deported…think again. All the latinos that voted for Trump have targets on their back for deportation….because they don’t consider you to be citizens. Karmas a b1tch ain’t it?

Elon Musk is an illegal. He lied on his petition to become as US citizen. Musk entered the country on a F-l student visa but did not attend college. On the admission for US citizenship a person is asked. Have you ever been in the US illegally. If he had answered the question truthfully he would have been denied his citizenship. A paper trail exist.

Trump will have a big talk with this fool. This is NOT Trumps plan AT ALL. Listen to Trumps speech after he won the election. He has been VERY clear on helping illegals without criminal records who want to work find a pathway to citizenship. This is in no way representative of Donald Trumps plan. Trump and most Americans want to deport the illegals with criminal records. Even if he tried there is no way to deport all illegals.

Key word she has green card!But did she get her citizenship!? Some of them are voting with the green card but are not eligible to vote until they get nationalized!

Take away all the free benefits, don't allow businesses to hire any of them, tell them all to leave on their own and apply the right way, the ones that don't leave they will be deported and never again have the option to apply for citizenship again

And they are gonna cancel Citizenship for many Naturalized Citizens too! Bye Bye✌?

You Latinos who voted for Trump and think your safe. Think again, just cause you were born here doesnt mean everyone in your family was and are here legally. Triump has already said he will strip your citizenship away and send you back with them.

Trump wants to get rid of birthright citizenship. You all think he's going to let you stay ???

Revoke her green card send her ass back to her country u may have citizenship but u are not a born ?? wow she’s had a heavy accent

? How do they actually determine illegals. Can they even create new documents to all citizens to prove their entitlement to citizenship! Could this even lead to you can't buy or sell unless your a certain type of citizen! Does this impose attack on all citizens with segregation?

We the people did NOT send a mandate to remove undocumented immigrants.\nFACTS MATTER\nExit polling shows that:\n55% wanted undocumented immigrants to have a path to citizenship\n36% want all undocumented immigrants removed immediately\nDONT TELL US WHAT WE SAID\nEven more to the point there are at least 335m Americans\n1/5 of them were able to and voted for trump, 1/5 of them voted for Harris, and 1/5 did not vote. The other 2/5th weren't eligible to vote\nIf you want to talk about a MANDATE tell us why trump got 2% fewer votes than he did in 2020\n20% of Americans do not a MORAL mandate form

Way too late you did that law in 1885 when it's not going to the United States and that become a citizenship before they came to the United States maybe they should interact with the capital punishment back then and we won't in the mess we are in today

People are gonna need clarification on the deportation of illegal Immigrants. Because she asked him specifically if legal immigrants will be included and he purposely did not answer. They want to revoke birthright citizenship. what's does this mean in very specific terms? you will deport anyone who was born in US to a country they never lived in before ? make it make sense!

Does this extend to people who came here legally, overstayed their visa, worked illegally, and then lied on their citizenship application?

get rid of birthright citizenship

People don't seem to understand that if you come into the country ILEGALLY (which is a crime), you will be deported. People who immigrate the right way, waiting for green cards and applying for citizenship, they will be fine.

No place for ILLEGAL and No more Illegal come to USA, please!!!\n\nIf you are in the US with a Valid Visa and comply with your Visa, then you are OK.\n\nIf you are a green card holder, then you are OK.\n\nOur family came here LEGALLY, from the front door, obeyed the law, paid taxes since the first year, never overstayed even 1 day!\n\nReceived our citizenship after 10 years!!!\n\nWhat makes others more special than us that they are allowed to cut lines?☝️ No No

People keep using fear mongering by talking about denaturalization and how it can strip your citizenship and depot you against your will. And while that may be true, that only applies to those who got their citizenship through naturalization....and there are many other ways to get a citizenship lol. Granted I don't agree with his massive deportation stance at all. I just also don't want everybody to freak out without knowing the facts. I saw U.S born citizens (I am speaking about other races that white people) freaking out that they may lose their citizenship ?. Which is hilarious, because you CAN NOT lose your citizenship if you were born here unless you decide yourself to get a citizenship in a different country lol. So to all the latino, asian, african american, indian, etc people that were BORN in the united states.....please stop freaking out. Denaturalization isn't going to affect you lol.

Immigration and citizenship is theft of sovereign right of people the only Americans . God makes an American a government of theives makes theives.

Yet he made it difficult to get citizenship for those who want it…but will deport them even while waiting for an approval. We have criminals here too. Stop using ‘immigration’ as a political stunt…these are innocent people. United States is built on immigration!\n\nWhy not help those countries who are suffering?, god knows we have a lot of money. Yet we will only help when they are in their own country, but be degraded if coming to the US!

? based on project 2025 Cubans Citizenship is going to be removed.

The second dude actually had a point. Nobody hates illegal immigrants more than legal immigrants. It's just painful that you were some kind of elites back in home country, went through a hell of a process and paper work to get yourself citizenship, and other under-educated can just come here legally, spend your tax money and get it? By the way, as someone may argue, they went through the documents, so they would not be deported by denaturalization.

we have a massive army just sitting there doing nothing. They, and all of their supporting equipment, are already paid for so declare Immigrants from 2020 through 2024 a national threat and produce the largest deportation of illegal immigrants. Once identified as such, there is no need for $10K in documenting any further, drive them to the border open the gate, push them through , close the gate. Once 8-10 Million have been deported, close the border completely and don't open it again until congress passes a comprehensive immigration plan to include visa overstays, path to citizenship, stronger penalties from illegal crossings, sponsorship programs and skills base requirements.

Trump might have latino shot like black people in a traffic stop! Welp, karma is a witch when police have immunity. What done don't realize is that trump own the supreme court and may get 2 more picks. He can literally have them side with him and they are all out! Citizenship can easily be revoked with the infrastructure he has and project 2025!

If they cross illegally then they have committed a crime , so turn them back , as they are now criminals and not qualified for citizenship!

They are all immigrants now blocking the paths to citizenship to others who they were once like. \nHUMANS ARE SELFISH ???

This is absolutely selfish af, I am an immigrant. I have my citizenship now. But hell, I would never, ever, take it for granted and block the others coming. There should be a way and a path for the other ones. Sensible immigration policy.

Well the best thing to do for those illegal immigrant to come to Canada would be they go to India, apply for a student visa, come to Canada, join the Khalistani gang, apply for ASYLUM ,get a citizenship of Canada and join one of the gangster either Lawrence Bisnoi or Goldie Bhel gang and become a local king pin.\n\nThis is a hand made strategy by Trudeau and Singh.

Yeah and yet they are about to be deported too and probably sent to Mexico because now the cops will get a greenlight to act as immigration agents and as always treat immigrants as animals, no documents to show, maybe show a fkn Star to represent citizenship or always have to carry your naturalization documents, or passpoets, but regardless even if you had them...they will still carry theirasses to Mexico. Because his idea is to rid of any non-white or anyone with none white sounding names. Chaos will ensue and their idea of family separation will be even crazier since they will end up separating real US citizens from their children and ship them out to another unknown to them country. Meanwhile their kids sent to either juvenile jails or adoption to possible child abusers or molesters or pedephiles....yay.....that is what you wanted...

Miami Cubans never came and waited their turn. They had immunity and were granted automatic citizenship. Obama ended that. They should have never been given special treatment. It screwed everyone else that waited their turn.

you are all crazy, of course the latinos that voted are already citizens. they don't like more latinos coming in bcoz they will also get affected. illegals did not vote for trump. the latinos with citizenship are the ones that voted to kick out their own bcoz they don't want more of them to steal their jobs.

Exit polls found that 55% of voters want a path to citizenship for all undocumented workers and only 36% want all undocumented immigrants to be deported en mass.\nDoes trump care? Probably not. He won't be able to use the Foreign Enemies act though, not even this extreme court of corrupt activist jesters will go along with that - would they?

I love how the people from immigrant families are like “f*ck everyone else” as soon as they get citizenship

My fellow whyte peeps, just remember the folk you brought with you on that damn boat. We should be good, right? Citizenship wise i mean.....i would never want anyone to think that y'all actually like us and whatnot. I wont say nothing, wink if we're good....

Latinos for Trump I hope you know that they want to end birthright citizenship! Start planning your trip back to your parent’s country.

The kind of deportation Trump has been talking about has gone beyond people that are here illegally. Trump has expanded it to include what he calls 'undocumented' migrants. That group includes people waiting for their asylum hearings, DACA recipients and protected status migrants/refugees, and people that have already had their asylum hearings, but are awaiting their citizenship hearings. \nAs for the narrative about 'murderers' and 'violent/horrible' criminals being in our country, it's like....wait...what??? Now, if you KNOW a person is a convicted murderer or horrible criminal, WHY would you allow them into or allow them to stay in this country to begin with? And, you'd kind of have to allow them to stay, otherwise, how the hell would you know how many of them are here?? Or who they are?? You can bet your butt that Pres. Biden didn't allow any people like this, that weren't in our prison system, yet 'known' to remain on US soil. That's not how it works! Not to mention, a large portion of the 13 to 15,000 number that Trump and the Right keep tossing out there, are from when Trump was in office! NOT during Pres. Biden's administration! \nIt's all been a lie manufactured for one purpose: to scare monger Trump's base. And it worked. Now Trump 'has a mandate' to put on an insane, cruel, probably hugely illegal 'show', of him rounding up large numbers of people and shipping them off to who the hell knows where..... whether they were here illegally or not. (he's already vowed to deport the 20,000 Haitians in Springfield, even tho they entered the country, LEGALLY, while TRUMP was president! HE is the one that signed their protected status into law!) Trump's deportation extravaganza is going to be ugly, brutal, bloody, grim and senselessly cruel, to a great many people that more likely than not, have no reason to be deported.

Anyone who is undocumented needs to be deported. But the Israeli lobby wants American citizens who criticize Israel to be stripped of their citizenship and deported as well. And Trump is not intelligent enough to understand how dangerous that is. If it does happen, all deported citizens need to be brought back as soon as trump's term ends and the israeli lobby investigated and put on trial.

So, can we rovoke Trumps citizenship and deport him to Scotland?

I have never been so happy to be a Ginger in all my life.\nRemember anyone with darker skin that birth certificates do not work at evidence of citizenship with this dude.

Pass a law that no immigrant can get citizenship,therefore can not vote.watch dem's become anti immigrant overnight.also let the ones here stay but they must live in a sanctuary state.then watch dem's scream deportation.dont believe me?call chicago,nyc,ect and ask them.the plan all along was flood red states with immigrants that vote blue.

We have tens of thousands of foreign nationals who have entered the country illegally. When these foreign nationals stepped across the border and violation of our immigration and border laws, they committed a crime. Their first violation was a misdemeanor. Their second violation was a felony. These individuals need to be held accountable for their lawless act. \n We heard Bernie and Kamala, and some other Democrats state that these foreign nationals need to be allowed a pathway to citizenship. I ask why? Perhaps if they leave the country and then they make application to re-enter the country they could be given consideration, but we should not reward people who violate our laws

The biggest thing is Joe Biden brought mixed racial and sexual couples to TV commercials. Under Trump, only straight white people will use fabric softener and you'll have to show proof of citizenship to buy window cleaner.

Note: If older Americans decide to move to Canada, and even take Canadian citizenship, they still get U.S. social security checks.

?Come on, they let in unvetted non English speaking strangers from war torn countries, with criminal histories. But, this law abiding, productive woman with speaks 2 languages is denied citizenship, shame on are government.??

She does not even realize that she could be one of the many people Trump sends the national guard and US military after bc they would question the authenticity of her citizenship. I bet if she were sent to one Trump's Nazi concentration camps, she'd be singing a whole new tune about Trump. This just blows my mind! She obviously didnt listen any of the times Trump said that ALL illegal immigrants are criminals from drug cartels, MS-13, rapists, murderers, from insane asylums, Venezuelan gang members, etc., I didn't hear her say that her family members were any of those things but Donald Trump did.

??? lady you'll be gone too as well as anyone who has “birthright” citizenship.

So, for decades they probably paid taxes, contributed to the economy, and stayed out of trouble, but instead of vying for a way to get their citizenship or even protect their descendants that were born here, so that they don't lose their parents... she's drunk the koolaid and has completely turned her back on their struggles. \n\nSome probably came to literally save their own lives or their children's lives. So, how could she be so willing to just support a man who thinks about her the same way as her family she'd let be deported?\n\nWhen your life is in danger, you're poor and living in a corrupt government that let's such bad things happen, you do what you have to for survival. \n\nYes, they need to work on becoming citizens, but to take all they know and built and toss them out with nothing and make them start all over again from zero is horrible for anyone, from any place..especially if they are elders now. Imo