Close Reading

Here is my opinion on this video.\n(First of all, I'm not Indian.)\n\n1. Who let them enter this country? Who approved their visas? What are the colleges, and universities issuing more and more study permits, and offer letters for one particular country? Who is taking the responsibility? \nNobody. \n\n2. Who let them build large temples, mosques and statues in this country? Who permitted to celebrate a mass rallying on public roads? Who is permitted to make a loud noise in a public place? \n\n3. Why are so-called Canadians (especially younger) not getting a higher education? Not willing to get a master's, or Ph.D.’s or even high school education. Why they are willing to get minimum-wage jobs? \n\n4. Why do these Canadians depend on social welfare system even if they can contribute their talent, and labour to this beautiful country? \n\n5. Why do we as a country face a lack of productivity issue rather than our south neighbour USA?\n\nI'm also an immigrant who came to this wonderful country (again I'm not Indian). But what I see, is nobody going to take responsibility for this social, economic and political issue. Liberals complain to conservatives, conservatives point to liberals and so on. But I would say both parties and Canadians let them play their games on this soil now they blame each other. \n\nOne last thing, I respect Canadian culture that’s why I'm in this country. If I can’t respect or adopt Canadian culture I won’t stay here and if I am in India I will respect their cultural values from my heart. If not I'm leaving.

That’s how gory treat cheep labour from India ????

Immigrants built this country form railroad useinf Japanese Chinese labour cux the ppl here did not want to do it so hey let’s bring everyone form gods knows where to work cuz most ppl born here only wanna cry on YouTube media abt this bunch fukin losers

Only reason we got immigrants like before is to fill labour force

This is the conservatives fault for importing cheap labour.

They literally have zero respect for Canada or Canadians, all they come to do is exploit the system as best they can, pinch every penny they can from their employees, ignore every labour law we have, and ruin our economy... Don't we have a housing crisis?? And we're still letting immigrants into Canada?? Close the doors already!!

That because government is paying 35 percent of wages cheap labour's and they all lazy and make pur labour's industry worse.

I feel for our brother. Guys stay in india , do labour work but stay in india and earn and live. There is no place better than our india. These ass licker people like this customer in abroad. They are so frustrated in thier life , dont have zest for working all they do is cry about how aisans are stealing jobs and they do this stuff like this in video to just letgo their frustration. As they know outsiders are afraid of getting kicked out.

As a Canadian - it's not just investment by outside or inside companies investing. A correction to 6:00, Canada also doesn't hire or pay it's citizens reasonably by intention. We're the smartest middle class on Earth, making things like Canada Arm 2, and researching things used by everyone in the world, but we're paid less. If you were to be hired, it would take 6 weeks to 2 year for a DEI driven, lazy HR employee who has no expertise in your skillset to evaluate you. You're intentionally drawn out to be desperate enough (financially) to accept a role that doesn't pay well. By accepting the role, you're accepting the terms that you make less and you pay less in taxes, which contributes to the evaluation that you're paid less. Canada also sells it's core assets to 3rd party international corporate entities. So we 'produce' nothing because it's designed to be a cheap labour US alternative.

Our Indians show same behaviour to our labour. we we go abroad we are learning the lessson.

Now u guys can feel the pain of racism , just thinking about the same for up-bihar labourers in other stat

Canadian immigration is a scam. It does no good for students or local Canadians. But colleges are making money and corporations are able to keep costs down with cheap foreign labour

True housing is horrible, labour and infrastructure shkrtsge, and less than 3% inflayion(the Inflstion Decline 2024 after the Inflationery Hikes in 2022-23 of 6-9% in Canada and the US to 3-3.6% in Fanada and the US in 2024).

Isn’t this like cheap labour? They get just by easing the visa restrictions and tier 2/3 Universities accepting students from 3rd world countries. Because of these students their economic surges too. ??

We are importing slave labour for our protected oligopolies, to depress wages especially at the low end. Come on! How many Uber drivers and fast food workers chasing useless fake diplomas does Canada really need? Factor in the disproportionate increased government spending and you can quickly see how we went from having among the richest middle class in the world only ten years ago to... today.

Canada was never like this ! It became after too many Indian students coming to canada and even they create a lot of mess here and people are fed up here because of high cost of living , labour jobs taken by them etc

People go abroad and work this... Its better to be a labour in our own nation rather than serving in other countries without respect

We must have immigration. We Canadians are too highly educated to want to do manual labour. We also do need immigration to prop up our pension plans, which will run out of funds in a few years. We are discriminatory with respect to professional immigrants. Shame.\n\nCovid caused a 2-year slowdown in construction, and in strong inflation. Trudeau is the mouthpiece for the technocrats who advise him on immigration, and the ability to match demand with supply. Immigration, healthcare, whatever-policy is not a one-man (king) decision. The liberals set the policy, not the quotas. As for housing, quotas were set and the liberals advised and provided confirmation.\n\nWith respect to housing, many contractors could not afford to build, given the almost doubling in the cost of raw materials. As well, infrastructure provided by cities, in some occasions, could not match the installation of sewers, water supplies, garbage disposal, etc.\n\nTrudeau is a convenient victim. And if you mean by Trudeau, that it is the Liberals in power, you must also include the NDP, who provided the support to keep the Liberals in power. The NDP have a large impact on the immigration decisions. Blame them as well.\n\nAnd if you think that Pierre P with the Conservative party can do better. Lets see how he does in his second term, if there is a second term.

Western countries are good to move only and only if you are well educated. Without education u are like a servant/ labour class in western countries.

It's the Liberal party that wants immigrants and especially from certain areas in the world. Liberals are gambling on importing cheap labour and compromised votes. Demographics already hit critical mass in major cities. Immigration is necessary as long as it's properly planned, balanced demographics and not politicized.

Justin Trudeau and His Liberal Must be Voted out of power ...What Labour shortage when we Canadians Cannot get jobs in this struggling economy ...many dont have money to pay rent ...Buy Groceries that they are going to Food Banks which are over loaded ...yet they keep on taking more and more immigrants each year and all these immigration lawyers make tons of money

Business board and policies are not sitting on one table it seems cheap foreign labour is the way since can't lower inflation

It's not the canadian population who ask for more and more immigrants, it's the globalist bussinessmen who want to maximize their profits with imported cheap labour.

We dont have cheap labour in anywhere except south asian countries.

The country doesn't want immigrants, it is the parasitic elites of developers, speculators, banks and cheap labour employers that need constant population growth. The real economy and land and the people are hurt by mass immigration.

Corporations get more money from cheap labour\nCorporations get more money from more people buying consumer products\nGovernment gets more tax income\n\nall for the price of everyone else other than those 2 interests getting a smaller piece of the pie

There is nothing wrong with immigration that either brings needed talent, finances, businesses or contributors into the country. What it doesn't need is untrained or older family settlement immigrants, uneducated labourers, international students, or refugees to be the majority of that immigration.

Canadians have to decide what they want to prioritize. We can keep education at its current level if we either pay more in taxes or allow the students in. Otherwise we have to start paying at minimum double what the current domestic price is. Same with our food. People are complaining that prices are too high, but prices need to get higher if we want to start employing Canadians on farms and in factories at livable wages. Canadians don't want to acknowledge that as messed up as it is right now, we need to pay substantially more for day to day for things we take for granted if we don't want to rely on the labour exploitations of immigrants and temp foreign workers.

No labour jobs in Canada pays you more than a $ 1000.00 a month. In that money you have to pay your rent, grocery and bills and in the end you're left with nothing forget savings I really don't know what these guys are talking about I'm here in Canada for 30 years and I have seen the life here.

Kuch bhi mat bola karo labour job mein kon two and half aur teen hazaar kamata hai Canada mein kuch bhi mat fekaa karo mujeh 30 saal ho gaye hai Canada mein aaj tak mein $ 1000.00 k upar nahi kamaya hai kisi bhi labour jobs mein.

Come to Canada, where housing, a necessity of life is left up to the captive free market. Where we sell our labour and resources to corporations that ship it all away, and send the profits back to foreign headquarters.

This country has never been good lived here for 38 years in small towns and the small towns are exsesivly criminal cult like and act like independent countries seperate from Canada I have had many family members die from lack of health care and I myself spent 6 years being sick with no diagnosis and malked and patronized the entire time took 5 years to find out I had a leasion in my stomach and almost 7 to find out I had a hiadious hurnea I was a happy home owner and was forced out of my house by fraud which I have proof of so one of the cool kids could have a house police in this country and you can just google the amount of times people have reported to police and nothing was done the biggest criminal organization is the police and just like they did to the Mofia made Reco laws they need to bring out new laws for charging corrupt criminal lazy incompatant police because there are millions of them out court systems are a joke I tried a civil prosecution against people who have committed crimes against me and was denied to go infront of a judge because I was part native and had proof of white crime I'm a 20 licensed mechanic and have to live in my car because I can't afford rent or a house have a 100 grand invested in tools and a tool box and have the choice to starve to death or live in my car and eat I hate living and working in this country as Canada has no work place standards and the labour board is corrupt and takes bribes instead of charging business owners example east way blew up killing six people in Ottawa nation's capital I had friends who worked for that companies and reported it it has hundreds of complaints to the labour board and nothing was done and six people died I have worked for two employers who have had death in the work place and almost died three times in the work place with proof one time I was struck in the head by a sledge hammer almost killing me another reason I hate working in this country is the monopoly it is employers pay and do the bare minimum example I produce 40 to 60 thousand dollars of work every two weeks out of Wich 20 to 30 thousand is profit for the owner I make not even two percent of that profit and all services in Canada are fake useless and a run by under educated lazy incompatant people go canada

High cost of living, insanely high taxe income and labour is expensive as well.

THIS COUNTRY HAS JOB SHORTAGE, FOOD PRICES ARE TOO HIGH, NO LABOUR SHORTAGE AT ALL. LOOK AT THE LINE-UP FOR ONE JOB.

In Australia 10-15 migrants are having to share a house, due to massive shortage of rental properties, they are nothing more then slave labour, to fill the underpaid underskilled jobs us Aussies refuse to do, its a giant scam, these migrants are being treated worse then dogs, I presume it's the same in Canada.

Cheap SoullessBugmen labour decrease quality live ???

The lie is there is no labour shortage, just employee replacement.

Canada no longer has Canadians just a country full of residents . Canada has turned into India . Most of the students aren’t here to study it’s just a way to get pr There is a job shortage not a labour shortage You have Indians. Every were in ever single business and most of the time you can’t understand them. There is a shortage of work know . Reckless mass immigration is to blame . Those students didn’t come here to study it’s just a way to get In to the country to WORK . The liberal government just wants votes that’s way they keep brining in so many people . We need change we need a new government liberals have messed Canada up conservatives will not be any better but what other options do we have weather liberal or conservative

Labour shortage and so when Artificial intelligence takes over where is everyone going then?

she is 100% right on all the points.. i went to canada and just returned in 3 months.. life is depressing there.. they are racist but they act sweet they want you to work as a labour there even doctors and engineers are working as taxi drivers and all the good positions are held by local canadians also they are hungry for your dollars

There’s no labour shortage but productivity shortage- because you keep immigration numbers high- they compete for low wage jobs- business owners do not need to invest in productivity measures

Cheap labour for Corporations and Tax Base

no labour shortage at all ,hard to land a job

You do not know shit mate. Young Canadians do not want to work. So we business got to find labour on students or refugees otherwise Canadians won’t have that Macas Hamburger done.

Why do we keep saying international students? Helping to mask the very clear disproportionate Indian cohort that has walked into this country for immigration purposes (not sure who decided it should essentially be all Indians, but I don't think it was the Canadian people). Let's stop being shy.\nAlso, a word of warning against Indians...once they get into low level management positions, guess who they hire at the exclusion of everyone else? That's right, other Indians.\n\nGood points on the 'labour shortage' and the connection between this mass immigration and GDP!

Just learn the millions were stuck in pakistam after it was made and while many moved to that side, those who stuck although it was their land were forced to live in an islamic republic, decades of religious persecution and no help from our side of government who promised transit either died, lived as bonded labour or were converted, raped and killed, this romantisation and fascination of no reason with pakistan is so stupid, there is no human connection and countless have died defending the land so people like us can live our full lives and this is not even emotional, it is logical and fact based. While people on their side keep calm and do nothing when their country sponsers terrorism. The far left leaning minds have always let the country down.

They won’t work physical labour… bring Mexicans over Indians

Labour shortage and so many people queuing up for 1 job. ?

it's not about the labour force for there is no labour to go around. so please show some decency and respect and stop regurgitating such garbage. rather, it is about bring in economic slaves...to have these get in debt by taking on loans they will never be able to repay. sadly but surely, that nation's only remaining productive industry is debt collection.

What they mean is cheap labour