Close Reading

I don’t know about rest of the world but in the US alone, 700,000 Indians entered the country either illegally or overstayed their US visa just last year alone. In Canada, some Indian international students were discovered to have forged their education documents and now have been deported. Temporary workers are demanding permanent residency after work visa extensions have been cancelled due to housing shortages & increasing unemployment rate. \n\nIndian people in general are good workers but these protest aren’t helping and demanding they be allowed to stay while their documents are forged is upsetting Canadians. It unfortunately grouping everyone together.

STAY HOME. THE WEST ALREADY TAKE TOO MANY OF YOU GUYS... YOU GUYS TURN BRAMPTON, CANADA INTO DELHI. POOPING ON THE BEACH, TRASHING THE STREET, CAR THIEVES, GANG RAPE, AND CRIME ALL OVER THE PLACE NO MORE

Thanks for your biased reporting. Do you have any idea how many Indians, mostly from Punjab, are illegally coming and staying in Western countries? I see it daily in Canada. This is why Indians visas are mostly rejected. Illegal immigration. Get your facts right

Mr. K.Mukherjee .BE (Germany ) (Canada) Thousands of Indian students went to Canada with a student visa, not for education but to find ways to stay and work.These Five Eyes countries are rejecting the visas at random.Don't try to blame ,rather try to teach these young people the basic moral education and polite behaviour to others and not to try from the back door.Without any legal Immigration papers ,there will be no survival in Canada.Try to bring back the respect from the others.Please don't repeat the fifth largest economy in the world over and over.This will not change a dime about the notion to the developed countries.

I am disappointed that Canada is not on this list. Stay home. We have enough!

They are not rejected for tourists they are going to EAU and Canada to work and stay and you know that...???

If they’re so valuable, why not stay back home and try to fix that nation? I’m sure Indian could use them more than Canada

I want to leave Canada. I'm staying long enough to take care of my parents, but I cannot see myself dying here.

You're better off staying in the U.S. I lived in Canada for years. Now in the States. The Canadian dollar is not nearly as strong as the American dollar. You can also forget about ever being a homeowner in Canada especially the major cities like Toronto you're looking at 1 million dollars for starter. Let's not forget the other hair raising cost of living. Healthcare is free in Canada but if you have a life threatening illness forget it. You can die waiting to get care!

Take the proper steps to stay in Canada.. rather than claim false asylum wasting taxpayers money.

F u Trudeau you creepy tradier stay out of canada you dont beling here anymore you failed your children and your wife and our country. Huge disgrace to our economy we need our workers from other countries and they need us and you are not a patron of our country. You don't understand the meaning of being free

They come to Canada to study and graduate, apply for permanent residency and work. They are not entitled for anything. If they we're told for some entitlement while staying in Canada studying, before leaving their country, well that's a scam and they've got scammed.

Homelessness in Canada and US is because of high property tax and because of very high inheritance tax. Indians would rather come back to India and live in their negligible property tax homes which they inherit from their parents without paying any tax on their inheritance than to stay homeless in Canada. Or homelessness is because of high price of land and redtapism in making a home for yourself in the west which is not the case in India.

I have been living in canada my whole life and worked my ass off to get into a really prestigious university program. Everyone I knew is looking to leave Canada, and mind you these are all HIGHLY skilled stem grads. I am included in that as well, I love Canada, but I am also an Indian, nobody sees the difference between me(someone who has been raised here) and someone fresh from India with no lack for the culture. (unless they hear my accent) I don't think staying is worth it. Probably looking to head to the states.

I'm in south Africa married with 4 kids I want to work and stay in Canada I have exp in retail , warehouse, construction and mortuary

Canada is very expensive and salary’s are really low better go to USA Ana pls stay there

I do not agree that these international students should stay here in Canada, they should be here to study and not for work. If they wanna be a permanent residents here, they should go back to their country and apply for a permanent resident. And if it all goes well, then they come here as a landed immigrants legally.

Student visa should never be a guarantee to stay forever without any obligation to integrate - then this is an invasion … we don’t want Canada to become India , Pakistan , Nigeria etc …

As a Canadian PR holder, the immigration system is broken. The fact that people who can't speak English, with criminal backgrounds and unqualified individuals can come in and stay while I had to wait 2 years for background checks and a 8.5 IELTS score, is insane. It shows that qualified workers aren't wanted but rather just get as many people from only one single country in the name of multiculturalism. Another thing which attracted me to Canada was the chance to experience different cultures but all I see are Indians and especially immigrants who don't want to integrate because Trudeau is happy with that and they bring their countries' domestic problems to Canada (read Gaza idiots and Khalistanis)

No more force just kick out these indians from Canada. As they call themselves better than Canada, why they wants to stay in Canada?????

If you love Canada and don't like what is happening, stay and help change it!

Mass migration to Canada will make its way to the US, stay out!

First, admit the fact that Canada owes foreign nationals no guarantees for a better life. Second, an attitude of humility had helped. Thirdly, if you are that bright, stay in India and contribute to your own country.

Tyler there are 600 mass shootings in the U.S each year which is almost 2 a day per average and while they do not all take place in schools, how many mass shootings are tolerable? As long as Americans like yourself dismiss all the data to the contrary the U.S will continue to have the tragedies it does, When you look up mass shootings which is where there are more than 2 victims per incident you'll find Canada doesn't even register in those statistics because where the U.S has 600 mass shootings a year Canada hasn't had 600 in its last 100 years. So that is why Canadians mention school shootings as a reason, because the potential is real for it to happen. It is preventable tragedy but Americans as a whole need to want that change, until it does the rest of the world will always bring up gun violence and school shootings when the U.S is in the discussion. The U.S is great but it could be better. Stay blessed ??

Just curious, does Canada consider melanin anemic people, flown in from European countries considered ‘illegal immigrants’? The U. S. has similar problems designating who does or doesn’t have illegal immigrant status which then determines who stays and who’s deported. ?

These are people ordered by Imgration Canada to leave Canada after failing the processes to stay in the country. That is 30000 people who should have been put on a plane and sent back to their country of origin. Law enforcement needs to be hired to find these people and put them on the plane. Another way to help this from happening in the future is through the laws. If you are here on a visa or temporary work permit, you must leave by the date on the permit or visa. Failure to do so will result in immediate deportation from Canada to your country of origin. It will also result in a permanent ban from for life from entry to Canada for any reason. If you have been found to enter Canada illegally for any reason. This will also be a permanent ban from entry to Canada in the future for any reason. The only way to extend a permit or visa is from outside of Canada, just like other countries require Canadians to do under their systems. There has to be a reason for people to follow the rules, and that is the permanent ban and immediate deportation upon failure to follow the rules. Another thing is an person needs to have paperwork to get on an international aircraft going to another country. So why do these people arrive in Canada and now have no paperwork. They must show that paperwork to CBSA or face immediate deportation and a lifetime ban from entering Canada for any reason. People who have followed the rules are fully welcomed to Canada. They should show they are entitled to be here and not break major laws of Canada. If you fail and are convinced of breaking major Canadian laws. You will be immediately deported from Canada with a lifetime ban from entry to Canada in the future. These are rules and laws used internationally by other countries, so nothing is new...

I trained Indians for two years as my company outsourced my job. I loved the manager I worked with. He and his wife eventually immigrated to Canada. And I am happy for them. However, it's become out of control. Some part of me wishes they would stay in India and clean it up because India is a mess.

India still is a sh**hole country with inequality much worse than at the time of the British Empire. \nCanada presents an illusion of utopia when in reality it's an unaffordable frozen wasteland with miserable people. \nImmigrants that Canada wants to keep, those with high income and pay the most taxes are the least likely to continue to stay here while the already wretched in India do find Canada to provide a marginal improvement to their lives leading to resentment from the local populace who blame all their problems on Indians.

Canada needs to do like:\nAustralia (after graduating, go home, strictly no staying!!) or Germany (after graduating, go home with government gave plane tickets money) !!!!!\nPS: take care of your Canada citizens first!!!!

NO, they don't get to stay in Canada, they aren't Canadians, they are foreign nationals. Once you've graduated you can apply to become a legal immigrant to Canada, otherwise you get on a plane and go back to your homeland.

Turn around.!!!.. we don't want you in Canada.!!!!.. go back to your own country and stay out of ours...!!!!.

Nova Scotia proud b'ye. Not a chance in hell I would move, or even visit, the US. You realize most of the world dislikes you guys. You are so very sheltered and shove this ideology that you guys are number 1 in everything down the worlds throat. Arrogant and condescending. Canada has its problems, trudeau, but I'll stay right here. If I would move outside Canada it would be Hungary or Poland.

Canada is full liberals causes this bull ? these fake students LIMA scammers get out of here asap conservatives are going to clean house stay tooned 2025 ❤❤??

the people who are leaving should leave immediately Canada has no jobs no affordable housing and offers nothing and I am saying confidently zero zilch even in bigger urban center's like gta and forget about it completely in other areas outside like n.b pei zero acceptance and zero jobs only white people who are increasingly weary of Indians bringing their filthy culture of strong smells and questionable hygiene to the country stay out for ever no one is waiting with open arms crack down should be like how trump has promised for u.s

As a Russian Canadian, born in Canada anyone anyone from any country that comes here under the pretense of fleeing oppression should be happy to live in Canada ?? and stay out of international politics for life. Political agitators bring problems for Canada.

Its sour grapes, Indians have been going to Canada for 100 years, granted some cities are expensive, but hard work has never hurt, most of what is being shown applies in the USA as well. \nMost Indians do not live on the streets where drug addicts live, the video simply gives a impression that Canada is bad, well just dont come, stay in India and stop complaining, all Indians want the might Power Passports, and Canada has that, so nothing is going to stop the smart Desi.

I came to Saskatchewan Canada as an international student in fall 2023. I did a care assistant program and was attracted to coming to Canada because I kept hearing that there is a labour shortage in healthcare in Canada. However I feel like everything just started going to sh*t in 2024 when I was finishing up my program ?.\n\n One of the things I'd like to highlight about the small towns is that they can be very biased in their hiring practices. Some of us as (black) students had a hard time getting jobs in healthcare in the town because jobs were given based on family and friend linkages (so mostly white or Filipino people got hired). Also there was a severe housing shortage. So even though locals (from my perception) wanted us to stay and work in healthcare (because they are short staffed), realistically there was no where to stay. Canada can't say it wants people in more rural areas and not improve housing in those areas as well. I have honestly been rather disappointed with Canada because I expected better planning from a developed country.

why these Indians cannot stay back in India \nwhy are they flooding US/ Canada , what are they looking for \nand when they move they doing this illegally giving India a bad name in the comity of nations\nis condition in india so deplorable that they have to move illegally to the west

If Pierre gets elected, I don't see Canada having a problem with this. If liberals got their heads out of their asses, it won't be a problem either. If Trudeau has any hope of staying in power, he has to give in. Otherwise he is burnt toast.

Stop with the crocodile tears, student can go back home and cry. Most were not Studying here as they were working FULL TIME JOBS which essentially means they lied on their applications. Now they trying to use other tricks to fraud the Canadian Government to extend their stay in Canada.

No, absolutely NOT! Why is it when people come to canada to learn, they think it automatically gives them a free pass to stay in canada. Take your education and go home. We are overpopulated with east Indians now. There are no jobs as it is for born and raised Canadians.\nSo send them home.

Good that Canada is sending all indian assholes back to india because they don't deserve to stay in canada. Next turn is coming from America too.. where indians go they turned that country in to hell.

Yah I agree 101% that Canada Immigration laws are too lax. When you stayed in Canada 14 days illegally or lost your status inside Canadian soil you can claim Asylum status in Canada. K

Canada need immigrants and Refugees with out them Canada cannot Survive becoz Canadians don't get marry and make kids canada need workers in thier Factories McDonald's pluner welders thats the problems folks you make enough kids lady stay home make 3 or 4 kids thats the solution ?

Canada just lets in anyone in. There is no immigration laws lol. Its just an Indian village now. We need extensive deportations in order to make sure Canada stays Canada.

Stay in India please. Better your own dirty country. Canada was good before the third world was allowed to enter. They have dragged the country down to there third world level. Stop educating the world Western countries. Educate your own. Keep the advantage we had. Watch the stupid ignorant get triggered. You will see who they are in the comments.

I was born and raised in Canada and last august I left to move to the Czech Republic. If you’ve ever been there you’ll know it’s not the cheapest country and I live in the most expensive city. I still am able to afford to live off my not so high salary of an English teacher. I wouldn’t be able to afford living away from my parents in Canada, I’m not saying it’s been easy or cheap, I have 6 roommates and my rent is over 50% of my monthly salary. I had to take out a loan from my parents to afford all the visa fees and hidden costs of moving to another country. However if I had stayed in Canada I would have been earning less because I couldn’t find a job in my field. I am filled with rage about the governments decisions to mess up the country like they have. And yes we have an immigration problem but they are not the problem, it’s the government. My mother was an immigrant to Canada, and yes she’s doing okay right now but things have changed a lot since she immigrated and how Canada is now.

As an Indian, I am aware of the many scams people are involved in just to stay in Canada. One of my acquaintances went to Canada with their family on an Express Entry PR. They are working full-time for cash while also claiming unemployment benefits from the Canadian government. I wonder what action the Canadian government would take against such scams. I hope my comment reaches someone responsible.

Indians should stay in India not Canada.

If you guys have no any interest in following the rules, integrate into both society and culture of the host country, then you should better stay in India and fight for it if it really is the greatest country in the world as you say. Many people's getting sick of your overpopulation issue, which you are supposed to solve, not the US, Canada or Australia. Don't make things more difficult, learn some manners and DON'T bring your problem to us, please.